The HEART-RENDING images of Brazilian infants with microcephaly linked to the rapidly spreading mosquito-borne Zika virus have brought the crisis into sharp relief and prompted heated debate over the use of a newly discovered gene-editing technology to eliminate the invasive Zika-carrying mosquito.
That technique, known as CRISPR, would allow biologists to edit the DNA of the Aedes aegypti mosquito, which also transmits dengue and chikungunya viruses. Using CRISPR, biologists could modify a specific gene in the targeted species so that it created only male progeny, for example. Through a process known as gene drive, that modification would rapidly spread within the population, wiping it out in a matter of months. Getting rid of the mosquitoes entirely, the argument goes, will also eradicate the diseases they carry.
Scientists in California and here in the Bay State are already experimenting with gene drive a faster process than developing a vaccine in an effort to stop the outbreak dead in its tracks. But with that power comes responsibility: The possibility of saving lives must be balanced against concerns about unintended consequences.
Its very important to test [a gene drive] a lot in the lab before its released, says Flaminia Catteruccia, a professor of immunology and infectious disease at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. Its also critical to have a system in place to withdraw the gene drive to reverse any unforeseen damage. A contingency plan has to be ready.
Questions abound: What is the environmental impact of genetically altered mosquitoes? Is it ethical to erase an entire species? Federal funding and more collaboration between government agencies and laboratories currently trying to develop a gene drive are a vital part of the equation. We need centralized actions and decisions that should not slow down research, adds Catteruccia. If we want to safely implement [a gene drive], there needs to be concerted action.
Although the World Health Organization has declared Zika an emergency, the response should involve top scientific agencies, such as the National Institutes of Health in the United States, as well as humanitarian organizations. And government officials should keep the ethical debate moving at the same speed as the science.
#1: interpreter To: All (#0)
That's a very good question. Besides wanting to wipe out genetic diseases in humans with CRSPR, scientists now want to wipe out mosquitos, which are also one of God's creations. What do you guys think about CRSPR?
interpreter posted on 2016-02-12 10:40:07 Reply Private Reply
#2: Fred Mertz To: interpreter (#1)
Sounds spooky to me. While it sounds well-intended, I worry about the unintended consequences.
I saw something about genetic engineering to eliminate the Dengue virus may have led to this Zika virus. Not sure what to believe.
Fred Mertz posted on 2016-02-12 12:16:16 Reply Private Reply
#3: Tooconservative To: interpreter (#1)
I noticed this a few days ago about a statement from James Clapper, the Director of National Intelligence:
TruNews: DNI chief calls Gene-editing a WMD, MIT suggests use for Zika
In the report titled Statement for the Record Worldwide Threat Assessment of the US Intelligence Community, Clapper noted that:
Gene editing refers to the use of advanced biotechnological processes to alter the DNA inside living cells. The most popular method, Clustered regularly-interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR), has been used in China to make beagles more muscular, dairy cows without horns, and GMO corn engineered to be resist to weedkillers and produce its own pesticides.
MIT Technology Review, a publication which reports on developments in the trans-humanism movement, said although Clapper did not mention CRISPR by name, they believed Clapper clearly had the newest and the most versatile of the gene-editing systems in mind.
The CRISPR techniques low cost and relative ease of usethe basic ingredients can be bought online for $60seems to have spooked intelligence agencies, author Antonio Regalado added.
Prior to Clappers report, MIT Technology Review released an article on Feb. 8 titled, We have the technology to destroy all Zika mosquitoes. In this article a technology called a gene drive was highlighted as way to wipe out all mosquitos carrying the Zika virus.
The article mentioned that Anthony James, a molecular biologist at the University of California, had already demonstrated the technologies effectiveness last year in yeast cells, fruit flies, and a species of mosquito that transmits malaria, and noted that it utilizes the gene-snipping technology CRISPR to force a genetic change to spread through a population as it reproduces.
MIT Technology Review noted that three U.S. labs that handle mosquitoes, two in California and one in Virginia, say they are already working toward a gene drive for Aedes aegypti, the type of mosquito blamed for spreading Zika. If deployed, the technology could theoretically drive the species to extinction.
Four weeks ago we were trying to justify why we are doing this. Now theyre saying Get the lead out, James told MIT Technology Review. Its absolutely going to change the conversation. We could have it easily within a year.
A member of the lab which discovered the Aedes aegypti gene that determines sex, Zachary N. Adelman, an Associate Professor in the Department of Entomology at Virginia Tech, told MIT Technology Review confirmed that a gene drive had the potential to make mosquito populations disappear. The simplest way to do that is to spread a genetic payload that leads to only male offspring, Adelman said, as the male-only instructions spread with each new generation, eventually there would be no females left.
Kevin Esvelt, author of online blog Sculpting Evolution and a gene-drive researcher at MITs Media Lab, agreed with James and Adelman that Aedes aegypti eradication should be the goal, with the contingency that the public was onboard, and the safety of the idea proved.
Technologically, we could probably do it in a couple of years, Esvelt told MIT Technology Review, Im sure well be able to do it before people can agree if we should.
Tooconservative posted on 2016-02-12 15:13:35 Reply Private Reply