[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Leave the US, Trump tells liberal congresswomen of color

In Iran, some take off their hijabs as hard-liners push back

Wilbury Twist

Trump Consiglieres Giuliani and Bolton Paid Big Bucks by MEK Terrorist Group

The Untold Story of Christian Zionism’s Rise to Power in the United States

The Death of Privacy: Government Fearmongers to Read Your Mail

Real Hedge-Fund Managers Have Some Thoughts on What Epstein Was Actually Doing

Nellis AFB security forces anti-terrorism squad commander relieved of duty following 1 October massacre. But why?

Was Jeffrey Epstein a “State Department cut out”?

Trump's Congressional Reform Act

Book: Paul Ryan Slammed Trump for Calling Stormy Daniels ‘Horse Face’

Most Veterans Say Iraq, Afghanistan Wars Weren't Worth It

US Fast-Food Drive-Thrus Will Soon Use License Plate And Facial Recognition Technology

The Death of Privacy

Florida Sheriff Deputy Arrested After Planting Drugs on Innocent People

This Cop Is Getting $2,500 a Month Because Killing an Unarmed Man in a Hotel Hallway Gave Him PTSD

British navy to Iran: Back the hell off

Court Upholds Conviction Of Cop Who Threatened, Beat, Tased, And Arrested A Man For Complaining About Being Beaten By Him Earlier

Megan Rapinoe Drops the F-Bomb to End the Speech: ‘New York City, You’re the Motherf—-ing Best’

Flashback: Billionaire Pedophile Jeffrey Epstein Sent Bill Clinton $3.5 Million From Secret Swiss Bank Account

The President’s Son Was ATTACKED While With Friends In Chicago — Secret Service SWARM!

Why Baseballs Are Flying in 2019

Bouton, ex-Yankee and 'Ball Four' author, dies

Anderson Cooper Giddily Tells Megan Rapinoe He Wants to ‘Hang out’ with Her

Americans Shocked to Find Their Rights Literally Vanish at U.S. Airports

Bombshell: Alex Acosta Reportedly Claimed Jeffrey Epstein "Belonged To Intelligence"

HILLARY RELEGATED TO THE DUSTBIN OF HISTORY

Greg Abbott Is About to Make Austin Regret Its Desire to Become Like California In Its Homeless Problem

Trump defends Home Depot co-founder after shoppers threaten boycott

The Heart of Darkness: The Sexual Predators Within America’s Power Elite

Jeffrey Epstein's Wikipedia Page Stealth-Edited To Remove Ties To Democrats

How socialism violates all Ten Commandments

Citizens Now Charged with a Crime for Repairing Their Own Car in Their Own Driveway

Daily marijuana use increasing among young adults

Despite Legalization, Adolescent Marijuana Use Hits 15-Year Low

An Iowa Man Wins His Free Speech Suit After Being Charged for a Facebook Rant Against a Cop

Government Bullies Want to Seize This Man's Home Because of Overgrown Grass

WATCH: Surveillance Video Shows Group Of About 60 Teens Vandalizing, Looting Walgreens On South Street

Why the Earth is actually 100% flat

A Glass of Wine

Michelle Obama Gets Personal: ‘Yes, I Support ... Great Sex at Every Age’

Gen Z Adults Encourage Each Other To Sign Up For Facial Recognition At Music Festivals

Pelosi says Trump is trying to ‘Make America White Again’ with census question

Camera-Shy Antifa Hits Washington D.C.

Frog-Marching Trump Toward War on Iran

Chicago Cops Taser Man Four Times in Front of his Kids for Recording them

How to Create a Gun-Free America in 5 Easy Steps

Kentucky man is told giving used glasses to the homeless is against the law

Bill Clinton Denies Knowing Anything About His Pedophile Friend Jeffery Epstein But Flight Logs Show Otherwise

Someone with a website claims The Creation Account in Genesis Describes A Flat Earth and Teaches True Science


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

U.S. Constitution
See other U.S. Constitution Articles

Title: Students Make A Video Depicting A School Shooting; Sheriff Decides Everyone Needs To Have Their Rights Violated
Source: TechDirt
URL Source: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/2 ... ve-their-rights-violated.shtml
Published: Dec 28, 2018
Author: Tim
Post Date: 2019-01-02 06:50:36 by Deckard
Keywords: None
Views: 133
Comments: 9

from the if-he's-lucky,-he'll-only-face-one-lawsuit dept

Heightened sensitivities and a law enforcement track record of overreaction has prompted a New York Sheriff's Office into actions that will probably result in at least one civil rights lawsuit. When students of a New York school decided to create a couple of videos and post them to Instagram, the Sheriff felt compelled to violate the students' Fourth Amendment rights after disregarding their First Amendment rights.

Three students face felony charges of making a terroristic threat for posting online two brief videos where they act out a school shooting in someone’s house.

[...]

The Albany County Sheriff’s Office said the videos were made by Ravena-Coeymans-Selkirk students aged 10, 14 and 15 and posted to Instagram. They show a student with a fake gun barging into a living room and “shooting” two other students. In one video, students, who are all white, use a racial epithet.

Sheriff Craig Apple called the videos “very graphic, very racist and horrifying.”

Lots of movies, books, TV shows, and videogames contain "graphic and horrifying" content. Some even include "racist" dialogue, just as this video did. At no point did any of the participants mention a school, mention an intent to perform these acts at a school, or even tag other students/schools in the posting. It was simply a dramatization of events that happen far too often in this country.

The videos were noticed by a student of the school the three arrested students attended. No one's faulting the school for handing over the videos to law enforcement, but the sheriff's office should have recognized the students were engaging in protected speech, not issuing terroristic threats. A simple conversation about why the videos might be disturbing to others should have been the end of it. Instead, there are now three arrests and a bunch of civil rights lawyers pointing out exactly why these arrests should not have occurred.

Manhattan civil rights lawyer and television commentator Ron Kube said the videos don’t rise to the level of terroristic threat because there was no specific target or agenda. “This appears to be a wild overreaction driven by the legitimate concerns about school shootings,” Kube said Monday.

Civil rights lawyer Normal Siegel, former executive director of the New York Civil Liberties Union, also said there was no terroristic threat and that the videos appeared to be an attempt at acting.

“The arrests raise serious and substantial First Amendment concerns,” said Siegel. “Making a video is protected by the First Amendment.”

Content disturbing to others is present in a lot of content. Just because this dramatization happened to be produced by students and distributed by Instagram doesn't somehow entitle it to less First Amendment protection than a motion picture released by a major studio. Just because the participants happened to be school students doesn't mean their speech is less protected than someone with a multi-million dollar budget.

Sheriff Craig Apple's speech -- as moronic as it is -- is also protected by the same First Amendment he won't extend to these students.

There’s been enough shootings going on around the country. This is despicable artistic expression, if that’s what it was.”

Sheriff Apple is free to hate the expressive speech. But he's not free to arrest people for speech he doesn't like. And all the "but what if a shooting actually happened?" excuses don't make this any less of a compound civil rights violation.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

Begin Trace Mode for Comment # 9.

#1. To: Deckard (#0)

"At no point did any of the participants mention a school, mention an intent to perform these acts at a school, or even tag other students/schools in the posting."

From the Associated Press:

"In one video, the “shooter” says “I’ve always hated school” before pretending to fire a toy gun at a boy sitting on the couch and a girl writhing on the floor."

misterwhite  posted on  2019-01-02   10:10:51 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: misterwhite (#1)

"In one video, the “shooter” says “I’ve always hated school” before pretending to fire a toy gun at a boy sitting on the couch and a girl writhing on the floor."

Oh, he mentioned the word "school"?

Pretty lame, even for you bobby boy.

He didn't mention a particular school, did he now?

Deckard  posted on  2019-01-02   10:22:21 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#8. To: Deckard (#2)

The defendants will have an opportunity to have a pre-lim to determine if LE had enough probable cause to have made the arrest. Then the defendants will have an opportunity to have a trial by a jury of their PEERS... if a pre-lim determines enough probable cause. THEN if the defendants are found guilty, they will have ample opportunities to file motions all the way up to the USSC to get their convictions overturned on the basis of “1st & 4th” amendment violations.

So shut your fucking mouth. You aren’t a legal or constitutional authority. You are simply an online anarchist opinionated asshole... aka little people.

GrandIsland  posted on  2019-01-03   18:29:15 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#9. To: GrandIsland (#8)

Deckard does tend to get ahead of himself -- he looks at an arrest as tantamount to life imprisonment -- skipping the 20 steps in between.

misterwhite  posted on  2019-01-04   9:15:49 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


Replies to Comment # 9.

        There are no replies to Comment # 9.


End Trace Mode for Comment # 9.

TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com