[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

COVID-19: Perfect Cover for Mandatory Biometric ID

MN Senator and Doctor: Hospitals Get Paid More to List Patients as COVID-19 and Three Times as Much if the Patient Goes on Ventilator

We Want Names! President Trump Says "Two Very Smart People" Came into His Office and Urged Him to Lock Down Economy or 2.2 Million Americans Would Die (VIDEO)

Florida City Closes Barbershops Because of Coronavirus, but the Cops Are Still Getting Haircuts

A Georgia bar owner removed $3,714 worth of bills stapled to the walls to give to her unemployed staff

Covid-19 had us all fooled, but now we might have finally found its secret.

Worldwide coronavirus response violates Nuremberg Code

Bill Gates My Father Headed Planned Parenthood

Why stores could start taking customers’ temperatures

They drove us mad with Corona

The Latest Death Count

Thank You to the Mother Who Brought Her Son to the Playground

Liberal Nonsense Is Looking Dumber Than Ever Now

Epidemiologist: Coronavirus Could Be ‘Exterminated’ if Lockdowns Lifted

Dr. Ron Paul: Resistance is Building to Coronavirus “House Arrest” Orders…It’s About Time!

Bill Gates Crosses The Digital Rubicon, Says "Mass Gatherings" May Not Return Without Global Vaccine

HUGE! MN Senator and Dr. Reveals HHS Document Coached Him on How to Overcount COVID-19 Cases -- WITH COPY OF DOCUMENT

Activists To Protest Coronavirus Restrictions With Rally On National Mall In D.C.

Lockdown Message: You Have NO Rights

Calif. Sheriff: We’ll Arrest Anyone Not Wearing a Mask

Pastor Tony Spell: Why I Love Him

LOUISIANA PASTOR If Parishioners Die After Contracting COVID-19 ... IT'S A SACRIFICE FOR GOD AND FREEDOM!!!

Charlotte Figi, Who Showed Americans the Value of Medical Marijuana, Dies of COVID-19 at Age 13

Neocons Seethe Over Claim Rand Paul, Tucker Carlson Pushing For Trump to Appoint Col. Douglas Macgregor

Woke Leftists Upset Over Christian Organzation Setting Up Hospital for Coronavirus Patients

Dr. Anthony Fauci Plotted ‘Global Vaccine Action Plan’ with Bill Gates Before Pushing COVID Panic and Doubts About Hydroxychloroquine Treatments

Another Coronavirus Side Effect: In-Home Surveillance By Remote Workers' Employers

Dennis Quaid breaks from Hollywood pack, praises Trump, faces immediate scorn

Learn to Recognize Your Negative Thinking Traps

Get Rid of Your Thinking Errors

Cops Violate Social Distancing to Arrest Innocent Dad for Playing in a Park with 6yo Daughter

To Enforce Social Distancing Rules, Cops Fined a Pennsylvania Woman Who Was Driving Alone

W.H.O Official ~ Entering Your Homes Soon…’Cause you Brought it Home’

Prepare To Have Your Worldview Obliterated

Presumptively Corona’d?

Rescindable Options

Tucker: Data Suggests Coronavirus Epidemic Peak ‘Passed Five Days Ago’

100 Bible Verses about Submission To Authority

John Prine, One of America’s Greatest Songwriters, Dead at 73

Why Do People Interpret The Bible Differently?

April’s Pink Supermoon Around The World, In Photos

Leaked Transcript of Trump/Biden Cal

The Day the White House Press Corps Went Full ChiCom Propaganda

This Is The Most PATHETIC Smear Against President Trump We Have Seen Yet

'Prayers needed': Two pastors from Raleigh church hospitalized for coronavirus

NC church service linked to coronavirus cluster

Kansas clusters tied to church gatherings

Redding church linked to coronavirus cases

Colorado Man Handcuffed in Front of His 6-Year-Old Daughter at Park For 'Violating Social Distancing Order'

“They called it wrong”: Trump Declares “Powerful Hold” on Funding “China-centric” W.H.O.


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

United States News
See other United States News Articles

Title: A Michigan Police Task Force Is Playing Jurisdiction Games To Avoid Compensating an Innocent Man Cops Put in the Hospital
Source: Reason
URL Source: https://reason.com/2020/02/19/a-mic ... -man-cops-put-in-the-hospital/
Published: Feb 19, 2020
Author: Scott Shackford
Post Date: 2020-02-19 23:07:43 by Deckard
Keywords: None
Views: 30

Kingphoto_1161x653

James King, post-beating in 2014. (Photo courtesy of Institute for Justice)

Courtesy of IJA young Michigan man was mistaken for a wanted criminal and assaulted by a couple of plainclothes cops so badly that he needed emergency medical treatment.

That's just where the awfulness began for James King as he was walking in Grand Rapids, Michigan, in 2014. Six years later, he's still trying to hold the officers involved responsible for their behavior in a case that may be heading all the way to the Supreme Court.

On that fateful July day, a detective with the Grand Rapids Police Department and a special agent with the FBI approached King, mistaking him for a man wanted for breaking into the home of a former employer and stealing. According to King, they didn't identify themselves but asked him questions, then pinned him against their SUV and took his wallet. King says he thought he was being mugged and attempted to run. The two officers then attacked King and beat him unconscious.

Bystanders who watched this happen also didn't realize that King's attackers were police. Some called the police and others filmed. When more police arrived, they ordered bystanders to delete video of the beating (some complied).

Rather than acknowledge they mistook King for someone else, police and prosecutors instead charged him with assaulting the police officers and resisting arrest. They tried to get him to accept a plea deal but King refused, forcing a trial and risking years in prison. While he was completely acquitted by a jury in 2015, the fight bankrupted his family.

King filed a lawsuit in 2016, accusing the two officers, Todd Allen of the Grand Rapids Police Department and FBI Special Agent Douglas Brownback, of violating his Fourth and 14th Amendment rights.

After filing the lawsuit, King and his attorney hit a huge jurisdictional problem. Those two officers were part of a multi-agency police task force, and neither the state nor the federal government are willing to say that the officers were operating under their jurisdictions. Even though the investigation and the crime wasn't a federal crime or the result of a federal investigation, the officers nevertheless attempted to claim federal immunity in Michigan courts.

King was represented by attorney Patrick Jaicomo, who has joined the liberty advocates at the Institute for Justice. They are now petitioning the Supreme Court to stop the police and the Department of Justice from ping-ponging responsibility for how King was treated. Beyond that, King's lawyers are challenging the concept of "qualified immunity" that law enforcement agencies use to shield themselves from lawsuits. The Institute for Justice has put up a page explaining the case and the background behind the lawsuit. They note about the jurisdictional games being played here that:

Applying these protective standards to the officers, the trial court held that James had guessed the wrong claims to bring against the officers, but even if he had not, the officers were entitled to qualified immunity because they could not have known that stopping, searching, beating and arresting an innocent person violated the Constitution.

Thankfully, the Sixth U.S. Court of Appeals reversed the trial court in every way but one, holding that the officers were not entitled to qualified immunity, but that they had acted under federal authority, not state authority … .

Now, the government has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to step in and provide additional protections for the officers—immunizing them from liability under a new interpretation of the Federal Tort Claims Act. At the same time, James has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to reject the government's new arguments for immunity and end to the shell game that allows officers to violate the Constitution without consequence.

Over at the Washington Post, former Reason editor Radley Balko helps untangle the mess of federal and state legal precedents and notes that the proliferation of these task forces has led to a number of examples where jurisdictional confusion is used to avoid accountability and responsibility. In Missouri, marijuana task forces avoid state-level public records requests by claiming to be federal agencies but then claim to be state agencies whenever anybody attempts to use the federal Freedom of Information Act to get information.

Balko also takes note of the deliberately complex and obtuse civil asset forfeiture law variances between state laws and the Department of Justice's "Equitable Sharing Program." This program allows many state and municipal law enforcement agencies to bypass state laws that put restrictions on how much they can seize and keep from the people they arrest by partnering with the FBI and Department of Justice and using the federal seizure system, with its looser rules, instead. Some states have had to pass new laws forbidding their own police from bypassing state restrictions and going to the feds. Others have allowed it to continue.

It's clear that these "task forces" are sometimes being used to shield law enforcement agencies from culpability for misbehavior and from having to comply with public records laws. The Institute for Justice put together a video explaining the complicated details of King's case in Brownback v. King. Watch below:

NEXT: America's Two Major Political Parties Are Melting Down. But the Two-Party System Remains Strong. (4 images)

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com