[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Trump Jr walks out of book launch after heckling from supporters

The Sad, Sad State Of Virginia

Let’s Invade Mexico! (Another Entry in the Tourney of Damn Fool Ideas)

Child Rape Stories Are Too ‘Stupid’ for ABC News to Cover

THOUGHT POLICE: Facebook, YouTube, Twitter all ban any mention of “whistleblower” Eric Ciaramella as the Overton Window of allowable speech collapses

AKA Stone onered with stachoo in his/hers/its/whuts liknis

Landmark Bill Would Bar State from Enforcing Federal Red-Flag Gun Laws

CNN Accidentally Airs the BEST PRO-GUN Commercial EVER!

Rachael Maddow Has Been Happily Married For 20 Years

Mormon families fleeing Mexico after violent attack arrive in Arizona

Baby Trump’ Balloon Slashed at Alabama Appearance

BREAKING: Rep. Devin Nunes Releases Requested Witness List for Adam Schiff’s Show Trial, Including: Hunter Biden, Adam Schiff, Alexandra Chalupa and Eric Ciaramella

AGW Taunts, Brutalizes Old Man

Cop Kills Two Innocent Girls, Gets Off Scot Free and Was Just Elected Mayor

Another Drug-War Massacre

Internet Owns NYPD After They Bragged About Stealing 106 lbs of LEGAL Hemp for Cancer Patients

Trump 'regularly stumbles, slurs and gets confused'

The Bloomberg Factor

Time for Some Drano in the Swamp

Gov. Ralph Northam confirms Virginia already 'working on' gun confiscation now that Democrats are in control

Study confirms TV industry is pushing homosexuality on network TV more and more each year…

Ohio detective dies after being shot twice in face during drug raid, police say

The Sissifying of America Continues (“Beat them, but not too badly” has no place in sports.)

AmericaÂ’s Largest Health Insurer Is Giving Apartments to Homeless People

Fake WhistleblowerÂ’s Lawyer Outs the Coup dÂ’etat in a Tweet

Federal judge strikes down rule allowing clinicians to object to abortions for moral or religious reasons

Oops! ADAM SCHIFF Accidentally Leaks Name of Anti-Trump ‘Whistleblower” Eric Ciaramella in Bill Taylor’s Transcript!

“It’s Going to Be Devastating. It’s Going to Ruin Careers” – Joe diGenova: IG Report Delayed Due to Durham Grand Jury – Several Obama DOJ Officials Will Be Indicted (VIDEO)

Social Media Increasingly Conduit for Surveillance and Voter Manipulation

Was he Lee ... was he PaTsy --- Was he Trying To Tell us someThing !

While You Slept, Government Created Internal Passports

Viral Meme Campaign Keeps Jeffrey Epstein Story Alive

Cop Charged after Allegedly Filming Himself Masturbate at a Concert Just Before Punching a Man

Woman Fights Back Against Charges for Using Cannabis to Treat Her Illness—and She WON

‘How did you kill Jeffrey Epstein?’ Hillary Clinton bursts into laughter over dead body joke… again

Fox News Poll: 49 percent favor impeaching Trump (BS)

Watch OAN reporter knock on Eric Ciaramella’s front door…

Death by Design

The Other '80s Blade Runner Movie

New York's Place as America's Fine-Dining Mecca in Jeopardy As City Bans Foie Gras

Brave, Compassionate Officer Tells "Why I Wear the Badge"

Bible verses about purgatory

Rage With The Machine? 90's Resistance Band Reunites To Do Establishment Bidding In 2020

$1 million in First Spouse gold coins wrongly sent for destruction (Fake News)

Video Shows Cop Jump Family’s Fence, Kill Dog in Front of 10 yo Girl

RaTcliffe ... raTs ouT --- The Schiff show…

The Deep State Has Been Redefined as "Career Bureaucrats Doing Their Patriotic Duty"

ROLLING STONES "WAITING FOR A FRIEND" **POP-UP VIDEO**, 1981

"Space Satellite" Crashes To Earth (Balloon & Tether still attached)

You may not believe this, but Greta Thunberg’s no air travel plan has hit a (hilarious) snag


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

U.S. Constitution
See other U.S. Constitution Articles

Title: Portland Police Review Board Says It's OK For Officers To Lie To Get Someone To Stop Filming Them
Source: TechDirt
URL Source: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/2 ... one-to-stop-filming-them.shtml
Published: Oct 16, 2019
Author: Tim Cushing
Post Date: 2019-10-20 17:28:52 by Deckard
Keywords: None
Views: 100

from the police-lie dept

The Portland Police Department's Review Board -- a board composed almost completely of police and government officials -- concluded it's OK for a cop to lie about the law to shut down recordings.

Police officers seem to struggle the most when it comes to understanding the rights and protections given to citizens. For years, officers have abused any number of inapplicable laws to arrest citizens who recorded them. When laws and policies were changed in response to court decisions, the abuse of laws continued. The only thing that changed were department policies, which some officers just decided to ignore.

This hasn't always worked out well for officers, who often end up in court with their immunity stripped. Those that don't progress as far as the federal court system, however, are left in the hands of local complaint review boards. Even when the board is more independent than Portland's, board recommendations for punishment are often ignored in favor of minimal or no discipline.

This case, covered by The Oregonian following the release of Police Review Board records, shows an officer knowingly lied about the law and got away with it.

The bureau’s Police Review Board found Sgt. Erin Smith didn’t knowingly violate the police directive on truthfulness.

Not even with the lying?

The sergeant acknowledged he misrepresented the law to get Kerensa to stop videotaping him during a Nov. 30, 2016, demonstration in front of fuel storage facilities in Northwest Portland over the Dakota Access Pipeline.

Smith admitted to falsely telling Kerensa that he didn't have the right to film officers and threatened Kerensa that he could be arrested if he didn’t stop.

So, how does an officer lie without violating a policy directive on "truthfulness?" As it turns out, there are a few convenient exceptions to this directive. First, officers are allowed to use deception for "legitimate law enforcement purposes." But telling someone the law forbade them from filming cops isn't a "legitimate law enforcement purpose."

That's the conclusion Portland PD Police Chief Danielle Outlaw (yes, that's her real name) reached. But she said this was more an issue of performance than a truthfulness violation because the officer admitted to lying about the law. Half-credit, I guess. The officer's direct supervisor was even more charitable.

Smith’s supervisor, Traffic Capt. Stephanie Lourenco, found Smith’s deception was permitted under an exception in the policy that says deception is permitted when “necessary to protect the physical safety’’ of an officer.

Lourenco did not explain how a passive recording threatened the officer's safety. The generous application of the deception exception encourages officers to invoke it any time they lie to citizens to get them to comply with unlawful orders. Good times. Thank god the PD is engaged in some form of oversight. Otherwise, we might be subjected to even stupider rationalizations...

[Board members] argued that Smith didn’t knowingly violate the directive and that “deception’’ is an acceptable de-escalation tactic.

Even assuming this was the sort of situation that necessitated a de-escalation, how does lying to people result in calmer interactions? Feeding a line of bullshit to a citizen who knows it's bullshit isn't going to nudge anything towards a more peaceful resolution. Making it a practice to lie to citizens just because you know multiple exceptions allow you to doesn't do anything to improve officers' relationships with the people they serve.

Fortunately, this exoneration got a second pass from the city's far more independent Citizen Review Committee, which was thoroughly unimpressed with the PRB's logic. Chief Outlaw agreed to take a second look at the case the PRB had refused to act on. But in the end, lying to citizens about their right to record is only worth about one day's pay. Cops willing to spin the Wheel O' Accountability may find it pays off more often than not, especially when the PRB is willing to make almost any excuse for an officer's bad behavior.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com