[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

John Kerry in Earth Day wonderland

Democrats Are Cheaters

Derek Chauvin's FaTe ... Is Now in The Hands --- of The Jury

Fools' overture

Democrats Are Terrified of Georgia

Climate Media vs. Climate Science

Why We Black Leaders Support Voter ID Laws

Pelosi: ‘No Plans' to Bring a Court-Packing Bill to the House Floor – at This Time

B-1 Bombers Are Deploying To Norway For The First Time With An Eye On Nearby Russia And The Arctic

High School Coach Fired After Refusing To Enforce “Insane” Outdoor Masks During Sports

CNN Says Chinese-Style Fonts Are Racist

Gran Torino Denounced for Anti-Asian Racism

'It Is Still Not Safe To Go Outside,' Says Fauci's Head In A Jar In Year 2739

Biden Re-Ignites the Waco Fire

Over 500 White People Have Been Killed By Cops Since 2020. There Has Been No Rioting Over Those Deaths.

Buttigieg on Exaggerated Infrastructure Jobs Estimate: ‘I Should Have Been More Precise’

Videos - ChrisTians Tear Down MeTal Fences ... Denounce The Closure Of GraceLife Church --- Due To A COVID-19 ResTricTions

Pete BuTTigieg ... To evangelical vaccine hold-ouTs --- Maybe iT's parT of God's plan

TINHORN FLATS ... The Symbol of Modern Day America --- AgainsT Tyranny

This Trial is a ToTal sham ... The enTire power of The sTaTe - media - lefT-wing shock Troops - counTry's finesT legal TalenT ... is being deployed againsT Derek Chauvin.

A few billionaires currenTly have The power To decide ... ThaT some Americans’ speech righTs are more sacred Than oThers --- Clarence Thomas offers a remedy.

Biden Defense Secretary Orders Several “Immediate Actions” to Weed Out ‘Extremism’ in the Ranks

Target selling book that includes prayer to 'hate white people' in 'Religion' section

America is losing its religion — and the effects will be long-lasting

Conservative Grassroots Begin to Take Back Wisconsin

Ron DeSantis Is What the Post-Trump GOP Should Look Like

White House pushes back on conservative argument over Georgia, Colorado voting laws amid MLB dispute

Why Conservatives Keep Losing The Culture Wars

Ex-Trump aide Stephen Miller forms conservative law group to challenge Democratic policies in court

Senate Democrats support conservative-backed Texas bill requiring pro-sports teams with state contracts to play national anthem

Pennsylvania agrees to remove dead voters from voter rolls

Nazi bitches wanna know Why did it take several months for GraceLife church to be closed down?

AnoTher Mass ShooTer Excused By The Media For ... BuTchering Five People --- In The Name of ResToraTive Murder

Fence goes up around GraceLife Church in Alberta after health officials "physically close" facility

Legacy Media Corruption Is At The Heart Of Our National Conflict

Pastor Who Threw COVID Officials - Police OuT Of His Church ...‘They’re AcTing --- JusT Like The CommunisTs’

Democrats demand I.D.s for everything but voting

BLM leader ThreaTens ... DemocraTs citTes ‘will burn’--- if Chauvin found noT guilTy…

The MLB Has Chosen a New City for the All Star Game. There Are Major Problems.

Res ipsa loquiTur - The ... Thing iTself ... speaks

Quite A Day In The Right Turn Against Corporate America

How Mark Zuckerberg Almost Handed Texas To The Democrats

Anyone Using the ‘Jim Crow’ Charge as a Political Weapon Should Hang His Head in Shame

Biden’s Bipartisanship Lie Will Cost Dems the House

Stop Worrying About Conservatives Refusing to Be Vaccinated

'Loving thy neighbor:' New ads urge conservative men with vaccine doubts to get their COVID shots

Legislature’s conservative Bastiat Caucus members say they aren't extremists, but principled Republicans

A way too early guide to the 2024 Republican primary

Polish Pastor Chases Cops Out of Church on Easter Weekend: ‘Get Out! You Nazis!’

Police defunded: Major cities feeling the loss of police funding as murders, other crimes soar

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

See other LEFT WING LOONS Articles

Title: How Did The Cancel CulTure ... Become DominanT --- So Quickly?
Source: townhall.com
URL Source: https://townhall.com/columnists/joh ... e-dominant-so-quickly-n2587228
Published: Apr 3, 2021
Author: John C. Goodman
Post Date: 2021-04-03 18:59:24 by BorisY
Keywords: huTus mau maus devilcraTs, huTus mau maus devilcraTs, huTus mau maus devilcraTs
Views: 30

How Did the Cancel Culture Become Dominant So Quickly?

John C. Goodman

Apr 03, 2021

By cancel culture, I mean the idea that people have rights and responsibilities and obligations and entitlements based on their skin color or their ethnic origin. A person’s identity is defined by the group they belong to. There are no individual rights. There are only group rights.

The cancel culture rejects the political view encapsulated in the Declaration of Independence. In particular, it rejects the idea that people have a right to pursue their own happiness. It also rejects the idea of basic rights guaranteed in the Constitution, including freedom of speech, freedom of religion and freedom of assembly.

Offensive speech can be seen as a “micro aggression” – and thus a form of force. There are no limits to what constitutes such aggression. For example, if you say you voted for Donald Trump, or you like capitalism, or you think free markets have lifted people out of poverty all over the world, you might be accused of offensive speech.

The cancel culture believes in persecuting people who have offensive ideas – by getting them fired, by silencing their writings and their speech, by silencing their access to the Internet and through social ostracism.

When you try to make a reasonable argument against any of this, you make the mistake of thinking reason is the arbiter. It isn’t. The cancel culture rejects the role the modern world has assigned to reason, logic and the scientific method. It sees the Age of Reason, The Enlightenment and indeed all of western civilization as enemies – rather than the path to the good life and the good society.

How did these ideas become so dominant, so quickly?

The answer: the world of ideas abhors a vacuum. What we might call “20th century liberalism” has been intellectually dead since the end of the Vietnam War. What we might call “20th century conservatism” has been dead for at least two decades. The cancel culture swept in and occupied the space that was otherwise abandoned.

Throughout most of the last century, the dominant intellectual viewpoint was called liberalism. It was the political philosophy that gave us the modern welfare state. But by the mid-1970s, liberals had run out of any useful ideas on how to solve economic problems. For the next 25 years, the political winds all over the world were anti- communist and anti-socialist. With leadership from Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher, all the interesting ideas were suddenly coming from the right.

The flat tax, private social security accounts, school choice, deregulation, privatization – these solutions were debated everywhere and enacted to one degree or another in many countries.

The left generally opposed this trend. But they had few alternatives to offer. So, the arguments almost everywhere were over policy ideas coming from the right.

The liberal approach to economic problems was almost always more government – more regulation, more spending, more control. But in the area of civil liberties, 20th-century liberals kept faith with 19th- century classical liberalism. They believed government should be held at bay and staunchly defended the right of people to speak, write and demonstrate on almost any topic.

The problem is: the argument for government intervention in the economy can be used with equal force in the world of ideas. Trade between two people, liberals used to argue, might make both traders better off. But there can be negative “external effects” for others and that justifies a role for government. Unfortunately, the same can be said of speech. Indeed, some speech is designed to upset others and make them feel uncomfortable. Does that mean government should intervene? By the time this argument was made, liberalism was so intellectually bankrupt that it produced almost no resistance.

What about conservatism? When Bill Buckley established National Review in 1955, he announced that “It stands athwart history, yelling Stop.” Small wonder, then, that such ideas as the flat tax, Social Security privatization and school choice did not originate on the pages of his magazine. Buckley’s conservatism was not about reform, it was about stopping reform.

Where did the free enterprise reform ideas of the last quarter of the 20th-century come from? They mainly came from Milton Friedman, who called himself a “liberal,” meaning a 19th--century classical liberal. Just as the classical liberals were reformers, so was Friedman. And while the National Review crowd welcomed these ideas, it only weakly supported the idea of a free market and never made a moral case for it.

What about free speech and First Amendment rights? It may be an uncomfortable memory, but the conservatives of the 1950s had their own cancel culture. Buckley, for example, wrote a book defending Joe McCarthy. He seemed to approve of hauling people before congressional committees and asking them about their political beliefs. He didn’t seem to mind very much when they lost their jobs because of their politics. As for the First Amendment, some conservatives questioned whether it really belonged in the Constitution. (See the essay by Willmoore Kendall in What Is Conservatism?) National Review writers also advocated outlawing movies judged to be pornographic.

Milton Friedman was a libertarian. He believed in “free minds and free markets.” But as an intellectual force, this point of view attracts a very small percentage of the electorate. As we entered the 21st century, people who called themselves “conservative” became increasingly focused on the culture wars – taking positions that had little appeal to young people. As I wrote recently at National Review, they showed little interest in free market reforms that would be most beneficial to those at the bottom of the income ladder.

Liberals progressively abandoned virtually everything they once believed about civil liberties and about race relations as well. Very few of them today would agree with Martin Luther King’s idea that people should “not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character."

Into the vacuum stepped a cancel culture that is collectivist, racist, anti-capitalist and unapologetically irrational.

It is dominating, because it has no real opposition.



Goodman, you're missing the point of the House UnAmerican Activities Committee - it was a sincere effort to keep us from being dragged into an extension of World War Two by the enemies within us.

The committee failed in its task and trashed our freedom doing so. We are still reaping the consequence.

Like all Libertarians I've interacted with, your entire corpus of writing assumes that man, left alone, will always do the right thing because man is essentially good.

This is a patently false idea.

First, you can't define "good" and "evil" - because you do not recognize an objective definer of those concepts.

Secondly, humans are inherently selfish and tend to evil (we call them "sinners").

Yes, we are all capable of doing good, but that is not our fundamental nature.

The vacuum the cancel culture (evil) rushed to fill was caused by the state stopping the teaching of Christian morality in the schools in the 1950s and the churches not filling(not being allowed to fill...) the gap - and now we are being cancelled for trying to do so because evil does not want to concede ground.

As a nation, encouraged by media, we are irreconcilably polarized.

Libertarianism is not capable of bridging the gap nor of establishing a secular utopia, because it is based on a false premise.

Republicanism is not capable of itself either, nor any political party - only a stirring of the hearts of the majority of the people by the Christian God will enable this country to be restored to the freedom we once enjoyed as a nation.

Poster Comment:

pluralism / freedom - yes

diversiTy / whiTe slavery - no

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com