[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Sharing Memes – Man Ends Up Red Flagged

Pre-Crime Hysteria Sweeps the Nation as Dozens are Arrested for Making Internet and Social Media ‘Threats’

Court Rules Cop Who Shot Unarmed 15-Year-Old Is Protected by Qualified Immunity

Florida Cops Arrest a 15-Year-Old Boy for Joking About Perpetrating a Mass Shooting

The Republican Party is never going back [to Reaganism]

Will Joe Walsh’s primary challenge to Trump backfire?

Detroit man charged with murder in death of girl, 9, who was killed by pit bulls

Trump May Issue Exec Order Ending Citizenship For Babies Of Illegal Immigrants: Calls It ‘Frankly Ridiculous’

Afghan forces and U.S. coalition allies have killed more civilians in 2019 than the Taliban

Five elderly men and an 85-year-old woman are arrested for 'having public sex in a Connecticut woodland'

Fresno police officer punches innocent teen multiple times

Could CANNABIS be the Key to Curing Pancreatic Cancer?

Philly Cop-Shooter Was Federal Informant

Secretive warfare training being staged in 21 North Carolina counties, Army says

Cleveland cop allegedly filmed himself urinating on girl at school bus stop

Michigan Court of Appeals Has Reversed the Felony Assault Convictions of a Gun Owner Who Acted in Self-Defense

Saloon owner: Nugget, Sparks city officials strong-arming him to raise prices

‘I am the chosen one’

The Process of Damockrisy

Portrait of a Politician

If “Emissions” Actually Mattered . . .

Happy Birthday, Ron

Law Enforcement To Flag & Spy On "Future" Criminals

Joe Biden's brain surgeon is defending Joe Biden's brain

Seth Rich Murder Update: FBI Claims They Didn’t Investigate but NSA Claims Can’t Disclose Files Due to Matter of National Security

Bartow sheriff's deputy fired, fiancee arrested over confrontation

LAPD Shoots Unarmed Homeless Man over Noise Complaint from Neighbor

Siege at Ruby Ridge: The Forgotten History of the ATF Shootout That Started a Militia Movement

Republican Palestinian-American is sole vote against anti-Semitism monitor

Oberlin College is a microcosm of our society ... The governing class assumes we must be motivated by racism - white supremacy - sexism - patriarchy - Naziism - fascism - etc - etc - etc - by all things bad.

Just A Few Points To Ponder

Planned Parenthood abandons Title X federal funds after Trump rule prohibits abortion referrals

Antidepressants AGAIN: Dayton shooter found to have mind-altering SSRI drugs in his system

HOTCARS Are Coming

NYPD Cop Danny Pantaleo Fired over Eric Garner's Death; Loses Retirement Pension

'I'm not happy with it': Trump hits Fox News over poll results

Psychedelic Drugs Are Finally Being Used to Treat Depression in US Hospitals

Wilsonville woman in custody battle over daughter with cancer - for successfully treating her cancer with CBD Oil

Rep. Pete King is the first Republican to sign on to the assault weapons ban

Trump's Farm Bailout Flows To "City Slickers," a D.C. Lobbyist and ‘Farms’ on Golf Courses

A New Mexico Man Accused A Deputy Of ‘Gestapo’-Like Training. Then He Was Arrested.

Bernie Sanders Calls For Legalization Of Marijuana And Safe Injection Sites

The Southern Poverty Law Center is a hate-based scam that nearly caused me to be murdered

Activist Post Applies For NewsGuard’s Coveted “Conspiracy” Blacklist

Cherish Your Privacy? New Anti-Surveillance Clothes Trick Cameras by Making You Look Like a Car

Only 29 Percent Of Americans Believe Jeffrey Epstein Committed Suicide

"Foreign Policy" Goes Into Propaganda Overdrive: 'White Supremacists Want A Nuclear Weapon'

Worse Than Ever: Government Schools After 35 Years

Release of official autopsy showing broken bones in Jeffrey Epstein’s neck is all the proof we need that he’s still ALIVE… here’s why

Cokey Roberts on Meet The Press defines gun control


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

International News
See other International News Articles

Title: Afghanistan Isn't Worth Dying For
Source: The National Interest
URL Source: https://nationalinterest.org/blog/s ... anistan-isnt-worth-dying-67392
Published: Jul 16, 2019
Author: Daniel L. Davis
Post Date: 2019-07-22 09:02:03 by Deckard
Keywords: None
Views: 120
Comments: 6

Rewarding broken promises, waste, and incompetence is offensive to the sacrifices of our troops.

Army Sgt. Maj. James Sartor was killed in action in Afghanistan’s Faryab Province on Saturday. He was “only” the twelfth soldier to die there this year. That makes his death no less inexcusable, no less an unacceptable sacrifice for Washington’s failed foreign policy.

What do we tell Sartor’s family? That he heroically “gave the last full measure” for the defense of our nation? In some conflicts in American history, that might have been true. But in Afghanistan, it is a trite and insulting bromide.

This man, like the eleven that preceded him this year, sacrificed his life in an operation that provided no benefit to our country. America is not safer because of this supreme, excruciatingly painful sacrifice. The truth is that hardly any Americans pay any attention to our war in Afghanistan and fewer still genuinely care that another trooper has tragically been killed.

Instead, the entire burden of the grief—the unquenchable, searing pain of loss—falls to a tiny number of family members and close friends of those who died. My blood boils in anger when I hear—as I have many times—some callously claim, “Hey man, nobody forced them to sign up. They volunteered and knew what they were getting themselves into.” This implies that we service members forfeit the value of our life once we raise our right hand.

I often wonder whether those who make such comments would feel different if it were their cherished son, daughter, husband, or wife whose death was so casually brushed aside. The answer is obvious. And that answer highlights the growing imperative that we should no longer stand for the pointless sacrifice of one more American life in Afghanistan.

U.S. envoy Zalmay Khalilzad is feverishly trying to negotiate an end to American military involvement in the war. That means Sartor lost his life while waiting for the order to withdraw. He died without even the pretense that we are there serving a valid military mission, fighting what has been an exercise in arrogant futility since at least the summer of 2002 (outside of the original operation, our objectives have never been militarily achievable).

That should be unconscionable. The lives of the men and women who serve our country in uniform should be treasured to such a degree that they are only asked to risk their lives when our country is in peril—not because Washington has failed to do the hard work of preserving their lives while the end of the mission is being negotiated. 

This becomes ever more obvious as the end of the war draws nigh. Khalilzad’s team and the Taliban both report they are shooting for resolution by September 1. There are no more military objectives to reach. Only two questions remain: When the withdrawal will begin and how fast it will occur? Any loss of life is tragic, but in these circumstances especially it would be beyond pointless and heartbreaking should one single more American die during the wrap-up of this disastrous war.

Beginning immediately, President Donald Trump should end routine combat operations in Afghanistan. Unless a direct threat to U.S. security is identified, our troops should not engage any enemy forces, should stop conducting “presence patrols,” and should not participate in any missions outside the wire. Our troops should protect diplomatic personnel and other U.S. personnel, conduct robust force protection operations, and in all cases defend themselves from any attack so long as they are in Afghanistan—but that’s it. 

Second, the period of withdrawal set by the U.S.-Taliban talks must be swift. While the foreign-policy establishment insists that pulling out “prematurely” would be a strategic mistake, the claim that any withdrawal pace after eighteen years of perpetual failure could be considered “premature” is laughable.

If an agreement is reached in September, then there is nothing strategic to gain by dragging out our exit schedule over multiple years, as is rumored to be under consideration. An orderly withdrawal could and should be initiated as fast as is practical after the signing of the agreement, and completed in months, not years.

Third, the United States should stand ready to continue diplomatic engagement with all relevant parties and, where it makes sense for American interests, provide economic assistance to Afghanistan for a fixed period. We should not, however, give any more money without stringent conditions, requiring the recipients to meet reasonable performance goals.

If those goals are not met, then we owe it to American service members to hold recipients accountable and cut off further funding. Rewarding broken promises, waste, and incompetence is offensive to the sacrifices of our troops.

Finally, we must openly acknowledge that it is possible that Afghanistan’s civil war, which our attack in October of 2001 interrupted, could resume once our troops withdraw. What must also be acknowledged, however, is that our perpetual military intervention for nearly two decades has not ended the fighting; if we don’t withdraw, then high levels of civilian suffering will likely continue, without relief, into perpetuity.

Too many U.S. military members have sacrificed their lives for no gain to our country, dying in a war that can’t be won by military means. It is time to end this pointless sacrifice of American lives. The time is now.

Daniel L. Davis is a senior fellow for Defense Priorities and a former lieutenant colonel in the U.S. Army who retired in 2015 after twenty-one years, including four combat deployments. Follow him @DanielLDavis1. The views in the article are those of the author alone and do not represent any group.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: Deckard (#0)

" Too many U.S. military members have sacrificed their lives for no gain to our country, dying in a war that can’t be won by military means. It is time to end this pointless sacrifice of American lives. The time is now. "

I have to agree with the colonel !!!!

We have wasted way too much American blood & treasure in these foreign adventures!!!

It has only benefited the globalists !!!

Si vis pacem, para bellum

Rebellion to tyrants is obedience to God.

"If there are no dogs in Heaven, then when I die I want to go where they went." (Will Rogers)

"No one ever rescues an old dog. They lay in a cage until they die. PLEASE save one. None of us wants to die cold and alone... --Dennis Olson "

People that say money can't buy you happiness, have never paid an adoption fee

Stoner  posted on  2019-07-22   9:10:53 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: Deckard (#0)

Afghanistan Isn't Worth Dying For

Removing Al Qaeda was worth dying for, the rest is just imperialism

paraclete  posted on  2019-07-22   9:13:57 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#3. To: Deckard (#0)

There are always a few late tragic deaths before the end of a long stalemated war. WW I, WW II, etc. So this is not news, it's inevitable if you have more than a handful of troops exposed to a hostile enemy. Even more so if your opponent is Muslim and any loser can go for his 72 virgins by killing an enemy.

Beginning immediately, President Donald Trump should end routine combat operations in Afghanistan. Unless a direct threat to U.S. security is identified, our troops should not engage any enemy forces, should stop conducting “presence patrols,” and should not participate in any missions outside the wire. Our troops should protect diplomatic personnel and other U.S. personnel, conduct robust force protection operations, and in all cases defend themselves from any attack so long as they are in Afghanistan—but that’s it.

Well, it sounds good but we have had a fair number of troops and officers killed on or inside their own bases. Even if Trump did as the writer suggests, it is no guarantee against further losses.

We'll certainly have more losses before we withdraw from Af/Pak.

Tooconservative  posted on  2019-07-22   10:20:40 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#4. To: Tooconservative (#3)

Afghanistan: "The place where empires go to die."

rustynail  posted on  2019-07-24   19:40:55 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#5. To: rustynail (#4)

Afghanistan: "The place where empires go to die."

another place Trump could wipe off the map if he was so inclined

paraclete  posted on  2019-07-24   20:08:08 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#6. To: rustynail (#4)

Afghanistan: "The place where empires go to die."

Afghanistan: the place where American soldiers still go to die for no good reason that any of the pols can explain.

Tooconservative  posted on  2019-07-25   15:13:35 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com