
Donald Trump backs off from his statement on torture and the military from Thursday nights Republican presidential debate.
From the Wall Street Journal:
Leading GOP presidential candidate Donald Trump said Friday he wouldnt order the U.S. military to break international laws, addressing criticism from military and legal experts that his policies regarding torture and killing the family members of terrorists would violate the Geneva Convention.
Mr. Trump, in a statement to The Wall Street Journal, said he would use every legal power that I have to stop these terrorist enemies. I do, however, understand that the United States is bound by laws and treaties and I will not order our military or other officials to violate those laws and will seek their advice on such matters. I will not order a military officer to disobey the law. It is clear that as president I will be bound by laws just like all Americans and I will meet those responsibilities.
This appears to be a reversal from Thursday nights GOP debate in Detroit, when Mr. Trump stood by earlier proposals to do things that were a hell of a lot worse than waterboarding terrorist suspects and also authorize the military to kill family members of terrorists.
Ive always been a leader, he said Thursday night. Ive never had any problem leading people. If I say do it, theyre going to do it. Thats what leadership is all about.
Read the rest of the story here.
#1: sneakypete To: cranky (#0)
That could be turned into a mantra or a tagline. If he doesn't drop out soon he's going to be having to say that a lot.
sneakypete posted on 2016-03-04 17:57:46 Reply Private Reply
#2: Pinguinite To: sneakypete (#1)
He's demonstrated no real resistance to reversing positions.
On the plus side, he doesn't deny it like any standard politician does. Rather he does openly and unapologetically.
Pinguinite posted on 2016-03-04 21:33:36 Reply Private Reply
#3: nativist nationalist To: cranky (#0)
Obama and McCain have been all about removing useful tyrants from power.
nativist nationalist posted on 2016-03-05 00:56:24 Reply Private Reply
#4: paraclete To: cranky (#0)
paraclete posted on 2016-03-05 04:27:32 Reply Private Reply
#5: Roscoe To: sneakypete (#1)
Roscoe posted on 2016-03-05 06:52:10 Reply Private Reply
#6: cranky To: paraclete (#4)
He might.
He's said an awful lot of things.
To paraphrase George Stephanopoulos, maybe Trump will keep all of the promises he intended to keep.
cranky posted on 2016-03-05 09:30:21 Reply Private Reply
#7: misterwhite To: Roscoe (#5)
Why, no.
But they're bound by the Geneva Convention just as we are. Well, aside from the beheadings, mass executions of civilians, suicide bombings, throwing people off high buildings and drowning people in cages.
misterwhite posted on 2016-03-05 10:33:56 Reply Private Reply
#8: Vicomte13 To: (#0)
So shortly thereafter words he says "Yesterday I said this, but I know that goes to far. So with reflection, here's what I really think."
Now, this is what we expect of spouses and friends, of children and teachers. We get pissed off, and rightly, when cops or school administrators or other officials take a strong, wrong position in the heat of the moment, and then refuse to back down.
So, here's Donald Trump being PERFECTLY SENSIBLE, a PERFECTLY NORMAL PERSON - yeah, I went too far, sorry, look, here's what I really think and would do.
And we've got the peanut gallery jumping all over him as a flip-flopper. What is it that you unappeasables want, precisely? That politicians say nothing, ever, unless they are prepared to never back down. The cop pulls you over for speeding. He sees your wife is having a baby. You want him to say "Fuck you, asshole, You were speeding. I pulled you over, and I'm not going to be reasonable" and then pepper spray everybody in the car and beat the hell out of you for good measure?
If you are perfect and never, ever, in your life, had to reverse yourself. never made a mistake - then you are a politician - that's the way they talk. And you're also a goddakned liar because no hiuman being exists who hasn't blown it.
Trump went too far with his torture 'em speech. He was fired up and angry at all of the prevaricating politicians and all of the poitical correctness. He went overboard -and then he thought about it overnight and pulled back.
This is GOOD.
If you think it shows that Trump is bad, weak, a flip-flopper, then you really do deserve to be pepper spratyed by the cop for speeding your wife to the hospital. You want public officials to never admit they're wrong, and never back down? Then you're an idiot, and you're going to get lied to all the time by politicians who never admit they were wrong.
That's what you want, that's what you get.
Trump is different, and his kind of difference is good. If he was wrong, he changes his mind. He WAS wrong about torture, so he changed his position, quickly. This isn't weakness. What OTHER politician do you ever see changing his mind and admitting he went overboard?
Who? When?
You LIKE politicians to pretend they're superman and never admit when they blow it. You LIKE to be lied to!
Vicomte13 posted on 2016-03-05 11:07:56 Reply Private Reply
#9: cranky To: Vicomte13 (#8)
As long as no one acted on his orders until he could revoke them, I guess, there's no harm done.
But for a guy who always felt that he was in the military because of his time at New York Military Academy not to know that illegal or unlawful orders need not be carried out by subordinates is pretty ignorant, imho.
That is BAD.
cranky posted on 2016-03-05 11:44:23 Reply Private Reply
#10: Vicomte13 To: cranky (#9)
Trump is going to be a great president. The fearful will wet themselves, but it will be ok.
Vicomte13 posted on 2016-03-05 12:25:26 Reply Private Reply
#11: tomder55 To: Vicomte13 (#8)
A President's words mean things here and around the world ;especially when he says them in public . What you are saying is that he in not Presidential.
tomder55 posted on 2016-03-05 12:56:39 Reply Private Reply
#12: cranky To: Vicomte13 (#10)
That depends on what the meaning of the word great is.
cranky posted on 2016-03-05 13:25:57 Reply Private Reply
#13: paraclete To: cranky (#12)
paraclete posted on 2016-03-05 16:25:36 Reply Private Reply
#14: sneakypete To: Pinguinite (#2)
Who says he doesn't have any firm positions?
On the plus side, he doesn't deny it like any standard politician does. Rather he does openly and unapologetically.
That's because he has a strong character,and refuses to admit he was ever wrong about anything.
Any day now I expect him to say he is the re-incarnation of Jesus,and for all his followers to fall to their knees and bow.
sneakypete posted on 2016-03-05 16:31:19 Reply Private Reply
#15: sneakypete To: Roscoe (#5)
Yes. Saudi Arabia being the most prominent example,but I am sure there are others.
sneakypete posted on 2016-03-05 16:32:18 Reply Private Reply
#16: Roscoe To: sneakypete (#15)
Ya don't say? How many members of the Saudi army have we waterboarded?
Roscoe posted on 2016-03-05 16:45:46 Reply Private Reply
#17: sneakypete To: Roscoe (#16)
You think we waterboard members of states we have treaties with?
Are you insane,or just everyday stupid?
sneakypete posted on 2016-03-05 17:02:42 Reply Private Reply
#18: Roscoe To: sneakypete (#17)
Roscoe posted on 2016-03-05 17:06:01 Reply Private Reply
#19: sneakypete To: Roscoe (#18)
I quoted your original post above,dummy.
YOU mentioned Saudi Arabia.
Of course I did. Most of the funding for terrorism comes from Saudi Arabia,and we not only have a treaty with them,we use US troops to train and fight to protect them.
sneakypete posted on 2016-03-05 17:15:04 Reply Private Reply
#20: Roscoe To: sneakypete (#19)
We don't have any treaties with unlawful combatants. The Geneva Convention does not protect unlawful combatants.
Roscoe posted on 2016-03-05 17:43:44 Reply Private Reply
#21: sneakypete To: Roscoe (#20)
No,and I am not in denial about Saudi Arabia,either,numbnuts.
sneakypete posted on 2016-03-05 18:46:04 Reply Private Reply
#22: Roscoe To: sneakypete (#21)
You're completely in denial about Saudi Arabia, conflating its military with terrorists outside the protection of treaties and the Geneva Convention.
Trump's a man, so you reacted with pearl-clutching vapors.
Roscoe posted on 2016-03-05 18:52:31 Reply Private Reply
#23: sneakypete To: Roscoe (#22)
He's a pussy in pants. No wonder you admire him.
sneakypete posted on 2016-03-05 19:01:21 Reply Private Reply
#24: Roscoe To: sneakypete (#23)
He'd lay you out like a cheap rug. Even if you had your Foam Party boy helping you.
Roscoe posted on 2016-03-05 19:40:54 Reply Private Reply
#25: A K A Stone To: sneakypete (#23)
A K A Stone posted on 2016-03-05 19:46:25 Reply Private Reply
#26: sneakypete To: Roscoe (#24)
ROFLMAO! You guys with your boy-crushes are hilarious.
He MIGHT sic his bodyguards on me while he hid behind a couple he held back,but that would be it.
sneakypete posted on 2016-03-05 20:41:33 Reply Private Reply
#27: Roscoe To: sneakypete (#26)
Roscoe posted on 2016-03-05 21:02:00 Reply Private Reply
#28: sneakypete To: Roscoe (#27)
You are projecting your cowardice on me.
I'm guessing Donald impresses you so much because he has bigger hands than you,and thus is your personal alpha dog?
sneakypete posted on 2016-03-06 03:22:11 Reply Private Reply
#29: Roscoe To: sneakypete (#28)
Roscoe posted on 2016-03-06 06:53:40 Reply Private Reply
#30: cranky To: paraclete (#13)
Tamerlane (aka Timur)?
cranky posted on 2016-03-06 11:04:42 Reply Private Reply
#31: nolu chan To: misterwhite, Roscoe, Vicomte13, cranky (#7)
Actually, the Geneva Conventions only apply to international war between two or more high contracting parties to the conventions.
See Hamdan v. Rumsfeld at 67:
Violations of customary International Humanitarian Law may be the subject of lawful reprisal in kind, for the purpose of coercing the transgressor to comply with customary IHL. It is not accurate that terrorists may chop off heads and drown people in cages, and that they remain entitled to all protections under international law.
https://www.icrc.org/customary-ihl/eng/docs/v1_rul_rule145
Customary International Humanitarian Law
nolu chan posted on 2016-03-06 12:54:50 Reply Private Reply
#32: paraclete To: cranky (#30)
paraclete posted on 2016-03-06 15:34:02 Reply Private Reply
#33: misterwhite To: nolu chan (#31)
misterwhite posted on 2016-03-07 08:30:27 Reply Private Reply