Capitalism has generated massive wealth for some, but its devastated the planet and has failed to improve human well-being at scale.
Species are going extinct at a rate 1,000 times faster than that of the natural rate over the previous 65 million years (see Center for Health and the Global Environment at Harvard Medical School).
Since 2000, 6 million hectares of primary forest have been lost each year. Thats 14,826,322 acres, or just less than the entire state of West Virginia (see the 2010 assessment by the Food and Agricultural Organization of the UN).
Even in the U.S., 15% of the population lives below the poverty line. For children under the age of 18, that number increases to 20% (see U.S. Census).
The worlds population is expected to reach 10 billion by 2050 (see United Nations projections).
Capitalism is unsustainable in its current form.
(Credit: ZINIYANGE AUNTONY/AFP/Getty Images)
How do we expect to feed that many people while we exhaust the resources that remain?
Human activities are behind the extinction crisis. Commercial agriculture, timber extraction, and infrastructure development are causing habitat loss and our reliance on fossil fuels is a major contributor to climate change.
Public corporations are responding to consumer demand and pressure from Wall Street. Professors Christopher Wright and Daniel Nyberg published Climate Change, Capitalism and Corporations last fall, arguing that businesses are locked in a cycle of exploiting the worlds resources in ever more creative ways.
Our book shows how large corporations are able to continue engaging in increasingly environmentally exploitative behaviour by obscuring the link between endless economic growth and worsening environmental destruction, they wrote.
Yale sociologist Justin Farrell studied 20 years of corporate funding and found that corporations have used their wealth to amplify contrarian views [of climate change] and create an impression of greater scientific uncertainty than actually exists.
Corporate capitalism is committed to the relentless pursuit of growth, even if it ravages the planet and threatens human health.
We need to build a new system: one that will balance economic growth with sustainability and human flourishing.
A new generation of companies are showing the way forward. Theyre infusing capitalism with fresh ideas, specifically in regards to employee ownership and agile management.
The Increasing Importance Of Distributed Ownership And Governance
Fund managers at global financial institutions own the majority (70%) of the public stock exchange. These absent owners have no stake in the communities in which the companies operate. Furthermore, management-controlled equity is concentrated in the hands of a select few: the CEO and other senior executives.
On the other hand, startups have been willing to distribute equity to employees. Sometimes such equity distribution is done to make up for less than competitive salaries, but more often its offered as a financial incentive to motivate employees toward building a successful company.
According to The Economist, todays startups are keen to incentivize via shared ownership:
The central difference lies in ownership: whereas nobody is sure who owns public companies, startups go to great lengths to define who owns what. Early in a companys life, the founders and first recruits own a majority stakeand they incentivise people with ownership stakes or performance-related rewards. That has always been true for startups, but today the rights and responsibilities are meticulously defined in contracts drawn up by lawyers. This aligns interests and creates a culture of hard work and camaraderie. Because they are private rather than public, they measure how they are doing using performance indicators (such as how many products they have produced) rather than elaborate accounting standards.
This trend hearkens back to cooperatives where employees collectively owned the enterprise and participated in management decisions through their voting rights. Mondragon is the oft-cited example of a successful, modern worker cooperative. Mondragons broad-based employee ownership is not the same as an Employee Stock Ownership Plan. With ownership comes a say control over the business. Their workers elect management, and management is responsible to the employees.
REI is a consumer cooperative that drew attention this past year when it opted out of Black Friday sales, encouraging its employees and customers to spend the day outside instead of shopping.
I suspect that the most successful companies under this emerging form of capitalism will have less concentrated, more egalitarian ownership structures. They will benefit not only financially but also communally.
Joint Ownership Will Lead To Collaborative Management
The hierarchical organization of modern corporations will give way to networks or communities that make collaboration paramount. Many options for more fluid, agile management structures could take hold.
For instance, newer companies are experimenting with alternative management models that seek to empower employees more than a traditional hierarchy typically does. Of these newer approaches, holacracy is the most widely known. It promises to bring structure and discipline to a peer-to-peer workplace.
Holacracy is a new way of running an organization that removes power from a management hierarchy and distributes it across clear roles, which can then be executed autonomously, without a micromanaging boss.
Companies like Zappos and Medium are in varying stages of implementing the management system.
Valve Software in Seattle goes even further, allowing employees to select which projects they want to work on. Employees then move their desks to the most conducive office area for collaborating with the project team.
These are small steps toward a system that values the employee more than what the employee can produce. By giving employees a greater say in decision-making, corporations will make choices that ensure the future of the planet and its inhabitants.

#91: A Pole To: CZ82 (#76)
In "ALL" you include American government or you don't?
Do you really believe that you can just go there?
A Pole posted on 2016-02-18 03:35:49 Reply Private Reply
#92: A Pole To: tpaine (#75)
History is not your strong side.
A Pole posted on 2016-02-18 03:37:42 Reply Private Reply
#93: A Pole To: tpaine (#71)
I would love to see some examples. What freedoms do you have that Italians, or Brazilians, or Irish, or Indians do not?
A Pole posted on 2016-02-18 03:47:17 Reply Private Reply
#94: A Pole To: SOSO (#86)
Reread carefully what you and me wrote. I have no energy to untangle your confusion.
A Pole posted on 2016-02-18 03:51:48 Reply Private Reply
#95: paraclete To: A Pole (#91)
Those of us who have done this have come to know a good thing when we see it. Before you talk about sorry ass forms of government you really should think for a while, if you really had a choice would you live where you do?
You have drunk the koolaid and want to believe anything you are told, but I have seen failed nations, I have seen places where you scratch your head and wonder what's going on. I've been to places when you are told not to go there and what I know is not everything is what you think it is and certainly not what you have been told it is
paraclete posted on 2016-02-18 03:51:55 Reply Private Reply
#96: A Pole To: paraclete (#95)
In a home country or a country that you know well and have friends there?
Politics is not so important while moving and adjusting to another place and culture is a very difficult thing.
A Pole posted on 2016-02-18 05:25:03 Reply Private Reply
#97: tpaine To: A Pole (#93)
The only type of rule of law that has worked, -- is American constitutionalism
Silly question, seeing there are no other countries with our freedoms.
I'm free to live in the United States. Many Italians, or Brazilians, or Irish, or Indians want to, but cannot. That's a continuing historical fact.
But being our resident pest, you don't let facts interfere with your juvenile trolling. ---- So please, get lost..
tpaine posted on 2016-02-18 09:03:52 Reply Private Reply
#98: Vicomte13 To: paraclete (#95)
If I really had the choice, I would live on my own cherry orchard and experimental dairy, with experimental sturgeon ponds, in Leelanau County, Michigan. My house would be a log-and-stone cabin, built entirely with local materials. Such electrical power as needed would be wind-generated.
It would be good.
But I don't have the choice - too many commitments, too many other people depending on me. This is true of all.
If my wife had the choice, we'd live in Paris or Manhattan.
Connecticut is a compromise.
Vicomte13 posted on 2016-02-18 09:34:44 Reply Private Reply
#99: Vicomte13 To: paraclete (#95)
Yes. Paris was a very easy place to live and to like. New York was. The other American cities in which I've lived, less so, because there's nothing in most cities except clothing stores, gas stations and fast food.
Vicomte13 posted on 2016-02-18 09:36:17 Reply Private Reply
#100: Vicomte13 To: A K A Stone (#63)
You are calling God's own economic structure, laid out in Exodus and Leviticus, and repeated in Deuteronomy, "thievery".
You're wrong.
Vicomte13 posted on 2016-02-18 09:42:14 Reply Private Reply
#101: A K A Stone To: Vicomte13 (#100)
You are full of it on this like most things.
God never told anyone to give 50 plus percent of their income to a godless government.
You support stealing from productive people and giving it to sloths.
Tell me great one what the Bible says about sloths and why you want to give slots money from productive people. You would make God a liar if you could.
A K A Stone posted on 2016-02-18 09:44:38 Reply Private Reply
#102: A Pole To: tpaine (#97)
There many Americans who want and live in other countries. This is XXI century in case if you don't know.
And every Italian, Brazilians etc have freedom to live in their country. And many of them like to do so. You have skewed perspective because you meet only those who wanted to emigrate.
Returning to the original question, can you show how Italy or India are less free?
A Pole posted on 2016-02-18 10:59:36 Reply Private Reply
#103: A Pole To: A K A Stone (#101)
Are you saying that rich people are rich because they work hard and poor working people are poor because they are lazy?
A Pole posted on 2016-02-18 11:01:40 Reply Private Reply
#104: Vicomte13 To: A K A Stone (#101)
Pass.
It is to a man's honor to avoid strife, but every fool is quick to quarrel. (Proverbs 20:3)
Vicomte13 posted on 2016-02-18 11:24:31 Reply Private Reply
#105: SOSO To: tpaine, TooConservative (#90)
Then how do you believe that, given the current demographics and the irrefutable trend, the U.S. will reverse course and backup to something more reasonable?
SOSO posted on 2016-02-18 11:26:04 Reply Private Reply
#106: tpaine To: SOSO (#105)
Get out much? -- We're about to elect Trump, who says he will reverse the trends. I have high hopes, ( but not much faith).
- And if Trump fails, we'll find somebody who can.
tpaine posted on 2016-02-18 13:43:17 Reply Private Reply
#107: Tooconservative To: SOSO, tpaine (#105)
The outlook is not encouraging at all, in part because the GOP talks more about fiscally conservative policy than doing anything about it.
Tooconservative posted on 2016-02-18 16:19:40 Reply Private Reply
#108: paraclete To: TooConservative (#107)
This is a time in which talk is cheap, and rhetoric abounds. Reality has flown and will be back in the autumn
paraclete posted on 2016-02-18 17:53:34 Reply Private Reply
#109: SOSO To: TooConservative (#107)
As sad as this is, that is my point. Keep coming to the light.
SOSO posted on 2016-02-18 19:34:04 Reply Private Reply
#110: SOSO To: A Pole (#94)
"#55. To: SOSO (#53) ....................................................
In the 1950s and 1960s American workers were middle class because of the unions/New Deal/custom tariffs and protection from the cheap Third World country labor.
.................................................
A Pole posted on 2016-02-17 13:35:40 ET Reply Trace Private Reply"
NB - you made the claim for the prosperity of the middle class IN THE 1950 and 1960s. I asked you three times now exactly to which Third World countries are you referring in the 1950s and 1960s. You haven't answered this yet and probably never will because you know that you are full of sh*t.
On the utterly remote chance you answer it is incumbent on you to document with links the source of you information as I just about always do with you. It is plain for all to see that you are just a mindless propaganda tool for your Commie handlers as you rarely, if ever, back up you claims with credible data from credible sources. This will just be one more time in that mold for you.
SOSO posted on 2016-02-18 20:20:42 Reply Private Reply
#111: SOSO To: A Pole, TooConservative, paraclete, Willie Green, nativist nationalist, A K A Stone, Pericles, nolu chan, Vicomte13, All (#110)
Show me exactly how much the U.S. benefitted from cheap labor from Third World countries in the 1950s and 1960s as you claim was a significant reason for the prosperity of the middle class in the U.S. during that time. Read the data very well now or get an honest person to read it for you and you will see that the value of ALL imports into the U.S. in the 1950s and1960s was close to nothing.
You can't defend your claim, can you?
SOSO posted on 2016-02-18 20:45:42 Reply Private Reply
#112: paraclete To: SOSO (#111)
I can defend the claims I make. if as you say the imports into the US in the 50's and 60's were inconsequential I would have to ask is this because of high tarriff barriers? You imports rose only because your job creators took your jobs and created them somewhere else
paraclete posted on 2016-02-18 22:05:02 Reply Private Reply
#113: SOSO To: paraclete (#112)
My post we directed to A Pole who made the claim that I referenced. You were copied because you appeared to be interested in the thread.
But if you have a claim to make then make it and we'll go from there. Please be specific and stick to the specific ear that A Pole reference, i.e. - the 1950s and 1960s. Look at the chart that I posted and tell me when imports really started to rise in any significant manner. It certainly wasn't in the 1950s and 1960s.
SOSO posted on 2016-02-18 22:53:09 Reply Private Reply
#114: paraclete To: SOSO (#113)
A single line on a chart doesn't allow us to corrolate the data with other factors. Why don't you chart the data with exports, population and GDP and employment(participation rate)
paraclete posted on 2016-02-18 23:46:41 Reply Private Reply
#115: SOSO To: paraclete (#114)
OK, have at it. The ball is in your court.
SOSO posted on 2016-02-19 00:18:59 Reply Private Reply
#116: SOSO To: paraclete (#114)
BTW, the dollar value of imports thru the 50s and 60s was less than 1/230 of what it was in the last five years. Inflation doesn't account for 1/10 or so, and currency much less. The fact is in real terms the U.S. was importing a small fraction of what it has been for the last decade and only a somewhat larger fraction of what it was for the 1980s and 1990s. I leave it to you to do the math. Frankly, I don't think that you are capable of it and will surely waffle and weasel out of it.
SOSO posted on 2016-02-19 00:26:00 Reply Private Reply
#117: A Pole To: SOSO (#111)
You misread me. I wrote:
"In the 1950s and 1960s American workers were middle class because of the unions/New Deal/custom tariffs and protection from the cheap Third World country labor. "
BTW, you replaced "workers" with "U.S.". Saying that England or English peasants benefited from Henry VIII rule, are two different things.
A Pole posted on 2016-02-19 00:32:46 Reply Private Reply
#118: A Pole To: paraclete, SOSO (#113)
SOSO changed my words, see post above. BTW, why did he say "we"?
A Pole posted on 2016-02-19 00:36:54 Reply Private Reply
#119: SOSO To: paraclete, A Pole, All (#116)
The CPI was 23.8 in mid-1950 and 238.6 in mid-2015, that's just spot on 1/10 or in other words 2015 was ten times higher not the 230 times higher as the chart shows. Now you may determine just how much currency changes adjust the numbers. I guarantee you its nowhere near 23 times. Both you and A pole are totally full of sh*t.
The fact is imports accounts for virtually nothing of the rise of the middle class in the U.S. in the 1950s and 1960s.
Your turn.
SOSO posted on 2016-02-19 00:38:19 Reply Private Reply
#120: SOSO To: A Pole, paraclete (#118)
You are a total sh*t eating liar. I copy what you posted in #55 and pasted it. There was no way that I could have changed you words. Go to your paste #55, the truth is there. They are the words that YOU posted. Piss off you smelly dishonest turd.
SOSO posted on 2016-02-19 00:41:57 Reply Private Reply
#121: SOSO To: A Pole paraclete (#120)
#110. To: A Pole (#94)
You reread what you said, I will just post it here:
"#55. To: SOSO (#53) ....................................................
In the 1950s and 1960s American workers were middle class because of the unions/New Deal/custom tariffs and protection from the cheap Third World country labor.
.................................................
A Pole posted on 2016-02-17 13:35:40 ET Reply Trace Private Reply"
NB - you made the claim for the prosperity of the middle class IN THE 1950 and 1960s. I asked you three times now exactly to which Third World countries are you referring in the 1950s and 1960s. You haven't answered this yet and probably never will because you know that you are full of sh*t.
On the utterly remote chance you answer it is incumbent on you to document with links the source of you information as I just about always do with you. It is plain for all to see that you are just a mindless propaganda tool for your Commie handlers as you rarely, if ever, back up you claims with credible data from credible sources. This will just be one more time in that mold for you.
потому что Бог хочет это тот путь
SOSO posted on 2016-02-18 20:20:42 ET Reply Trace Private Reply"
You are a disgusting person. A characteristic of almost all commie, leftist and leftwing jerks
SOSO posted on 2016-02-19 00:48:58 Reply Private Reply
#122: A Pole To: SOSO (#120)
You copied this from me? "Show me exactly how much the U.S. benefitted from cheap labor from Third World countries in the 1950s and 1960s as you claim was a significant reason for the prosperity of the middle class in the U.S. during that time."
Here is the entire post and wash you mouth Mr "We". ("My post we directed to A Pole", you work in twos?)
#55. To: SOSO (#53)
Western European socialist forms of government also has worked to a lesser degree in developing a broad and deep middle class.
How do you define middle class?
People who live from selling their labor but are able to command wages significantly higher that needed for basic leaving. They have leisure time and means to do extra activities.
Lower class are those who just have enough to make ends meet.
Underclass are those who cannot break even.
Upper class are those who buy labor of the other classes to turn profit.
In the 1950s and 1960s American workers were middle class because of the unions/New Deal/custom tariffs and protection from the cheap Third World country labor.
After Free Trade reforms workers moved to lower class thanks to labor arbitrage and off-shoring.
Professionals like physicians are protected by their unions/associations so they remained in the middle class.
Financial deregulation opened door to usury and many working people slide into underclass.
Now, who has more disposable income and free time, German or American workers?
A Pole posted on 2016-02-17 13:35:40 ET Reply Trace Private Reply
A Pole posted on 2016-02-19 00:58:14 Reply Private Reply
#123: SOSO To: A Pole (#122)
F*ck off you lying sack of sh*t. I quoted you word for word in my post #110 and will do it again.
"#110. To: A Pole (#94)
You reread what you said, I will just post it here:
"#55. To: SOSO (#53) ....................................................
In the 1950s and 1960s American workers were middle class because of the unions/New Deal/custom tariffs and protection from the cheap Third World country labor.
.................................................
A Pole posted on 2016-02-17 13:35:40 ET Reply Trace Private Reply"
NB - you made the claim for the prosperity of the middle class IN THE 1950 and 1960s. I asked you three times now exactly to which Third World countries are you referring in the 1950s and 1960s. You haven't answered this yet and probably never will because you know that you are full of sh*t.
On the utterly remote chance you answer it is incumbent on you to document with links the source of you information as I just about always do with you. It is plain for all to see that you are just a mindless propaganda tool for your Commie handlers as you rarely, if ever, back up you claims with credible data from credible sources. This will just be one more time in that mold for you.
потому что Бог хочет это тот путь
SOSO posted on 2016-02-18 20:20:42 ET Reply Trace Private Reply"
Or are you just a moron and don't know what you said "In the 1950s and 1960s American workers were middle class because of the unions/New Deal/custom tariffs and protection from the cheap Third World country labor." means.
You continue to weasel and lie and snake and deflect. And that is because you can't defend your words. So, ass wipe, for the last time I ask what to Third World countries are you referring in your statement?
I know, as everyone else does, that you will not answer this very straight forward, simple question. You can't because you know you lied.
SOSO posted on 2016-02-19 01:13:34 Reply Private Reply
#124: A Pole To: SOSO (#123)
You continue to weasel and lie and snake and deflect. Yup.
Now you quoted me correctly, hoping that others will not notice that you are wiggling away from recent distortion.
Let me interpret this for you, "American workers were able to command high wages, thanks to the unions, New Deal regulations, tariffs on imports, and lack of competition from the cheap Third World labor (no mass immigration, no off-shoring)"
And forget about throwing me out of balance by your silly vulgar insults. You do not look pretty with them.
A Pole posted on 2016-02-19 01:49:33 Reply Private Reply
#125: Vicomte13 To: (#124)
Back then, it was because the British had much more advanced machines and techniques, and could produce more goods of comparable or better quality, cheaper than Americans or anybody else could. The whole world, not just the Anericans, had a choice: accept British domination of economics by simply letting them manufacture everything and export to the world OR protect the domestic markets through tariffs and barriers, so that the same industrialization could occur at home, and concentrate profits at home.
Countries that had advanced populations and armies were able to do that - France, Germany, Italy, Russia, Austria, Japan and America. The rest of the world was unable to defend itself militarily, and ended up colonized by one of those great powers. Colonized countries could NOT break the domination of British (or French, or German, or Japanese, or Italian, etc.) industry, and so THEIR economies remained banana plantations and gold mines, with backwards people. They could not defend themselves, so they were reduced to what free trade would have reduced the whole world too.
The major powers were able to erect barriers, build their own industries, and prevent the British from running the table. But where the British DID run the table (or the French, etc.), you saw exactly what happened, and happens: Britain: rich, India and Africa and the rest of the colonies: poor.
The Americans broke the British model first, before industrialization, but we had no free trade. We understood that, against the British Empire, we would either be an economic colony, or we would build our own industry. The French, Germans, Italians, Russians, Japanese, et al in Europe, saw this too.
In the 20th Century, the protectionism of the 19th Century paid off for America in the World Wars. The Europeans did isometrics in World War I, but the massive industrial advantage of the Americans turned the table. America was unstoppable in World War I, and again in World War II, because of an overwhelming logistical advantage. The Third Reich had to conquer and steal in order to try to compete, and in the end they could not. The Russians fought bravely and desperately, but their margin of victory was American trucks and American planes and American ammunition. Without those, Russia could not have kept a supplied army in the field and on the roll to Berlin.
American industrial power was the key to victory in the World Wars. The destruction of the rest of the world in those world wars was the key to the utter American economic dominance of the post-war period. In 1950, the war had only been over for 4 1/2 years. Millions were still dead. Lives were still shattered. And - importantly - the Europeans were losing their colonies left and right. The war broke their power. They no longer had the finance or industry to easily dominate the world. And out there in the world, a combination of American penetration of all formerly closed colonial markets (due to the overwhelming American industrial advantage AND the fact that Britain and France were both economically trashed and had depended upon the Americans to save them - such that they could not say "No" to the Americans - AND the insistent subversive pressure of Communist agitation and domestic anti-colonial agitation - all of this meant that the chase-gardees of the past, the great poor hinterlands in which Britain and France, Germany and Italy, and Japan, could operate without competition, were all gone.
There was America, and there were a bunch of rebuilding Europeans and Japanese under American tutelage. There was the USSR, ravaged and rebuilding under Stalin, and there were the ex- and soon-to-be ex-colonies all wriggling free.
OF COURSE American productivity and wealth was high in the 1950s and into the 1960s. We were in a better position than Britain had ever been: absolute superpower of the West, with all of the Europeans of the West beholden to us, the Japanese conquered and beholden to us, and not defending the Europeans as their colonial empires fell apart, opening new markets to us.
But by the 1960s, 15-20 years after the war, things were different. Europe had rebuilt, and undistracted by military expense, was industrially competitive. Japan likewise. America bore the burdens of empire, and did so rather badly (Korea, Vietnam, Bay of Pigs, etc. It added up, and in Vietnam it began to take its toll).
With the oil shock of the 1970s, American domestic automobile monopolies faded in the face of fuel efficient Japanese cars that turned out to be better built. The decline began then.
And then came the age of Reagan and beyond, where finance moved to the top, "free trade" became the mantra, and financiers shifted their game to a global enterprise. Industry flowed out, and in time, unemployment rose and rose, and stayed stuck in the McJobs economy.
Meanwhile, China is now the industrial behemoth.
So, there are lines on charts, but the charts don't show the severe wealth redistibution upward into fewer and fewer hands, as we sacrificed our industrial base to serve a finance-based economy.
It may give us pause to remember who the greatest bankers of the late-19th and earliest 20th centuries were - the "bankers to the world" were not the British or the Americans or the Swiss. No, it was France that was called "Banker to the world". It was the French who financed the Suez Canal, the Panama Canal, and country after country. France was a first-rate financial power.
When the shooting came, though, money was not enough. You needed industry, and people. And that meant that France needed allies. The victorious power was America, because we had industry.
We are following the path of France, into monied aristocracy and finance, sacrificing industry. It didn't work out well for the French. It's not working out for us either.
When I say "us", I mean the bulk of Americans, and overall American power and security. Sure, the cream at the top have gotten wealthier and more powerful than ever. But then, there was nowhere like Versailles, was there? Until the people overturned it all because they were left with too little.
The American model is not sustainable without industry to employ most and make most middle class.
And that requires a tariff, for Americans can no more compete industrially with China today than we could with Britain in 1850, but we need the industry nonetheless.
The North had the industry. The South had the money. And then the North had both. There is a lesson in this. Short-sighted capitalists don't seem to be able to see the lesson.
Which is why a French, and Southern plantation, perspective can be helpful.
Vicomte13 posted on 2016-02-19 07:16:16 Reply Private Reply
#126: GarySpFC To: A Pole (#21)
Neither. However, unlike you I believe in God's sovereignty. He chooses our parents and where we will be born.
GarySpFC posted on 2016-02-19 08:25:50 Reply Private Reply
#127: GarySpFC To: paraclete (#77)
Fidel and Che started ruling by executing over 1,000 men, and yet you have faith in them.
GarySpFC posted on 2016-02-19 08:42:22 Reply Private Reply
#128: tpaine To: Vicomte13, Y'ALL (#125)
Not 'we', -- short sighted capitalists, assisted by stupid politicians, made this happen, -- as Trump is saying, and common sense voters will affirm.
Depends on exactly how we set up our welfare system, and how we tax to pay for welfare, imo.
The Fair Tax scheme, wherein everybody would get a 'prebate' payment (a monthly debit card) for x dollars, -- (enough to pay for three hots and a cot and NOTHING MORE) could work, --- and such a scheme would allow those who wanted a better life to engage in unfettered capitalism, restrained only by the rule of constitutional law.
Comments?
tpaine posted on 2016-02-19 12:07:48 Reply Private Reply
#129: SOSO To: A Pole (#124)
You are off balance. This an entirely different statement than your original one. But my question remains, specifically to what Third World countries are you referring for the period of 1950s and 1960s which is the original period of time under discussion and specifically quoted BY YOU. I ask you again to prove you contention by posting data on what products and services were on the market and available for import into the U.S. in the 1950s and 1960s and what products the U.S. prevented from being imported at your so-called cheap labor price.
Also document the data that supports your new contention that U.S. companies were prevented for "off-shoring" to Third World countries during 1950s and 1960s or any countries for that matter.
Then let's examine U.S. 1950s and 1960s off-shoring to Developed countries such as UK, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Russia (I will be charitable by including Russia) etc. None of these countries were interested in permitting U.S. companies to compete with the rebuilding of the respective country's industrial and manufacturing infrastructure that was destroyed by WWII. These countries were glad to take U.S. financing aid to help their respective companies rebuild but absolutely did not U.S. companies owning the new assets. NB - OPIC was formed in 1971 out of need to help U.S. companies compete against foreign companies that were being directly supported in the global export markets.
Document that during the 1950s and 1960s the U.S. government prevented U.S. companies from investing in plants and facilities abroad and how the U.S. government did that.
The fact is that there was little-to-no "cheap labor" products from any countries during that period, Third World or otherwise. The fact is the U.S. allowed the demise of much of its indigenous manufacturing infrastructure by funding the rebuilding of the infrastructure in other countries affected by WWII. Just look at the history of U.S. steel manufacturing. But it was years and years later than the 1950s and 1960s that the consequences of this neglect first manifest.
Now for the nail in your coffin to expose you for the propagandist you are.
"Foreign investment of U.S. companies abroad has changed drastically in the last half of the twentieth century. Since World War II (19391945) and especially in the 1950s and 1960s, the United States dominated world wide foreign investment. But with the advent of the energy crisis and the oil shortages in the early 1970s, that situation reversed. The United States became the recipient of large investments from Great Britain, the Netherlands, and especially Japan. Yet recently American "indirect" investment abroad has begun to rise dramatically and in 1998 foreign "indirect" investment hit a record of more than $250 billion, climbing sharply during the entire decade. Europe was the prime destination, with the pharmaceutical and telecommunications industries dominating, along with banking and electricity, gas and water utilities. In 1998 U.S. investment abroad doubled to $97 billionhigher than the world direct investment total less than a decade ago. During the 1980s the United States became the largest recipient of foreign direct investment and Japan became the leader in direct investment abroad. Since 1985 foreigners, especially the Japanese, have increased their acquisitions in the United States or have expanded or established businesses there. That kind of investment from Japan and other countries has "trickled" down to include foreign investment of U.S. companies abroad.
Many economists argued that foreign investment, both inward and outward, has been fundamental to the prosperity of the United States."
You are an ultimate lying Commie propagandist that believes that if you tell a big lie often enough it becomes the truth. Fortunately there is documented history for those of us that are not off balance.
SOSO posted on 2016-02-19 12:09:52 Reply Private Reply
#130: A Pole To: SOSO (#129)
You are disingenuous. You deny me right to explain what I mean by my own words, and play games.
This is trolling.
A Pole posted on 2016-02-19 12:51:47 Reply Private Reply
#131: tpaine To: A Pole, SOSO, Vicomte 13, Y'ALL (#130)
Back at #128 I challenged y'all to comment on the issue I raised.
Any takers? --
The Fair Tax scheme, wherein everybody would get a 'prebate' payment (a monthly debit card) for x dollars, -- (enough to pay for three hots and a cot and NOTHING MORE) could work, --- and such a scheme would allow those who wanted a better life to engage in unfettered capitalism, restrained only by the rule of constitutional law.
tpaine posted on 2016-02-19 13:41:38 Reply Private Reply
#132: Vicomte13 To: tpaine (#131)
Vicomte13 posted on 2016-02-19 14:05:29 Reply Private Reply
#133: tpaine To: Vicomte13, Y'ALL (#132)
tpaine posted on 2016-02-19 14:46:35 Reply Private Reply
#134: Justified To: Willie Green (#0)
This is asinine.
Food is as cheap as it has ever been.
US manufactures are moving plants to cheaper countries which brings up their standard of living.
Stupid Americans have forgotten how bad the world was before America showed the world the way. Spoiled rotten Americans ie the easily lead somehow think we went to foreign lands and stole their gold or something! They must not have been told the truth of how Americans worked their ass off and sacrificed to get where they were the best of the best! I guess they forgot how we fought 2 world wars and feed the world until it could stand again!!!!!
It is crony capitalism ie socialism/fascism that is killing the planet. Corrupt people like clintons and the elites in both parties are the ones to blame.
There is nothing more Christian more fair than real capitalism but don't expect to see it because there is no money to be scammed this way. Socialist and Fascist use the easily lead people with dreams of equality of results which has never worked instead of equality of opportunity.
Justified posted on 2016-02-19 17:58:08 Reply Private Reply
#135: A Pole To: tpaine (#133)
Not taking your homework assignments is nor trolling. You are not middle school teacher here and we are not pupils.
A Pole posted on 2016-02-20 05:52:57 Reply Private Reply
#136: A Pole To: Justified (#134)
The first to benefit were Indians and Negroes.
A Pole posted on 2016-02-20 05:56:20 Reply Private Reply
#137: paraclete To: A Pole (#136)
Don't forget the Mexicans who lost 2/3 of their country, and the phillipinos.
What a blessing the americans were to native peoples, releasing them of the burden of looking after their country
paraclete posted on 2016-02-20 07:06:43 Reply Private Reply
#138: Justified To: A Pole (#136)
Every nations has issues. Its just easy to keep harping on the two worst things American has done.
What about freedom and property rights and equality of rights for all rich or poor?
How about when US came and saved Europe twice? Then gave them food until they could get back on their feet?
Until the elite socialist and fascist took over US government America was the place everyone good person on earth wanted to come and live! Not France or England or Russian or Spain or Italy but GOOD OLE USA!
Justified posted on 2016-02-20 07:50:23 Reply Private Reply
#139: Justified To: paraclete, A Pole (#137)
Hogwash. Mexican government lost their land because they decide whitey wasn't Mexican enough and made them second class citizens which cause whitey(and non whites) to kick their ass and take the land. Any Mexican including non whites that wanted to stay, stayed and became Texans.
BTW it was the Mexicans that could not deal with Indians who begged whitey to come and take care of the Indians and then told whitey to piss off after they did.
You guys should read a little real history.
BTW it was the Mexicans ie Spanish who kicked the Indians off their land. Im sure the Indians kicked someone else off the land before them.
Justified posted on 2016-02-20 08:00:17 Reply Private Reply
#140: rlk To: paraclete (#137)
The Mexicans never lost 2/3 of their country. In 1519 Cortez claimed land extending as far North as his imagination could see for Spain. Cortez got his army to the base of a Mexican mountain range but could go no farther because there weren't enough people living there to steal from to feed his army and he could go no further. During the Mexican revolution of about 1820, they overthrew Spanish rule but decided to keep fantasy Spanish claims on the North. There were few Mexicans that ever came North. The land barrier was dry and unpopulated and additionally the Comanch and other Indian tribes were fond of torturing Mexicans to death for sport. The white man subdued the Indian tribes and settled the area.
The phillipinos were being attacked by islamic jihad. They got help from the American Army in repelling the islamics, known in military history as "wiping out the moros". When it was over, the Americans left and returned the land to the phillipinos.
rlk posted on 2016-02-20 09:26:57 Reply Private Reply