Have you ever made fun of Donald Trump? Have you ever read an editorial that really lays into him with criticisms of his proposed policies, or even his hair?
Well if Trump becomes president, he promises that things will change, and these sorts of critiques will no longer be legal.
It almost sounds like satire, but during a speech in Texas on Friday morning, the Republican candidate and frontrunner, Donald Trump said he wants to sue news outlets if they negative stories about him.
He acknowledged that currently the First Amendment of the Constitution protects a free press, and thus shields journalists from suits like this.
But Trump said on Friday that he would limit the press using litigation that would be permitted due to opening up libel laws and allowing them to include things like criticism and critiques that he doesnt like.
I think the media is among the most dishonest groups of people Ive ever met, Trump stated. Theyre terrible.
So Trump promised to change things through legislating what he considers honest reporting.
One of the things Im gonna do, and this is only gonna make it tougher for me, and Ive never said this before, but one of the things Im gonna do if I win is Im gonna open up our libel laws so when they write purposely negative and horrible and false articles, we can sue them and win lots of money. Were gonna open up those libel laws.
He went even further and made it clear what he meant, saying, Were gonna open up those libel laws, folks, and were gonna have people sue you like you never get sued before.
See if for yourself in the video clip below
(Article by M. David;
#1: Roscoe To: Deckard (#0)
Try actually reading it someday.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 11:54:04 Reply Private Reply
#2: Pinguinite To: Deckard (#0)
Pinguinite posted on 2016-02-27 11:58:58 Reply Private Reply
#3: Deckard To: Roscoe (#1)
Seems to me that Communist regimes have similar laws against criticism of public figures.
Trump is sounding more and more like a dictator.
Must be why statists like you and whitey like him so much.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 12:03:31 Reply Private Reply
#4: misterwhite To: Roscoe (#1)
Sure it did. It clearly says that the press can write lies about you if you're a public figure. The U.S. Supreme Court found it hiding in a penumbra.
I'm with Trump on this one. Get rid of the "public figure" exemption and hold the press responsible for negligent behavior. All other countries do it.
And, prior to 1967, so did the United States.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-27 12:21:58 Reply Private Reply
#5: Roscoe To: Deckard (#3)
Shields everyone against Congressional restrictions, not just leftist journalists.
Strike two.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 12:24:33 Reply Private Reply
#6: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#4)
Cruz and Rubio would wind up penniless from their libels and slanders in this campaign alone.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 12:28:14 Reply Private Reply
#7: Deckard To: Roscoe, misterwhite (#6)
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 12:41:22 Reply Private Reply
#8: Roscoe To: Deckard (#7)
When has your beloved Hillary ever proposed abiding by original intent?
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 12:43:59 Reply Private Reply
#9: misterwhite To: Roscoe (#6)
In the age of the Internet there is no excuse to not know something. And if the press doesn't know, it shouldn't be published as fact. Just one example of what was reported in the press that Rubio gladly regurgitated:
If you hadnt inherited $200 million, youd be selling selling watches on the streets of Manhattan.
First, Fred Trump Sr. died in 1999. By then, Trump was already a billionaire. Second, when Fred Trump Sr. died, his estate was worth $20 million and that was divided among his 4 surviving children. Third, Trump admits that his father loaned him $1 million back in the 60's to start his business -- money which he paid back.
Good people have fought and died in wars to preserve this version of "freedom of the press"?
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-27 13:03:26 Reply Private Reply
#10: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#9)
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 13:08:59 Reply Private Reply
#11: misterwhite To: Deckard (#7)
Hillary would never propose a return to constitutional law.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-27 13:23:39 Reply Private Reply
#12: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#9)
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 13:24:04 Reply Private Reply
#13: Deckard To: Roscoe (#10)
The idea of a dictator who believes that suing the press for criticizing him should scare any American.
Like I said, if Hillary had proposed this you'd be against it.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 13:33:38 Reply Private Reply
#14: Deckard To: misterwhite (#11)
Trump suing the press for criticizing his hair is "constitutional"?
What country do you currently reside in comrade?
I'll bet you two clowns love Feinstein.
Feinstein wants to limit who can be a journalist
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 13:34:48 Reply Private Reply
#15: Roscoe To: Deckard (#13)
Change your pants.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 13:34:57 Reply Private Reply
#16: tomder55 To: Deckard (#0)
Gutting the 1st amendment so public leaders can silence critics is totalitarianism in my book. I've got news for Trump . The 1st campaigns in this country were far more vicious when it came to the lies and slanders . The nation survived . Take his proposal now and put the power in the hands of Evita or Bolshevik Bernie. Not so attractive is it ? I'm probably on my way to the frog march ,and if not me ,any conservative outlet that opposes them .Evita thinks they are all in a conspiracy against her. But I have to give him credit . He has most of the US media wrapped around his fingers . He claims his campaign is self financed ;but he should be giving a big hat tip to the press in this country who cower at the idea that he would cut off their access. The free promotion has been worth $$$$$$$ millions .
tomder55 posted on 2016-02-27 13:36:12 Reply Private Reply
#17: Deckard To: Roscoe (#15)
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 13:40:25 Reply Private Reply
#18: Deckard To: tomder55 (#16)
Seems that there are some here who disagree.
The cult of Trump is scary. His followers would give up their liberty for him.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 13:44:34 Reply Private Reply
#19: Roscoe To: Deckard (#17)
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 13:44:44 Reply Private Reply
#20: misterwhite To: Deckard (#14)
Is that whhat he said? Let me check. No. He didn't say that. There's a transcript (AND a video if you cant read):
He said, "... but one of the things Im gonna do if I win is Im gonna open up our libel laws so when they write purposely negative and horrible and false articles, we can sue them and win lots of money."
That's the way it was in our country for 200 years. An activist court in 1967 changed that by excluding "public figures" from protection against libel and slander.
Does freedom of the press include them intentionally telling lies about someone -- to promote some hidden agenda -- without facing any consequences for their action?
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-27 13:47:03 Reply Private Reply
#21: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#20)
Deckard lies. It's what he does.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 13:50:51 Reply Private Reply
#22: Deckard To: Roscoe (#19)
Once again you are clueless.
It's you and the other Trump cultist who are on Feinstein's side.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 13:51:00 Reply Private Reply
#23: Roscoe To: Deckard (#22)
Lie and project. It's all ya ever do.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 13:51:46 Reply Private Reply
#24: misterwhite To: tomder55 (#16)
The critics can still publish whatever they want. Trump is simply saying that they need to be held responsible for what they publish. If the press chooses to knowingly publish a lie, they open themselves up to a lawsuit.
This is currently the case with private citizens and WAS the case with public figures prior to 1967. Trump wants to go back to the original laws.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-27 13:54:40 Reply Private Reply
#25: Deckard To: misterwhite (#20)
And here I thought misterwhite was opposed to frivolous lawsuits.
You Trump cultists are the Bush Bots of the new milenium.
Does freedom of the press include them intentionally telling lies about someone -- to promote some hidden agenda.
Maybe you should ask Hannity, O'Reilly, Kelley and Limbaugh.
As far as I know, there is no "fair and balanced" clause in the First amendment.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 13:55:39 Reply Private Reply
#26: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#24)
The Trump-haters also hate mere citizens. They want a Government-approved elite press with special privileges beyond what the rest of us enjoy.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 13:59:20 Reply Private Reply
#27: Roscoe To: Deckard (#25)
Update: Lie, project, and beg the question.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:00:23 Reply Private Reply
#28: Deckard To: Roscoe (#23)
Good grief, your hatred of freedom is utterly repulsive.
As are you.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 14:00:38 Reply Private Reply
#29: Deckard To: Roscoe (#26)
just what the fuck do you think Trump is proposing you bleating sheep?
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 14:02:03 Reply Private Reply
#30: Roscoe To: Deckard (#28)
Actually it is a restriction on Congress. A restriction protecting ALL citizens, much to the dismay of Constitution-haters like yourself.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:02:21 Reply Private Reply
#31: Roscoe To: Deckard (#29)
That the establishment presstitutes be treated just like the rest of us. You and Rachel Maddow hate that.
Uh, you need to change your pants again.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:04:55 Reply Private Reply
#32: misterwhite To: Deckard (#25)
I expect the truth from any organization given special protection under the first amendment. The first amendment exists in order to protect the dissemination of the truth to the public.
I don't see the benefit in protecting the ability of news organizations to tell me lies. I think if a protected news organization intentionally tells me lies they should be held responsible under our civil tort laws.
The second amendment protects your right to keep and bear arms. Does that mean you can use those arms to violate the law?
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-27 14:05:06 Reply Private Reply
#33: Deckard To: Roscoe (#30)
Oh....now it all makes sense.
You delusionally believe that as long as the 1st amendment is infringed by a president and not by congress, then it's all good?
Are you fucking out of your mind?
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 14:06:35 Reply Private Reply
#34: Deckard To: Roscoe (#31)
Nice try though, your tactics are unsurprisingly transparent.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 14:08:47 Reply Private Reply
#35: misterwhite To: Deckard (#28)
WRONG!
The first amendment, as written, protects certain rights from federal infringement.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-27 14:09:07 Reply Private Reply
#36: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#32)
By Deckard's "reasoning", establishment insiders should have a greater right to keep and bear arms than the rest of us.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:09:35 Reply Private Reply
#37: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#35)
Pearls before swine.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:10:11 Reply Private Reply
#38: Deckard To: misterwhite (#32)
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 14:10:53 Reply Private Reply
#39: Roscoe To: Deckard (#33)
Update: Lie, project, beg the question, then double down.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:11:32 Reply Private Reply
#40: Deckard To: Roscoe (#36)
Asshole.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 14:11:51 Reply Private Reply
#41: Roscoe To: Deckard (#38)
The Übermensch shouldn't be subject to the same gun laws as the Juden, according to Deckard.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:14:19 Reply Private Reply
#42: Deckard To: Roscoe, misterwhite (#39)
Fuck this, there's no reasoning with Trump-worshiping twits like you two.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 14:14:43 Reply Private Reply
#43: Roscoe To: Deckard (#40)
And more projection.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:14:55 Reply Private Reply
#44: Deckard To: Roscoe (#41)
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 14:15:21 Reply Private Reply
#45: Roscoe To: Deckard (#42)
Backwards. That one goes in both the "lie" and the "projection" buckets.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:16:24 Reply Private Reply
#46: Roscoe To: Deckard (#44)
Have you thought about trying Haldol?
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:17:22 Reply Private Reply
#47: misterwhite To: Roscoe (#36)
They way I read him, establishment insiders (EI) would have the same right to keep and bear arms as the rest of us.
BUT, the EI could use those arms any way they wanted without repercussion. They can shoot people, rob stores, whatever -- all the while hiding behind their special EI license to own guns.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-27 14:19:20 Reply Private Reply
#48: Roscoe To: misterwhite (#47)
Yeah, that's about right. The Übermensch could shoot the Juden, but the Juden couldn't shoot back. Heil, Deckard!
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:22:24 Reply Private Reply
#49: tomder55 To: Deckard (#18)
The good news is POTUS doesn't write laws . If Trump ever read a copy of the Constitution he would know that .
tomder55 posted on 2016-02-27 14:26:31 Reply Private Reply
#50: Roscoe To: tomder55 (#49)
Federal judges do that.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:33:07 Reply Private Reply
#51: tomder55 To: Roscoe (#50)
The court decided that public figures needed to prove that there was a falsehood ,and that the press knew it was false.
In this case there is no Federal libel laws. There are state laws. So when Her Donald proposes "opening up " libel laws what he means is that he wants to amend the 1st amendment .
tomder55 posted on 2016-02-27 14:42:35 Reply Private Reply
#52: Roscoe To: tomder55 (#51)
Quote, please. It's not like I don't trust your interpretations, but I don't trust your interpretations.
Which the federal judges wrongly subjected to the 1st Amendment's restrictions on Congress, right?Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 14:52:02 Reply Private Reply
#53: Deckard To: tomder55, Roscoe, misterwhite (#51)
Fox News Wins Lawsuit To Misinform Public Seriously
Heres the rundown: On August 18, 2000, journalist Jane Akre won $425,000 in a court ruling where she charged she was pressured by Fox News management and lawyers to air what she knew and documented to be false information.
The real information: she found out cows in Florida were being injected with RBGH, a drug designed to make cows produce milk and, according to FDA-redacted studies, unintentionally designed to make human beings produce cancer.
Fox lawyers, under pressure by the Monsanto Corporation (who produced RBGH), rewrote her report over 80 times to make it compatible with the companys requests. She and her husband, journalist Steve Wilson, refused to air the edited segment.
In February 2003, Fox appealed the decision and an appellate court and had it overturned. Fox lawyers argued it was their first amendment right to report false information. In a six-page written decision, the Court of Appeals decided the FCCs position against news distortion is only a policy, not a law, rule, or regulation.
So, Fox and the other gladiatorical cable news channels were given the okay to legally lie right around the time of the Iraq Wars birth when media lies coincidentally hit a peak in both frequency and severity.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 15:09:57 Reply Private Reply
#54: Roscoe To: Deckard (#53)
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 15:15:00 Reply Private Reply
#55: tomder55 To: Roscoe (#52)
Quote, please. It's not like I don't trust your interpretations, but I don't trust your interpretations.
'In sum the court ruled that "the First Amendment protects the publication of all statements, even false ones, about the conduct of public officials except when statements are made with actual malice (with knowledge that they are false or in reckless disregard of their truth or falsity).'
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Co._v._Sullivan
tomder55 posted on 2016-02-27 15:30:55 Reply Private Reply
#56: Roscoe To: tomder55 (#55)
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 15:32:52 Reply Private Reply
#57: Roscoe To: tomder55 (#55)
This is an example of why nobody with an above room temperature IQ depends on anonymous Wikipedia opinions.
The Court acknowledged that there were falsehoods.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 15:48:04 Reply Private Reply
#58: Deckard To: Roscoe (#54)
The court affirmed that fact.
The MSM exists to publish and broadcast the approved propaganda fed to it by the government and act as the official mouthpiece for government policy.
Simpletons like you with your fascist proclivities will never get that.
Guess you never heard of "Operation Mockingbird".
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 16:50:57 Reply Private Reply
#59: Roscoe To: Deckard (#58)
You didn't read the decision. Predictably.
Roscoe posted on 2016-02-27 16:55:23 Reply Private Reply
#60: paraclete To: Deckard (#0)
paraclete posted on 2016-02-27 17:51:14 Reply Private Reply
#61: misterwhite To: tomder55 (#51)
Why the higher standard? Prior to 1967 the same standard applied to public or private figures.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-27 18:35:13 Reply Private Reply
#62: misterwhite To: Deckard (#58)
Yet they still warrant constitutional protection? Why?
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-27 18:37:40 Reply Private Reply
#63: tomder55 To: misterwhite (#61)
I can give you Justice William Brennan's reasoning in his majority He placed the legal issues in the context of "a profound national commitment to the principle that debate on public issues should be uninhibited, robust, and wide-open, and that it may well include vehement, caustic, and sometimes unpleasantly sharp attacks on government and public officials." Brennan maintained that erroneous statements are inevitable in free debate and must be protected if freedom of expression is to have the "breathing space" it needs to survive.
In the decision Brennan did not go as far as Justices Hugo Black and William Douglas would've liked. The voted in favor of the opinion ,but would've made it impossible for a public figure to win a liable case. They concluded that the First Amendment provided an absolute Immunity for criticism of the way public officials do their public duty.
This was not a divided court on this case. There was a 9-0 majority .
tomder55 posted on 2016-02-27 20:30:09 Reply Private Reply
#64: Deckard To: misterwhite (#62)
The media are under no obligation to tell the truth.
Therefore Trump's threat to sue them has no legal standing.
Good grief - you cultists are impervious to facts.
Deckard posted on 2016-02-27 20:37:21 Reply Private Reply
#65: misterwhite To: Deckard (#64)
Correct. But they can be sued if they don't. Trump merely wants to extend the ability to sue to public figures.
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-28 10:33:57 Reply Private Reply
#66: misterwhite To: tomder55 (#63)
I read that statement and I agree.
"erroneous statements are inevitable in free debate and must be protected if freedom of expression is to have the "breathing space" it needs to survive."
I read that and agree with it also.
So, where do intentional lies (not errors) about a candidate fit into that? Isn't a lie about a candidate contrary to the principle of an honest debate? Are you better off if the New York Times gives you no information or misinformation?
And if "debate on public issues" is the reason, then why does the law extend to actors, sports figures, TV personalities, and other public figures?
misterwhite posted on 2016-02-28 10:55:31 Reply Private Reply
#67: tomder55 To: misterwhite (#66)
tomder55 posted on 2016-02-28 11:09:45 Reply Private Reply
#68: tomder55 To: misterwhite (#66)
Influential people in federal, state and local government and those in the "star" category of cultural trend-setter have been filing a fair proportion of libel cases against the print and broadcast media in recent years, according to the study. But the more influential they were, the less often they won. Those with the most visible public personalities won just 29 of the 131 suits they took to court.
The implications of that record are obvious to the study's authors, University of Minnesota journalism professor Donald M. Gillmor and San Francisco lawyer Melanie C. Grant. They want to close the courthouse door to libel lawsuits by those who achieve public prominence as policymakers or stars.
Gillmor and Grant propose that "public officials at policymaking levels and celebrities," dependent upon the media for their fame and fortune, "shall have no remedy in libel law." The authors do want the media to give something in return: They should stand ready to open their news columns or air time for replies by influential people whom they wrong as a voluntary rather than a legally compelled remedy.
While their proposed solution is hardly likely to become law, the Gillmor-Grant study is worth a second look. For some years now, similar proposals have been bandied about by legal scholars and judges, with little behind the discussion but raw theory. Now, with a wealth of statistics from 614 libel cases against the media between 1982 and 1988, Gillmor and Grant have provided a firm scholarly basis for what seems a compelling conclusion: Since the high-profile libel suit is demonstrably a failure, it can no longer claim to have social value or purpose.
The Gillmor-Grant study is, at its core, a tough reminder that the American press did not get what it thought it was getting in 1964, when the U. S. Supreme Court decided the case of New York Times v. Sullivan . The ruling, which put libel law under the restraints of the First Amendment for the first time, supposedly built a constitutional bulwark against libel lawsuits by public officials and celebrities.
It has been easy enough to make the argument, in theory, that the Sullivan decision was very good for the press, because it opened the way for more rigorous, even aggressive, coverage of public affairs. It is alien to American political theory to permit those with power to try to silence the press when it gets too tough or too close in monitoring the powerful.
And, one could easily extend the theory to suggest that libel as a legal option ought to be reserved for those who have no influence in society. They often are unable to generate publicity to counter harmful stories and, besides, they rarely become targets of aggressive press attention.
The press has been relying on the Sullivan theory, and thus has been able to tell itself, over and over again, that its constitutional shield was sturdy indeed. But high-profile individuals apparently did not get it: They kept suing and suing and suing. The fact that they didn't win much (and everybody believed that as a matter of faith, even before the Gillmor-Grant data became available) provided little comfort. The press may have walked away from many of those legal bouts without paying megabuck verdicts, but its wallet was a lot thinner after paying the legal bills to gain those victories.
It fell on deaf ears among many members of the press when a critic of Sullivan noted that the decision did not keep the powerful from suing; it simply set down the rules that, with increasing complexity, made libel lawsuits costlier.
Now come Gillmor and Grant to deflate the myth of Sullivan 's promise of deliverance from the devil of libel. A form of litigation with such a low success rate, they show, is a futile exercise.
But what can the press do about that? It has just two options; neither is at all promising. It can go to the Supreme Court in the next libel case and try to persuade the justices to extend Sullivan to implement the ban suggested by Gillmor and Grant. Or it can troop to every state legislature (and perhaps Congress as well) and ask lawmakers to eliminate their right to sue the press for libel.
The first option is as foolhardy as the second. The current Supreme Court appears to be bent on retreating from Sullivan , not expanding its scope. The press doesn't know what it would get if the court began to tinker with Sullivan .
It hardly needs saying that the second option is a dream world proposition. Every harried politician in the country knows that a libel lawsuit is a good publicity gimmick, even when it fails.
The Gillmor-Grant study might yet be put to use, however: Press lawyers could cite it as they try to get celebrities to settle out of court. l
http://ajrarchive.org/Article.asp?id=1749
tomder55 posted on 2016-02-28 12:07:23 Reply Private Reply