[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

I do believe ThaT iT is wiThin The realm of possibiliTy ThaT Biden could win a presidenTial elecTion ... iT would Take place during a severe weaTher evenT --- hеll freezing over.

New Data Finds Majority Of Trump’s 2020 Voters Were Women and Minorities

Why Republicans believe they're right to oust Liz Cheney

150,000+ Sign French LeTTer ... Warning Of Civil War --- Demanding Major AnTi-IslamisT Changes To SocieTy.

Immediate Use of Ivermectin Medicine Globally Can End COVID-19 Pandemic: Scientists

COVID Fraud – Lawyers & Medical Experts start legal proceedings against W.H.O and World Leaders for ‘Crimes against Humanity’

School Board Nazi struggles to breathe while she orders kids to wear masks…

Warren says she'll run for reelection to Senate

WiThheld rouTers ... The laTesT of many roadblocks --- To Arizona SenaTe's audiT of 2020 elecTion

Windham ResidenTs ... Refuse --- To Be Silenced

When Cruelty Actually Is The Point

Fauci's agency spent over $400k on experiments grafting aborted fetal scalps onto mice and rats

Who Is Bill Gates? (Full Documentary, 2020)

Here Is What Republican Voters Really Believe in. It's a Shame the GOP Has No Idea

guTTing america ... going back --- on Track

“The ElecTion is Over”... Trump HaTer Cindy McCain Trashes Arizona ElecTion AudiT ---“Ludicrous” (VIDEO)

DissidenT Episcopalians awarded $100 million worTh of property ... as U.S. Supreme CourT --- declines To Take up Fort WorTh case

Joe Biden needs to stop lying about the cause of the border crisis and start fixing it

George W. Bush says ... The Republican ParTy has a shoT aT fuTure elecTions if iT curbs --- iTs 'whiTe Anglo-Saxon ProTesTanTism' ( heriTage )

BREAKING EXCLUSIVE - TGP’s Jordan Conradson InTerviews AZ AudiT DirecTor Ken BenneTT — HUGE DEVELOPMENTS ... Including Plans To Triple OuTpuT --- QuesTions on Number of FraudulenT BalloTs (VIDEO)

Can Democrats Avoid a Wipeout in 2022?

Biden declares war on America -- literally

Former Trump assisTanT says ... 'freighT Train' of elecTion resulT audiTs coming --- 'The MAGA movemenT is demanding answers'

Tim Scott's 2024 Star Rises After Biden Rebuttal

“We Will Find MisTakes – IrregulariTies ... We Probably Are Going To Find OuTright Fraud” --- AZ GOP Chair Dr. Kelli Ward Give - UpdaTe on HisToric AudiT (VIDEO)

Australia security official warns nations are ‘beating drums’ of war amid Asia-Pacific tensions

Former Obama White House advisor Seth Andrew arrested, accused of stealing from charter school he founded

This is fo sucking funny ... Joe has no clue --- The dumbocrap leaders are in a hearT aTTack panic!!.

The voter suppression lie

War Room ... Rachel Maddow Is Worried abouT whaT AZ ElecTion AudiT will Find — She Knows Georgia Is NexT

Conspiracy Queen Rachel Maddow ... Panics Over --- ‘Dangerous’ Arizona Vote AudiT

‘True To iTs docTrine’ ... ConservaTives plan for a new church afTer UniTed MeThodism spliTs --- over homosexualiTy debaTe

Michael Eric Dyson - WhiTe People Can Help BLM ...by Holding RacisT RelaTives --- ‘To AccounT’ aT Thanksgiving

Derek Chauvin ... The GreaT --- WhiTe DefendanT

New Mexico state trooper executed by Mexican cartel member… Horrific Video

John Kerry in Earth Day wonderland

Democrats Are Cheaters

Derek Chauvin's FaTe ... Is Now in The Hands --- of The Jury

Fools' overture

Democrats Are Terrified of Georgia

Climate Media vs. Climate Science

Why We Black Leaders Support Voter ID Laws

Pelosi: ‘No Plans' to Bring a Court-Packing Bill to the House Floor – at This Time

B-1 Bombers Are Deploying To Norway For The First Time With An Eye On Nearby Russia And The Arctic

High School Coach Fired After Refusing To Enforce “Insane” Outdoor Masks During Sports

CNN Says Chinese-Style Fonts Are Racist

Gran Torino Denounced for Anti-Asian Racism

'It Is Still Not Safe To Go Outside,' Says Fauci's Head In A Jar In Year 2739

Biden Re-Ignites the Waco Fire

Over 500 White People Have Been Killed By Cops Since 2020. There Has Been No Rioting Over Those Deaths.


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

LEFT WING LOONS
See other LEFT WING LOONS Articles

Title: Maine Decision Asks ShifTed Supreme Court To Decide ... If Only ATheisTs --- Can ConTrol Public EducaTion Funds
Source: thefederalist.com
URL Source: https://thefederalist.com/2020/11/0 ... ontrol-public-education-funds/
Published: Nov 2, 2020
Author: Joy Pullmann
Post Date: 2020-11-02 14:24:22 by BorisY
Keywords: huTus mau maus devilcraTs, huTus mau maus devilcraTs, huTus mau maus devilcraTs
Views: 128
Comments: 1

Maine Decision Asks Shifted Supreme Court To Decide If Only Atheists Can Control Public Education Funds

The First Circuit's open admittance that public schools discriminate against religion presents a new Establishment Clause question to the Supreme Court.

By Joy Pullmann

NOVEMBER 2, 2020

Because Christian schools openly encourage students’ faith, they are not eligible for Maine’s longstanding school choice program, a federal court of appeals ruled Thursday. Three families had sued to receive equal access to a longstanding state program that funds private education for children whose local district does not run a high school, which is about half of districts in the mostly rural state.

But the schools these families wanted to attend proclaim they have, for example, a “thoroughly Christian and biblical worldview” and “a mission of ‘instilling a Biblical worldview’ in its students, with religious instruction ‘completely intertwined’ in its curriculum and the Bible as its ‘final authority in all matters,'” noted U.S. First Circuit Judge David Barron, an Obama appointee, in the decision. Barron was joined unanimously by former Supreme Court Justice David Souter and Reagan appointee Circuit Judge Bruce Selya.

Because these schools see teaching Christianity as inseparable from all their other instruction, Barron wrote, they may not receive taxpayer funds. The decision says taxpayer dollars may not fund “the religious purposes of inculcation and proselytization” — so long as that proselytization is for any religion except secularism.

The ruling says taxpayer funds may only support instruction that promotes secularism among children. Secularism’s religious beliefs include the assumption that either God does not exist or His potential existence has nothing to do with educating. These are religious beliefs the decision says Maine may and does subsidize through public schools.

Barron’s decision says that because Maine has decided its public schools may discriminate against religion by providing a strictly secular education, and its school-choice program only allows students to access private schools that are “equivalent” to a public education, then students may not attend Christian schools via its choice program because such schools do not offer an “equivalent” education to the state’s legally anti-religion public schools.

In other words, this decision says that in schooling taxpayers must subsidize only one religious view, secularism, but no other religious views, such as those from Christianity, Mormonism, or Islam. It reinforces secularism as the only permissible state-sponsored American civil religion.

About half the states in the nation have tuition voucher programs similar to Maine’s, noted EdChoice Vice President Leslie Hiner to Courthouse News Service, meaning this decision has national implications. The parents’ lawyers promised to immediately appeal the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court has historically affirmed the constitutionality of school vouchers, and with three Supreme Court justices appointed by Republican President Donald Trump, it is likely they will do so again if they agree to take up this case. The Roberts court has also issued significant First Amendment rulings that reinforce prior courts’ affirmation that vouchers are constitutional.

The court has found voucher programs do not violate the First Amendment’s ban on government preferencing one religion on the grounds that if vouchers result in allowing public funds to go to religious institutions they do so based on individual families’ choices rather than the choice of the state. In other words, with vouchers the state funds families, not religious institutions. Nearly half of families say a private school is their top choice, but only one in ten enroll their children in that top choice, largely because public funds for education serve special interests instead of families’ preferences.

Religious institutions receive voucher funds only if families choose them, rather than through a specific state preference like public schools receive. The reason voucher programs end up largely supporting Christian schools is that a Christian education is only available outside public schools.

A good deal of research has found that legal preferences against religion in public education are a major contributing factor for the loss of faith across the Western world. Societies that erode Christianity among the next generation pay a severe price. Today’s historically unprecedented faith recession is clearly linked to financially and emotionally devastating social consequences, such as dramatic declines in marriage, work, and childbearing and increases in theft, murder, and child abuse.

“[Ex]pansions in government service provision and especially increasingly secularized government control of education significantly drive secularization and can account for virtually the entire increase in secularization around the developed world,” writes sociologist Lyman Stone in a review of research on this question (emphasis added). “The decline in religiosity in America is not the product of a natural change in preferences, but an engineered outcome of clearly identifiable policy choices.”

Government preferences for secularization as a religious view that competes with Christianity (and other faiths) create a more dependent and despairing society. For those who care about social justice as measured purely in materialistic terms, Christian schools have a protective, poverty-reducing effect on children, especially disadvantaged children, compared to public schools.

Poor children who attend Christian schools are set up for greater life happiness as measured in longer-lasting marriages and higher educational attainment. Compared to public-school graduates, children who attend Christian schools have substantially higher rates of civic engagement and patriotism and lower levels of intolerance and racism.

Secularists are willing to trade these benefits that accrue disproportionately to the poor in order to use public institutions to proselytize their own religious ideas. This was obvious in other aspects of the First Circuit’s ruling in the Maine case, such as in noting the Christian schools in question would not employ teachers who openly support homosexual behavior. The current Supreme Court seems to understand that giving secularism de facto control of public funds is also an establishment of religion. Yet so far its rulings have not gone so far as to find this unconstitutional, likely because of the disruption such a ruling would bring to the nation’s public school system.

Instead, the Roberts court’s jurisprudence has focused on making it clear that banning private institutions from public funds based solely on their religious nature is unconstitutional discrimination. That is what it found this spring in the Espinoza v. Montana decision, which concluded the state could not withhold charitable contributions from Christian schools because they are Christian.

“Drawing on ‘enduring American tradition,’ we have long recognized the rights of parents to direct ‘the religious upbringing’ of their children,” wrote Chief Justice John Roberts in the Espinoza majority opinion. “Many parents exercise that right by sending their children to religious schools, a choice protected by the Constitution.”

Roberts elsewhere noted that states do not need to subsidize private schooling at all. But once they do so, he wrote in the Espinoza decision, they must not discriminate against religious schools. A question the court has yet to consider is whether public education itself discriminates against religion by its open preference for secular religious viewpoints. The First Circuit’s open admittance that public schools discriminate against religion presents a new Establishment Clause question to the Supreme Court.

Given, however, Roberts’ abundance of caution that makes him now the swing vote on a newly conservative court, it’s unlikely the court addresses this deeper prejudice embedded inside American schooling if it decides to take up the Maine case.

Joy Pullmann is executive editor of The Federalist, a happy wife, and the mother of six children. Her newest ebooks are"Classic Books for Young Children" and "32 Classic Games You Can Play Anywhere." @JoyPullmann is also the author of "The Education Invasion: How Common Core Fights Parents for Control of American Kids," from Encounter Books.


Poster Comment:

taxpayers must subsidize only one religious view, secularism, but no other religious views,

pc unigod - unisTaTe - uniworld

noT To be challenged - denied - quesTioned - disobeyed

church / sTaTe - anTichrist - marxisT liberals

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: BorisY (#0)

Yet so far its rulings have not gone so far as to find this unconstitutional, likely because of the disruption such a ruling would bring to the nation’s public school system.

This, and the idea that the "public" in the public school system does not even remotely see secularism as an organized religion. In fact, the public does not recognize itself as "secularists" in any sense. [Unless things have changed recently]

Good article.

Ideally, Christians should not seek a penny from the government in order to finance their Christian lives. I paid for every aspect of my children's education, all the while paying property/school taxes to finance the local liberal indoctrination center. However, not every Christian family can do homeschooling as we did. Those families should at least be exempt a certain percentage of their school tax to put toward the education methods of their choice. Call 'em vouchers.

watchman  posted on  2020-11-02   18:53:03 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com