Plano, TX Alfred Pick served his country honorably. After going on over 100 combat missions in Vietnam, Pick was given the militarys third highest honor, the Silver Star. He was also captured and did time as a POW. Now, after escaping a cage in Vietnam 40 years ago, the country he laid down his life for is throwing him back in a cageover a decades-old gun.
At a gun show 40 years ago, Pick bought the rare M-14 rifle, similar to the one he used in Vietnam while he served in the Army. He put this rifle in a case, along with 14 other extremely rare guns and proudly displayed them in his Texas home for four decades.
This gun was very rare at that time it was rare to see one so he instantly had a connection to it, said Picks attorney Ryne Sandel. Over the course of his life he and his wife and collected about 14 weapons, many of them were collectors items.
As CBS DFW reports, Pick lived in Planos Air Park neighborhood along with other pilots who enjoy a runway right outside their homes. The 70-year-old Vietnam veteran even served as the president of his homeowners association. Thus, when the ATF raided his home last year it came as a shock to friends like Mark Shackelford.
Hes always been a good person to me, Shackelford said.
When federal agents raided this American Heros home, they were looking for and seized the rare M-14 rifle that pick bought in the early 80s at a Fort Worth gun show.
He was a gun collector and it was probably the piece de resistance of his collection he had shown it to me. Ive never seen it taken it out of the case, said Shackelford.
Instead of simply telling Pick that his rifle was illegal and asking him to modify or remove the firing pin to make it inoperable, masked agents of the statearmed with automatic riflesransacked the recent widowers home, kidnapped, and caged him.
Because the raid and arrest came just two weeks after his wife died of cancer, agents also found her cannabis that she used as medicine. This was tacked on as another charge.
This week, for having a rifle similar to the one he actually defended your freedoms with in Vietnam, Pick was sentenced to 87 months in prison by a judge. This, after hed already spent the last year in a cage.
Hes a really remarkable man to be honest, said Sandel. I do think its unfortunate for a gentleman like Alfred thats had such an outstanding life to have it mired at the age of 70 by this federal felony.
In the land of the free, you can be issued a rifle to kill people in foreign countries at the direction of American politicians. However, if you come home and purchase this same gun to display to your friends and family, you will be sentenced to die in prison. And we still have the audacity to call this freedom.
The man is a Silver Star winner, he saved lives, he took care of his wife, hes been in custody for a year, I would think that when a man turned 70 and is an American hero you dont destroy the rest of his life for one mistake, said Shackelford.
#1: misterwhite To: Deckard (#0)
More correctly, "At a gun show 40 years ago, Pick bought a full-auto M-14 rifle with the serial number filed off".
Not that the freethoughtproject would ever tell you.
misterwhite posted on 2018-10-19 12:35:25 Reply Private Reply
#2: Stoner To: Deckard (#0)
I would bet dollars to doughnuts that the rifle ended up in some ATF agents collection, or will remain in some PD's evidence locker. To be forever enjoyed by the agents, or local cops.
Stoner posted on 2018-10-19 13:28:59 Reply Private Reply
#3: VxH To: misterwhite (#1)
SMH.
Details details.
None of my flamingos have serial numbers either, BTW!
VxH posted on 2018-10-19 14:05:49 Reply Private Reply
#4: misterwhite To: VxH (#3)
Yeah, but are they full-auto flamingos?
misterwhite posted on 2018-10-19 14:16:54 Reply Private Reply
#5: Justified To: misterwhite, Deckard (#1)
Yes he should have known better.
Putting him in jail is a waste all the way around. Take the weapon and fine him some reasonable amount and be done with it.
Freethought plays fast with the facts. Not a very reliable source IMHO.
Justified posted on 2018-10-19 17:47:56 Reply Private Reply
#6: nolu chan To: Deckard, misterwhite, Stoner, A K A Stone (#0)
https://dfw.cbslocal.com/2018/10/17/decorated-vietnam-veteran-pow-sentenced-to-7-years-for-mistake-made-decades-ago/
- - - - - - - - - -
https://www.glocktalk.com/threads/vietnam-war-hero-sentenced-to-7-years-for-decades-old-rifle-purchase.1728060/page-9#post-26104352
- - - - - - - - - -
https://www.dallasnews.com/news/guns/2018/10/17/american-hero-plano-sentenced-7-years-decades-old-rifle-purchase
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-19 18:42:46 Reply Private Reply
#7: nolu chan To: Deckard, misterwhite, Stoner (#0)
https://www.redcatcher.org/activek/roster.asp?sSearchName=&sSort=&sLetter=&showphotos=0&filter-sUnit=2nd+Battalion+3rd+Infantry&itemstart=401&itemsperpage=20&itemsort=
Redcatcher
199th Light Infantry Brigade
Viet Nam 1966-1970
199th LIB Association, Inc.
AKA Redcatcher Association
199th Infantry Brigade (Separate) (Light)
Member Directory
Filtered for 199th Infantry Brigade, 3d Infantry Regiment, 2d Battalion
Page 21, listing 401-420
There is no listing for Pick between Phillips and Pico.
- - - - - - - - - -
https://www.linkedin.com/in/alfred-pick-7709841
LinkedIn is not an official source. It is an individual's brag sheet.
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-19 18:47:05 Reply Private Reply
#8: nolu chan To: Deckard, misterwhite, Stoner (#0)
http://www.dpaa.mil/Our-Missing/Vietnam-War/Vietnam-War-POW-MIA-List/
http://www.dpaa.mil/portals/85/Documents/VietnamAccounting/pmsea_acc_p_name_20181019.pdf
No Alfred Pick, or anyone named Pick, is listed. DPAA is an official military source.
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-19 18:49:00 Reply Private Reply
#9: GrandIsland To: nolu chan (#7)
GrandIsland posted on 2018-10-19 20:50:53 Reply Private Reply
#10: Fred Mertz To: nolu chan (#8)
I appreciate your due diligence.
Fred Mertz posted on 2018-10-19 21:17:41 Reply Private Reply
#11: BorisY To: Deckard (#0)
Reminds me of
Vermin howell / david koresh
MenTal hisTory lock up case
Love
boris
BorisY posted on 2018-10-20 00:11:57 Reply Private Reply
#12: VxH To: misterwhite (#4)
Only if they get fed habanero peppers for breakfast.
VxH posted on 2018-10-20 10:11:09 Reply Private Reply
#13: misterwhite To: nolu chan (#6)
misterwhite posted on 2018-10-20 10:22:33 Reply Private Reply
#14: nolu chan To: Fred Mertz, misterwhite, Boris Y, GrandIsland (#10)
https://www.dallasnews.com/news/guns/2018/10/17/american-hero-plano-sentenced-7-years-decades-old-rifle-purchase
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-20 15:23:58 Reply Private Reply
#15: nolu chan To: Fred Mertz, misterwhite, Boris Y, GrandIsland (#10)
Thank you.
Pick's purported Silver Star citation states it is for action of 14 May 1968 by "Second Lieutenant (Field Artillery) Alfred Pick (ASN: 0-5428223), United States Army...." The purported citation is not from the National Personnel Records Center (NPRC) in St. Louis (Overland) MO, but attributed to some file in the National Archives in College Park, MD as published by an unofficial source. I believe this may well be another exploit of the July 12, 1973 fire at the NPRC in St. Louis which destroyed about 18 million Official Military Personnel Files (OMPF).
The claimed Army Service Number appears bogus for the Vietnam era. (Wikipedia/
NPRC states, "No duplicate copies of these records were ever maintained, nor were microfilm copies produced. Neither were any indexes created prior to the fire. In addition, millions of documents had been lent to the Department of Veterans Affairs before the fire occurred. Therefore, a complete listing of the records that were lost is not available. However, in the years following the fire, the NPRC collected numerous series of records (referred to as Auxiliary Records) that are used to reconstruct basic service information."
Pick's LinkIn page states, "On May 19, 1968, 19 year old Second Lieutenant Alfred Pick assigned as Forward Observer attached to infantry company with 199th Light Infantry Brigade...."
Pick's date of birth was April 27, 1948 in Oceanside, New York. By my reckoning, Pick turned 20 on April 27, 1968, and was 20 on May 19, 1968.
I was in the Navy. Correct me if I am wrong, but I believe you have stated you were in the Army back when. In your experience, did you ever come across a 19/20-year 2nd Louie in the Army? I never heard of a 19/20-year old Ensign in the Navy. It sort of presupposes that somebody got a college degree at 19 and quickly signed up for the Army.
Pick's LinkedIn page also claims an Air Medal for March 1969 (at 20 years old), "Awarded for over 100 aerial combat assaults and direction of numerous aerial attacks on enemy positions. Shot down during combat operations." This sort of presupposes Pick somehow went from a forward observer in the infantry to doing whatever he was doing 10 months later to be awarded an Air Medal for 100 aerial combat assaults. It does not state, but infers he was flying the plane.
Wikipedia says, "The medal is awarded to anyone who, while serving in any capacity in or with the Armed Forces of the United States, distinguishes himself or herself by meritorious achievement while participating in aerial flight."
I'm ex-Navy and don't know much about infantry or Army, but I just don't see how an infantryman would distinguish himself while participating in aerial flight. These two claims, when considered together, make no sense to me. Does it make sense to someone with Army experience?
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-20 15:25:30 Reply Private Reply
#16: sneakypete To: Deckard (#0)
Secondly,I would have to inspect it myself before I would agree it is even a selective-fire M-14,or the civilian semi-auto version known as the M-1A. Even if it is a M-14,it is not a full-auto weapon without the selective fire switch. Not all M-14'S were issued with selective-fire capabilities because most soldiers were teen age kids that had a tendency to hold the trigger back until it quit making loud noises,and if they hit anything at all,it was one of their fellow soldiers.
I was never in a conventional infantry unit in VN,but have been told by those who were that generally speaking,the platoon sgt would have one full-auto M-14 per squad,and that would be the most experienced soldier. Which follows along with how the old BAR the M-14 replaced was used.
Full-auto fire mostly wastes ammo and accomplishes nothing except for when you are using it to provide cover fire to keep the enemies heads down while your troops are advancing on them,or when the enemy is advancing on you and are very close. Even then the idea was to shoot short bursts. VERY easy to do with the old BAR because they had a "slow fire" and a "fast fire" selector switch,and on slow fire it was really easy to shoot 3 round bursts. Plus,as I wrote above,it was usually the most experienced soldier in the squad that got issued the BAR and they understood that a empty weapon was useless.
The thing is not many people these days know the difference between a M-14 and a M-1A,and this includes many BATF agents and local cops. The M-14 hasn't been a standard issue item since around 1969,so most people have never even seen one. Which means this USAF Pilot guy may have ACCIDENTALLY bought a M-14 with the selector switch on it and had no freaking idea it was an automatic rifle he was buying,or it could mean it's a M-1A and not an actual M-14 and the cops didn't know what the hell they were doing.
It's going to unnecessarily cost this sick old guy some money and more than a little embarrassment,but in the end the charges will be dropped even if it is a M-14 with the selector switch. After all,how many juries would be willing to convict him when it is obvious neither he nor the rifle was any danger to anyone,and it was an innocent misunderstanding?
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-20 16:21:04 Reply Private Reply
#17: sneakypete To: misterwhite (#1)
HorseHillary! You have watched too many movies. Since an actual M-14 can't be traced back to the seller anyhow,why the HELL would anybody bother to grind a serial number off of it?
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-20 16:23:11 Reply Private Reply
#18: sneakypete To: Stoner (#2)
That's not a bet I would take.
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-20 16:23:54 Reply Private Reply
#19: sneakypete To: nolu chan (#6)
It is usually both.
Pick was originally charged with 3 counts, including making a terrorist threat to the staff at a local hospital saying What happened in Las Vegas is nothing compared to what Im going to do to you people. This resulted in them raiding his home to search for weapons and finding cocaine, pot and an automatic rifle with the serial number filed off.
I would be willing to bet he filed the number off himself. Filing/grinding a serial number off a gun instantly decreases it's sales value by at least 90 percent. ANYBODY that buys a gun with the serial number removed is either clueless or a fool because you can never make the claim you didn't know the weapon was stolen. Not even if you were that ignorant. Nobody is going to believe it.
Al confided to another neighbor that he had stolen the automatic weapon during a target practice session, hiding it under some leaves and returning that night to the range to retrieve it.
Yeah,ask ANYBODY that has ever been in the military how likely that is to happen. You ain't seen people jump through their asses until you have seen a full-auto weapon disappear between the range and the arms room. On top of that,everyone that came to the range came there in possession of a weapon,and platoon sgts routinely check each weapon to make sure it is unloaded before they leave the range. If you are standing there and don't have a weapon to show before getting on the trucks,you are going to have some splainin to do.
After reading the update nolu chan posted,I have to change my opinion to "lock his crazy,evil,child-molesting ass UP!" This guy is not senile,he is just a liar and evil on top of it.
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-20 16:35:34 Reply Private Reply
#20: sneakypete To: VxH (#12)
They fire tracers after that?
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-20 16:38:42 Reply Private Reply
#21: sneakypete To: nolu chan (#15)
I can't speak for them,but I sure did. I was even offered the chance to be one myself,but turned it down.
I don't know about the other branches,but the army had a OCS program that would turn enlisted swine into officers and gentlemen in 90 days. Graduates would receive a RESERVE commission as a 2nd Lt in whatever career field they chose or the army chose upon successful completion of the program instead of the Regular Army Commission that West Point grads and people with battlefield commissions received. MOST that decided to stay in had that converted to a Regular Army Commission after being promoted to 0-3,but I never heard of one going higher than Full Bird. Not even ones that received battlefield commissions due to getting a Medal of Honor,like Ola Mize or Bob Howard. If you wanted a star,you had to be a ring-knocker.
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-20 16:48:35 Reply Private Reply
#22: nolu chan To: sneakypete, misterwhite (#17)
Because he did not buy it, he was the one who stole it from the military?
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-20 17:31:10 Reply Private Reply
#23: nolu chan To: sneakypete (#19)
Tks. Common sailors very rarely went to a range. SEALS and SeaBees would do that.
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-20 17:41:40 Reply Private Reply
#24: nolu chan To: sneakypete (#21)
The Navy had 90-day knife and fork school, but I never knew of a 19-year old going to it. Admittance direct from civilian life required a four year college degree.
Current Army requirements appear to require a 4-year college degree. In the Vietnam era, I am sure that was not the case. Then and now, the Navy LDO program allowed enlisted to become officers, but the time in grade E-6 requirement made doing it by age 19 impossible.
https://www.goarmy.com/careers-and-jobs/current-and-prior-service/advance-your-career/officer-candidate-school.html
Currently, the Army requirements include:
The Navy has a Limited Duty Officer (LDO) program that turns enlisted into officers, and does not require a 4-year college degree. The advancement path is capped at Captain (O-6). I had a good enlisted friend who asked me to assist with his LDO brag letter. I pulled an all nighter and wrote what proved to be a successful letter. Command suspected he got help from a Master Chief (E-9) and never found out I was the ghost writer. He retired at O-4.
Enlisted requirements for LDO include being E-6 with a year in grade. It is not possible to get it done by age 19.
https://www.public.navy.mil/bupers-npc/officer/communitymanagers/active/ldo_cwo/Pages/applicantinformation.aspx
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-20 18:28:33 Reply Private Reply
#25: sneakypete To: nolu chan (#22)
Maybe,but it seems unlikely. I am starting to doubt he was even in the military,and grinding away a serial number or being in possession of a modern weapon with no serial number is pretty much an admission of felony guilt x 2. The first felony when you stole it,and the second felony when you ground the serial number off of it.
You could probably keep a stolen M-14 in a rifle rack in your house for decades with nobody suspecting anything,but anybody that knows anything about guns will drop it like a hot potato the instant they see the serial numbers have been removed.
I have heard horror stories about conventional army units in VN being over ran at night because the asshole Regular Army commanders they had insisted on everyone's weapons but THEIRS and those on guard duty be locked up in arms rooms.
I personally know of one incident where a mortar round landed somewhere close enough you could hear it,and the alleged leadership of a conventional US Army support company went batshit crazy and insisted the arms bunker be opened and everyone issued M-14's and ammunition. I also know for a fact the company armorer (me) told them to kiss my ass because I wasn't issuing any weapons to anyone.
I arrived in VN with a pulled muscle in my lower back and a dislocated shoulder,so I couldn't keep my SF assignment because I was physically unable to run missions. Because of this I was sent to a straight leg signal battalion right there at Nha Trang to serve time until my profile expired,and I could go back to SF.
Since they didn't know what else to do with me,they made me the company armorer.
Their "plan" in case of attack was to have the troops fall out and run behind the sandbag walls alongside each barracks,and prepare to open fire on the attacking enemy. There were a couple of "slight" problems with this "plan".though. The prime one being these were people who hadn't fired or even handled a weapon since basic training were to be issued full-auto M-14's,and would have them resting on the top sand bags and facing the guys in the platoon next to them and MAYBE 30 feet away who were also resting their full-auto M-14's on the sandbags beside their barracks. If just ONE shot had been fired,they would have all opened up and shot each other to shreds. ONE VC running though the company area and firing ONE AK burst would have resulted in dozens of deaths and who knows how many injuries from wounds?
When the CO started bitching at me about refusing to issue weapons and ammo,I told him "Fine,do it,but at the court-martial I am going to tell them why I did it,and that YOU would have been responsible for all the resulting deaths and wounds." That shut him up.
Keep in mind this was a rear echelon signal battalion,not a infantry unit,though.
Once back in SF I could and did walk into the arms room and say stuff like "Gimme a silenced M3 greasegun and a case of frag grenades",and the supply sgt would just hand them over. Didn't even have to sign for them. The difference was we were all NCO's or officers,and we WERE a front line combat unit. We needed them or we wouldn't have asked for them. In a regular infantry unit with a small percentage of NCO's and officers,and 75 percent or more of the others being privates only a year or two in the army,the rules would have been stricter. For one thing,there was no danger of any of us getting drunk and shooting each other. It just didn't happen. Ever.
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-20 19:32:17 Reply Private Reply
#26: sneakypete To: nolu chan (#23)
They probably did like we did in SF. Not so formal. Everybody went to the arms room and checked out there weapons and ammo,and jumped into their cars and drove to the range. The highest ranking people there got stuck with being the range safety officers and NCO's. The rest of us would just blast away on full-auto to get it over with,get back in our cars,and go back to the arms room to turn them in after cleaning them.
It was a waste of time and ammo to require us to go to the range once a year to prove we knew how to shoot safely and that we could hit what we were aiming at,but the army required it.
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-20 19:38:17 Reply Private Reply
#27: sneakypete To: nolu chan (#24)
The minimum age in the army was 18 years old. No big deal since almost all of the graduates became Infantry Branch officers,and a 2nd Lt (0-1) is basically a highly paid Private with responsibilities in the infantry. They are adopted by the platoon sgts they work with,and that's who really runs the platoon and teaches the 0-1 the tricks of the trade.
There are no civilian occupations comparable to infantry platoon leader,so that's why that system works.
Admittance direct from civilian life required a four year college degree.
Ahhh,the army does that too,but ONLY in branches or occupations where specialized knowledge is required,like engineering,Military Police,etc,etc,etc. I had a cousin from NYC (I know,the shame,the shame!) enlist as a E-6 because he had a degree in physical education,and had tried out for the Olympics. His job was to teach physical education stuff at the base Special Services building to soldiers,their wives,and their children.
Lots of guys with technical or scientific degrees enlisted as 0-3's.
COMPLETELY different system than OCS,though.
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-20 19:47:48 Reply Private Reply
#28: Vicomte13 To: nolu chan (#24)
Vicomte13 posted on 2018-10-20 21:42:12 Reply Private Reply
#29: Vicomte13 To: All (#28)
Vicomte13 posted on 2018-10-20 21:45:10 Reply Private Reply
#30: nolu chan To: Vicomte13 (#29)
I just never met one who was 19 years old. Pick was supposedly an infantry 2LT awarded a Silver Star at 19, and 10 months or 300 days later had flown 100 air combat missions and was awarded an Air Medal.
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-21 01:36:50 Reply Private Reply
#31: Vicomte13 To: nolu chan (#30)
Vicomte13 posted on 2018-10-22 07:16:29 Reply Private Reply
#32: nolu chan To: Vicomte13 (#31)
It is a different world from the Navy, for sure. I served alongside Army types at a NATO command.
His claimed military history sounds lke a sea story to me, but lots a sources unquestioningly cite it or echo it as fact. His daughter and her husband reported him to authorities.
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-22 13:32:33 Reply Private Reply
#33: CZ82 To: sneakypete (#21)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_William_Vessey_Jr.
There are a few other Mustangs who made General but how they ended up there is sketchy especially when it comes to battlefield commissions.
CZ82 posted on 2018-10-22 15:05:52 Reply Private Reply
#34: Vicomte13 To: nolu chan (#32)
Vicomte13 posted on 2018-10-22 19:30:46 Reply Private Reply
#35: nolu chan To: Vicomte13 (#34)
Yes. USN, Ret., 20 years active duty.
nolu chan posted on 2018-10-22 19:57:16 Reply Private Reply
#36: Vicomte13 To: nolu chan (#35)
Officer or Enlisted?
LANT Fleet OR PAC Fleet?
Vicomte13 posted on 2018-10-22 21:00:27 Reply Private Reply
#37: sneakypete To: CZ82 (#33)
I never heard of this happening with anyone involved in special operations. Being a redleg meant he had the conventional brass on his side. I personally knew people who did a lot more than he did,and they retired as Full Birds after being promoted at their retirement parties.
Look at the careers of Robert Howard and Ola Mize,for two examples.
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-22 22:35:45 Reply Private Reply
#38: CZ82 To: sneakypete (#37)
Since SO/SF groups are small you wouldn't think there would be that many postings for a General to begin with. Besides doesn't the Army want their Generals to have experience with "the big picture" (experience in other areas/bigger units) before they are considered for promotion to that rank??
CZ82 posted on 2018-10-23 06:37:19 Reply Private Reply
#39: CZ82 To: sneakypete (#37)
Very impressive careers, Howard was nominated for the MOH three times before he received it.
CZ82 posted on 2018-10-23 06:39:22 Reply Private Reply
#40: sneakypete To: CZ82 (#38)
That used to be true. Back in the mid-60's there was only 1 General in the entire US Army,and he only had 1 star. You can't walk around Bragg now without tripping over them.
Besides doesn't the Army want their Generals to have experience with "the big picture" (experience in other areas/bigger units) before they are considered for promotion to that rank??
That used to be true,but these days it SEEMS like they want every ring-knocker that ever put in the time to graduate from West Point to wear a Green Beret. For 1 tour,anyway. Helps promotion.
I am convinced they want this more to destroy SF than to help it. I have seen conventional Lt or full Colonels come into SF with novice (5 jump) jumpwings straight out of the very,VERY special jump school the army runs for field grade officers,and take over a SF group. They stay there a year or two to fuck it up,and then move on to a Special Operations Joint Command to get another star or two.
Please do not misunderstand me. I do NOT ridicule technical branch officers that wear stars because they spent years serving in their technical fields,and deserve the stars. I have NO use for politically-connected losers that use the Old Boy West Point Protective Society to gain ranks and commands they are in NO respect qualified to hold.
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-23 19:55:18 Reply Private Reply
#41: sneakypete To: CZ82 (#39)
I know. He was serving as the 1st Sgt of Recon Company at Kontum while waiting to see if he was going to get it. Bob was the one that greeted me and gave me my initial briefing when I first got there.
Ola Mize was my Company Commander on Okinawa. He was also one of the nicest men you or anyone else could hope to meet. A true gentleman in the traditional meaning of the word. He just died a few years ago (so did Bob),and people like that are hard to replace.
BTW,I am not "putting on airs" or claiming some special spot because I call Robert Howard "Bob". Everybody that knew or served with him either called him Bob,or stayed the hell away from him. If you weren't on a first name basis with him when he was the first shirt at Recon Company,you would not be in Recon Company for very long.
I called Ola Mize "Sir" or "Colonel". (smile)
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-23 19:57:18 Reply Private Reply
#42: CZ82 To: sneakypete (#41)
I got the impression the first two were downgraded so as not to bring undue attention to the locations of his actions, which is a shame. If the man deserves it he deserves it, embarrassment to the government be damned. They would have made him the one and only triple award recipient if what I've read is correct.
CZ82 posted on 2018-10-24 06:57:14 Reply Private Reply
#43: CZ82 To: sneakypete (#41)
Not many guys like that left in this world and am not sure if they ever will be replaced. The world is a different place and has different values than when they were born/grew up, so it is not conducive to spawning guys like that.
CZ82 posted on 2018-10-24 07:05:45 Reply Private Reply
#44: sneakypete To: CZ82 (#42)
IIRC,we were pretty much told this could happen shortly after getting to SOG. Besides,you don't really have to be a genius to figure out you are NOT going to get the rewards of conventional soldiers when you are initially briefed and told you will turn in your Army ID card and dog tags before each mission,and will go into the jungle wearing sterile fatigues and carrying sterile weapons. Even our CAR-15's and M-16 were weapons that had been reported stolen from various armories.
On top of this add the normal confusion involved in a situation where you have a 6 man recon team or a Hatchet Force platoon in a running gun battle with sometimes hundreds of NVA regulars chasing after them,team members becoming separated due to laying behind to provide cover fire,getting wounded or killed,and sometimes the only survivors dying of wounds after being extracted and there was no one left alive or available to put anybody in for anything,and ALL valor awards require multiple eye witnesses. Even if common sense and experience tells you that a lone survivor pulled from a hole in the jungle that has been shot up and almost out of ammo had to do some pretty serious stuff to have survived long enough to get rescued,no witnesses to write him up means no valor award.
Then there are situations like at least one personnel clerk that served at Group Headquarters at Nha Trang admitted to years after the VN war ended. He said he was jealous of all the valor awards SOG guys were getting when he wasn't getting any,so every time he got a chance and figured he could get away with it due to whole teams being shot up and separated as they were sent off to various hospitals to recover or to the graveyard,and he just threw the documents into his trash can.
I personally received a valor award from the South Vietnamese government that I didn't even know I had been put in for,and got none of the US valor awards I was supposed to have received. The SVN government mailed it to me,and he never told me I got it. Which was common because fellow team members die,get transferred to stateside hospitals far away,and get discharged from the army without ever seeing or talking to their former teammates again. That's how the clerk got away with throwing award award citations.
Even IF everyone survives,there were only 3 Americans on a recon team. The rest of the team members were Montengyards or Vietnamese,and couldn't write you up for an award. Lose ONE American team member,and getting the regular army to approve a valor award is pretty damn tough,and the regular army regulations also applied to SF soldiers.
Most people didn't really seem to care. In my case,I was out of the army less than a year after getting med-evaced from VN,and army awards mean nothing once you are out of the army,so I didn't really care. Still don't care.
BTW,despite all of the above,I have read several places that MACV-SOG still received a higher percentage of valor awards than any other unit in the history of the US Army. There were probably less than 50 Americans (never counted,so am guessing) at the FOB where I was assigned,and I have stood in a Recon Company formation with 3 living Medal of Honor winners. Not many people can make that claim.
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-27 12:04:06 Reply Private Reply
#45: sneakypete To: CZ82 (#43)
There were never many guys like that alive in this world,yet each generation produces a few.
For all we know,each generation produces many heroes,both male and female,but most are never in a position to "rise to the surface" and become publicly known.
So they just become "everyday heroes",their sacrifices and dedication only known to the families they raised. I don't care who you are or what standards you put on the words "courage" and "hero",it takes courage to marry and have children,and take on that financial and emotional burden if you are not born to wealth or position,and then stick with it and do it RIGHT.
My hat is off to all of you who have done this,and done it right. Civilization would not exist without you.
sneakypete posted on 2018-10-27 12:16:17 Reply Private Reply