[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Non-citizens legally register to vote in San Francisco school elections

Why Libertarianism is wrong

Nunes declares war on the media

First Win for Trump-Putin Summit: Agreement to Restrain Iran in Syria

Update: Mueller Suspected of Giving Podesta Brothers Immunity to Indict Manafort and Is HIDING THIS FROM PUBLIC

Crowdstrike Analyst Who Ran Forensics on DNC Server Used to Work For Mueller at FBI

Bill Maher vs. an intelligent Christian (Maher loses). *mirror*

Ladies Professional Golf Association using facial recognition technology to surveil fans and spectators

The world’s most nutritious foods

Papa John's founder 'isn't going quietly,' lawyer says — Schnatter just dragged Kanye West into fight with the board

New Kentucky Law Puts Limits on Drone Spying, Will Help Thwart Federal Surveillance Program

What To Learn From The Social Justice Warrior Who Was Eaten By His Own Mob

Is the Media the “Enemy of the People”?

Well, I think I am going to have to schedule a surgery


Las Vegas Police Body Cam: Cop Fires Through Windshield

3 Problems With Libertarianism - After Economics

Brazile, Rice, Obama Gave Russian Hackers Free Rein

The irrational hysteria over Trump and Putin

John Brennan Misses Communist Russia

The Latest: Trump says he misspoke on Russia meddling

Cop Charged After Video Shows Him Execute Unarmed Mother by Shooting Her in the Head

Cop Encounters Tortoise Going Too Slow on Highway, Overcomes His Fear and Doesn't Shoot.

Keeping Cops’ Hands Out of Your Pockets

Trump-Putin Summit Success: Neocons Furious!

Mandalay Bay's owner MGM has sued the Las Vegas mass shooting victims, claiming it's not liable for the massacre

Eric July On Why The Only Rights Are ‘Negative Rights’

Russian woman charged with being Putin’s SPY by joining NRA during Trump election campaign

Tucker Carlson: Mexico has interfered in US elections 'more successfully' than Russia

Months Before His Death, Anthony Bourdain Blasted ‘Rapey’ Bill Clinton, Exposed Hillary’s Complicity

The Shroud Of Turin Is Not Jesus' Burial Cloths

Trump calls off Cold War II

Police Come to Iraqi Veteran’s Home, Attempt to Confiscate His Guns, He Tells Them No

Hillary Clinton Is Exhausted, Everybody

‘Palestinian’ Man Skates Murder Charge for Stabbing Israeli Woman in Back, Sentenced on Assault

Trump's Putin Summit Is Another Reminder He Prefers Dictators to Democratic Leaders

Libertarians’ reality problem: How an estrangement from history yields abject failure

Trump Is Right to Meet Putin

Full transcript of Chris Wallace's interview in Helsinki with Russian president Vladimir Putin, as supplied by Fox News.

Chris Wallace interviews Russian President Vladimir Putin

Once Again, President Trump Is Magnificently Right—This Time About Russia

McCain rips Trump: 'One of the most disgraceful performances by an American president in memory'

Trump condemned as treasonous after press conference with Putin

How Everything is Racist, And You’re a Terrible Person

The big influence of 'Big Pink'

Documents Reveal Two US Soldiers Overheard Plot To Kill JFK—and Were Committed After Reporting It

Fox's Perino: Strzok marriage questions by GOP lawmaker 'felt like a public lynching (Relly? I don't think so, Dana!'

Trump: Strzok's testimony 'a disgrace to our country'

Trump Is Right: Mueller’s Latest Indictment Suggests He’s Conducting A Witch Hunt

Constitutional Conservatives Fail the Drug Test

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

International News
See other International News Articles

Title: War, Imperialism, and Statism (Football vs Fútbol)
Source: Bionic Mosquito
URL Source: https://bionicmosquito.blogspot.rs/
Published: Dec 4, 2017
Author: Bionic Mosquito
Post Date: 2017-12-05 05:13:46 by Deckard
Keywords: None
Views: 47

have long wondered about the “why” regarding the differences between American Football and what the rest of the world calls football (i.e. soccer).  American football: so completely regimented and precise; fútbol: very free-flowing and quite uncontrolled. 

This in contrast to what appears on the surface the opposite regarding the political and bureaucratic regimes.  The United States: relatively free-market; Europe and Latin America (where fútbol is most popular): bureaucratic and stifling.

I have never felt satisfied with any answer I have come up with to explain this seeming contradiction; I have never found anything on point upon which I could develop a reasonable hypothesis.  Well, maybe that day has arrived.

Total State/Total Sports, by Dr. Gregory C. Dilsaver.

In this essay, Dilsaver examines the role that organized youth sports indoctrinates people toward being an obedient citizen to a controlling state.  It is a worthwhile read, but I want to focus on one gem that turned a light bulb on for me regarding my quest:

So too, sports inculcate the belief that life is a level playing field, where rules are made up by decree. This is legal positivism, which is the life blood of the Total State, as opposed to God-given natural law, which is the nemesis of the Total State.  (Emphasis added; the light bulb.)

Football vs Fútbol

Before I dive into the history and political theory, I offer a brief examination regarding the differences in the two sports – one very regimented and controlled, the other very free-flowing.  For a mental picture: take someone unfamiliar with either game and plant them in a stadium, one game at a time.  In less than five minutes, he will understand fútbol; in five years, he still may not understand football.

A little detail:

Football: if it means anything, the rule book is 92 pages long.  But this is the simple part.  Why do they call it football?  Rarely does anyone play the ball with his feet.  The play stops and starts; why? A new set of players come in when the team changes from offense to defense to special teams (what’s that?).

Different players come in and out; the formations must follow a prescribed formula; the offense gets four chances to advance the ball ten yards – measured precisely by a chain of ten-yards’ length; when the play goes out of bounds, a precise placement is made of the position; the clock stops and starts with precision – the referee can review and reset the clock; the team has a specific amount of time by which they must begin the next play; there are fouls for dozens of offenses beyond dangerous plays.

Football might be the most regimented popular sport played on the planet; perhaps baseball can be included (another popular American sport) in this category.

Fútbol: there are seventeen Laws of the Game; yes, just seventeen.  Only one of these would offer any confusion to the new fan, the rule of offside: basically, an offensive player must be behind the midfield line or the second-last opponent when the ball is played forward – and then, he is only offside if he is engaged in the play.

As to fouls, basically fouls are called only for dangerous plays.  As to marking the ball for a throw-in, free kick, etc., let’s just say somewhere in the neighborhood is good enough. 

Regarding the clock – it is there merely for general reference.  It is never stopped during the half – if play stops for an extended time (an injured player, for example), the referee just adds on however many minutes he feels appropriate to the end of the half.  Even this added time isn’t set in stone – when the added time expires, the referee will often let a developing play come to some conclusion before blowing the whistle.

There may not be a less regimented popular sport in the world.

The History of Fútbol

Dilsaver’s statement about natural law sent me to the history of fútbol:

The modern rules of association football [fútbol] are based on the mid-19th century efforts to standardise the widely varying forms of football played in the public schools of England. The history of football in England dates back to at least the eighth century AD.

Medieval law offers the most extended period of governance by natural law in the west.  This relationship can be seen in the earliest rules (and I use the term loosely) of the sport:

By some accounts, in some such events any means could be used to move the ball towards the goal, as long as it did not lead to manslaughter or murder.

Which is pretty much the same rule today – fouls are called for dangerous play, and that’s about it.

None of the legal positivism that defines American football; none of the regimentation, precision, call it bureaucracy and regulation.  Just natural law: get the ball in the goal, don’t initiate aggression against another player.


In one simple sentence, Dilsaver opened this window for me.  American football conforms perfectly to a society that is indoctrinated in legal positivism – indoctrinated almost from the birth of the nation and the birth of each citizen.

Fútbol conforms to natural law – natural law that was the basis for the medieval law in the lands of fútbol’s birth; natural law that began to shift to legal positivism with the Renaissance and Enlightenment.

I was looking in the wrong place.  I was looking for an explanation of this seeming contradiction in today’s bureaucratic Europe; instead, I should have looked to Europe’s roots, in natural, medieval law.

Until I come across a better explanation, this is the one I will stick with.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com