CNS News by Terence P. Jeffrey
Americans on average spent more on taxes in 2018 than they did on the basic necessities of food, clothing and health care combined, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey.
The surveys recently published Table R-1 for 2018 lists the average detailed expenditures of what the BLS calls consumer units.
Consumer units, says BLS, include families, single persons living alone or sharing a household with others but who are financially independent, or two or more persons living together who share major expenses.
In 2018, according to Table R-1, American consumer units spent an average of $9,031.93 on federal income taxes; $5,023.73 on Social Security taxes (which the table calls deductions); $2,284.62 on state and local income taxes; $2,199.80 on property taxes; and $77.85 on what BLS calls other taxes.
The combined payments the average American consumer unit made for these five categories of taxes was $18,617.93.
At the same time the average American consumer unit was paying these taxes, it was spending $7,923.19 on food; $4,968.44 on health care; and $1,866.48 on apparel and services.
These combined expenditures equaled $14,758.11.
So, the $14,758.11 that the average American consumer unit paid for food, clothing and health care was $3,859.82 less than the $18,617.93 it paid in federal, state and local income taxes, property taxes, Social Security taxes and other taxes.
I asked the BLS to confirm these numbers, which it did while noting that the Pensions and Social Security section of its Table R-1 included four other types of payments (that many people are not required to make or that do not go to the government) in addition to the average of $5,023.73 in Social Security taxes that 77.21% of respondents reported paying.
You asked us to verify the amounts for the total taxes and expenditures on food, apparel/services, and healthcare, said BLS. Based on table R-1 for 2018, your definition for food, apparel, and healthcare matches the BLS definition and the total dollars. Your dollar amounts for federal, state, and local income taxes and for property taxes are correct, as is the amount for Social Security deductions. For the combined pension amount [$6,830.71] that we publish however, in addition to the $5,023.73 for Social Security, there is an additional amount for government retirement deductions [$135.11], railroad retirement deductions [$2.85], private pension deductions [$608.22], and non-payroll deposits for pensions [$1,060.79].
That Americans are forced to pay more for government than they pay for food, clothing and health care combined has become an enduring fact of life.
A review of the BLS Table R-1s for the last six years on record shows that in every one of those years, the average American consumer unit paid more in taxes than it paid for food, clothing and health care combined.
In 2013, the average American consumer unit paid a combined $13,327.22 for the same five categories of taxes cited above for 2018, while paying a combined $11,836.80 for food, clothing and health care.
In 2014, the average American consumer unit paid $14,664.13 for those same taxes and $12,834.34 for those same necessities.
In 2015, it was $15,548.36 versus $13,210.83. In 2016, it was $17,153.30 versus $13,617.60. And, in 2017, it was $16,750.20 versus $14,489.54.
Even when all the numbers for the last six years are converted into constant December 2018 dollars (using the BLS inflation calculator), the largest annual margin between the amount paid in taxes and the amount paid for food, clothing and health care was last years $3,859.82.
The margin was so great last year that you can add the $3,225.55 Table R-1 says the average consumer unit paid for entertainment to the $14,758.11 it paid for food, clothing and health care, and the combined $17,983.66 is still less than the $18,617.93 it paid for the five categories of taxes.
You get a similar result if you add the combined $2,903.50 that the average consumer unit paid in 2018 for electricity ($1,496.14) and telephone services ($1,407.36).
Yes, Americans on average paid more in taxes last year than they paid for food, clothing, health care, electricity and telephone services combined.
Was the government you got worth it?
(Terence P. Jeffrey is the editor in chief of CNSNews.com.)
#1: Gatlin To: Deckard (#0)
So what?No one ever said that living in the best country on earth would be the cheapest did they?
You get what you pay for
Let me share with you the best things about living in America,
OK, I'm going to limit myself to just ten items, because I really could go on for a while about my beloved country
Yes, Americans on average paid more in taxes last year than they paid for food, clothing, health care, electricity and telephone services combined.The correct question to ask is: Were the benefits your received from paying taxes worth you living in the greatest county on earth?
Should you think they were not, Deckard Then pease permit me to list 10 countries you can move to.
Salute,
Gatlin
Gatlin posted on 2019-10-03 03:20:48 Reply Private Reply
#2: A K A Stone To: Gatlin (#1)
Dumbest comment ive ever seen you post.
A K A Stone posted on 2019-10-03 07:28:06 Reply Private Reply
#3: Gatlin To: A K A Stone (#2)
I must leave for now.You have a great day.
Later
Salute,
Gatlin
Gatlin posted on 2019-10-03 09:23:52 Reply Private Reply
#4: Deckard To: A K A Stone (#2)
I think what he's saying is that he's rich, loves paying taxes and doesn't really give a shit about Joe Six-Pack working two jobs trying to get by, who pays more to the IRS and other goob agencies than he is "allowed" to keep.
Let's see how Gatlin feels when the stock market goes in the shitter.
Deckard posted on 2019-10-03 09:38:48 Reply Private Reply
#5: misterwhite To: Deckard (#0)
Sure. To pay for the food, clothing and health care of the moochers, scammers, and illegals.
misterwhite posted on 2019-10-03 10:08:15 Reply Private Reply
#6: A K A Stone To: misterwhite (#5)
Gatlin is ok with that. I think he said that is why America is great or something like that.
A K A Stone posted on 2019-10-03 10:13:19 Reply Private Reply
#7: misterwhite To: A K A Stone (#6)
Sure. Helping others is great as long as you're not $22 trillion in debt already.
misterwhite posted on 2019-10-03 10:18:36 Reply Private Reply
#8: Deckard To: A K A Stone (#6)
He likely thinks that America is great because of people like him, the ones who always follow the rules and snitch on their neighbors.
America is great because of people who happily pay their taxes, never complain about or criticize anything the government does.
Deckard posted on 2019-10-03 10:30:05 Reply Private Reply
#9: Gatlin To: Deckard (#8)
You always have lots of problems with America.Do you also have as many problems in all walks of your life?
Or do you just find that griping about everything is therapeutic for you?
Salute,
Gatlin
Gatlin posted on 2019-10-03 10:40:05 Reply Private Reply
#10: Gatlin To: misterwhite. A K A Stone, Deckard (#7)
Which I might add, does see to be working on some feeble-minded folks, as expected.
We pay more in taxes that we pay for lots of things in America. I can make up a list of many things to prove that. But of course, if I select certain things to show that then it will be more effective propaganda.
I say so what because I simply cannot see the catastrophic effect to show that the sky is falling on America when the total US tax revenue is barely equaled to 26 percent of gross domestic product and definitely well below the 33 percent weighted average for developed countries.
https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing- book/how-do-us-taxes-compare-internationally
I do agree entirely with your point, which I see to be thats it not really that the taxes are collected but how the money is spent in many cases. That definitely needs to be worked on.
I have no problem with my taxes since Trump Gave Americans a Massive Tax Cut. But I will be happy to take time an read about reports from those who have a great personal problem.
Salute,
Gatlin
Gatlin posted on 2019-10-03 11:11:57 Reply Private Reply
#11: Gatlin To: Deckard, A K A Stone (#8)
You repeatedly find yourself attempting to tell everyone what I think All the while never asking me to tell you exactly what I am thinking.
Here is a 30sec Tip: Dont Try to Read Other Peoples Minds.
Salute,
Gatlin
Gatlin posted on 2019-10-03 11:21:37 Reply Private Reply
#12: Gatlin To: A K A Stone, Deckard, misgterwhite (#2)
Probably on par with the one you made where you said that as a contractorm ut us wgeb an elderly citizen who has little money to spend tellq youL I am old and on a fixed income you AUTOMATICALLY increase you estimate to him, or her.
Right?
But back to the discussion at hand.
I ask: Do you find your tax rate too high and if so, why?
Salute,
Gatlin
Gatlin posted on 2019-10-03 11:35:21 Reply Private Reply
#13: Deckard To: A K A Stone (#12)
The grammar and spelling queen of LF posted this?
Day drinking perhaps
Deckard posted on 2019-10-03 11:40:36 Reply Private Reply
#14: Gatlin To: Deckard, A K A Stone (#13)
Here, let me repost it for you since you seem so interested in making sure everyone understands how Stone takes advantage of old people.
I will guess that your buddy Stone really appreciated you calling attention to that and having it reposted.I know that I appreciated it.
Thanks
Salute,
Gatlin
Gatlin posted on 2019-10-04 06:29:45 Reply Private Reply
#15: A K A Stone To: Gatlin (#14)
When someone tells me give me a discount i'm on a fixed income. If I think they are lying I make sure they are on the high end of an estimate. Or if they have a liberal bumper sticker. If it is some old lady and she doesn't ask for a discount and I can tell she doesn't have much money. I will keep her price at the low end of the spectrum. Yep it's true.
I also always do a little more than what was agreed to.
A K A Stone posted on 2019-10-04 06:44:39 Reply Private Reply