[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Jamie Dimon’s quick kowtow after telling truth on communist China

Progressives forget that parents are in charge of kids’ education

NH Public Health Policy Has Officially Killed More “Kids” than COVID

CLIF HIGH AND DAVID NINO RODRIGUEZ - 11-26-21

Smartphones and Social Media - A Mass Surveillance Dystopia

In The Pacific NorThwest ... members of survivalisT movemenTs --- are growing in number ( 2016)

Biden-Harris dream team suddenly Dems' worst nightmare after just 10 months

Democrats' deepest fears

If GOP wins in 2022, they must investigate Biden family corruption

BOOM: Trump Gets Even MORE Good News From 5 Key Battleground States

The Corrupt Media Did Not Fall For The Russia Collusion Hoax. They Were Part Of It

Attempts barred to Access Info about Brandon's daughter!

How Facebook and Google Actually Fund the Creation of Misinformation

Build Back Better’s tax hikes will squeeze Americans long into the future — yet still won’t cover its spending

Whistleblower Videos Capture Pennsylvania Election Officials Destroying Evidence

Feehery: The next Republican wave is coming

FULL RELEASE: Ashley Biden Diary Reveals Child Sex Trauma, Drug Abuse, Resentment For Joe – Whistleblower

Proof that AG Garland misled Congress about silencing parents who dissent

Trump ... ‘ The USA is ' --- ' a Radicalized Mess’

IT’S NOT JUST WHITE PEOPLE: DEMOCRATS ARE LOSING NORMAL VOTERS OF ALL RACES

Pinkerton: Joe Biden and John Kerry’s Green Great Reset Punishes America, Rewards China

Are You Better Off Today Than You Were 10 Months Ago? (Does a bear sh-t in the woods?_

Byron York's Daily Memo: The Biden White House dumpster fire

Washington Post edits and adds editor's notes to at least a dozen Steele dossier stories

Media ... sacrifices RiTTenhouse --- aT alTar of iTs lies

Byron York's Daily Memo: When Adam Schiff loved the dossier

SANHEDRIN BEGINS TO PREPARE OIL TO ANOINT KING MESSIAH/KOHEN GADOL

What Did Obama Know and When Did He Know It?

The Russian ATTack On Ukraine ... Has Already Begun --- Biden Will Do NoThing To STop IT

“The only Thing ThaT sTands beTween The new way of life ... The currenT way of life is - frankly --- hesiTancy To vaccinaTions,” he said.

Joe Biden is all-in for open borders

NJ Senate President Stephen Sweeney concedes election loss to GOP trucker Edward Durr

Virginia Paves the Way for Trump’s Return

Astro World Hell - First hand account - My prayers go out to everyone involved

Mississippi to launch mobile ID program with digital driver’s licenses and vaccine cards

Joe Biden just keeps on lying to the American public: Devine

Democrat Governor Who Pushed for Trump's Tax Returns Didn't Pay Income Tax for Years

CNN - Sesame STreeT Team Up ... To Push Vaccine Propaganda --- for Very Young Children

Supreme CourT Likely To Hold New York Law ViolaTes Second AmendmenT ... ConsTiTuTioal RighTs means --- we don'T need permiTs - permission

PoTenTial apex TargeTs above him in The invesTigaTion ... range from STeele himself --- To ClinTon general counsel Marc Elias To ClinTon campaign officials.

ERs Across The Nation ... Are CompleTely Overwhelmed WiTh Non-Covid PaTienTs --- Is This The ‘vaccine effecT’ in acTion?

President Biden's Not So Stellar Report Card

A deserved Democratic defeat and Republican victory

LAODICEAN FRANKLIN GRAHAM PLEADS WITH EVANGELICALS ... TO RECEIVE THE SACRAMENT OF VACCINATION --- SAYS HE’LL JOIN WITH JOE BIDEN TO PUSH THE JAB

What to watch for in Virginia on election night

Flashback (2013) MSNBC Says Children Belong to Community, Not Parents

I&I/TIPP Poll: Just 42% Now Think Biden Is ‘Mentally Sharp’

Democrats have screwed up everything — stop voting for them!

META will be a plaTform wiTh The approved ThoughTs - beliefs ... allow Them To escape realiTy --- like Zuckerberg.

L.G.B.


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Watching The Cops
See other Watching The Cops Articles

Title: Epic Drug Lab Scandal Results in More Than 20,000 Convictions Dropped
Source: NBC News
URL Source: http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news ... 00-convictions-dropped-n747891
Published: Apr 19, 2017
Author: Jon Schuppe
Post Date: 2017-04-19 07:46:06 by cranky
Keywords: None
Views: 235

A mass dismissal of wrongful convictions ─ perhaps the biggest ever ─ unfolded in a Boston courthouse on Tuesday, as prosecutors in seven Massachusetts counties dropped more than 21,000 low-level drug cases tainted by the work of a rogue lab chemist.

The number of corrupted convictions was so unwieldy that the district attorneys used compact discs to deliver lists of cases they were dropping and those they believed they could successfully re-prosecute.

By day's end, just a few hundred cases involving the disgraced chemist, Annie Dookhan, remained. The exact number may not be clear until Wednesday, when the court finishes processing the lists. The American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts, which fought for the dismissals, did its own tally and came up with 320 cases dropped from a total 21,907.

Defense lawyers hailed the dismissals as a triumph over a system that valued convictions over due process.

"This was a mistake that comes from the war on drugs," said Carl Williams, an ACLU lawyer.

Prosecutors said they decided to re-prosecute defendants with lengthy criminal histories. But they also stressed that the abandoned cases involved people with long records and those who likely committed the offenses for which they were convicted ─ often as the result of more serious crimes. Most pleaded guilty before Dookhan's misdeeds came to light in 2012, prosecutors said.

"If there had been evidence that any of these defendants was actually innocent, we would not have hesitated to dismiss the case outright and exonerate the defendant immediately," Daniel Conley, the district attorney in Suffolk County, which includes Boston, said in a statement.

Conley said he'd decided to pursue 117 of the 15,570 cases undermined by Dookhan's work.

The dismissals capped a five-year legal fight, longer than it took to discover, prosecute and punish Dookhan, who worked at the William A. Hinton State Laboratory Institute in Boston. She admitted to tampering with evidence, forging test results and lying about it. The former lab tech served three years in prison before being released last year.

Why Dookhan did it remains somewhat of a mystery. Investigators and former colleagues have said the Trinidadian immigrant seemed driven by a compulsion to overachieve, even if it meant making things up or cutting corners. She became the lab's most prolific analyst, a record that impressed her supervisors but also worried her co-workers — a concern that went overlooked, investigators found.

The prosecutors fought for a way to preserve the convictions, and leave it to the defendants to challenge them. But civil rights groups and defense lawyers argued for all the cases to be dropped, saying that was the only way to ensure justice. In January, the state's high court chose its own solution, ruling that district attorneys should focus on a small subset of cases it wanted to retry, and drop the rest.

The prosecutors delivered their answers individually Tuesday at the Suffolk County Courthouse in Boston.

Bristol County District Attorney Thomas Quinn III, from south of Boston, said that he would pursue 112 of more than 1,500 cases in which drugs were analyzed by Dookhan.

In Essex County, north of the city, authorities dropped 5,160 cases and said it would re-prosecute 55, authorities said.

Cape & Islands District Attorney Michael O'Keefe said his office would keep one case and drop 1,067.

"Some are having their case dismissed because we believe that the integrity of the system of justice is more important than their conviction," O'Keefe said in a statement. "Others whose cases are of significance and can be proven independent of the actions of this chemist will not be dismissed."

But defense lawyers and civil rights advocates said the dubious convictions made it difficult for defendants to find jobs and housing or to obtain student loans. Some defendants were convicted of more serious crimes, and the drug convictions were used to stiffen their sentences, the lawyers say. In other cases, non-citizens were threatened with deportation.

Lab scandals have undermined thousands of convictions in eight states in the past decade, according to data maintained by the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. The Dookhan case isn't the only one riling Massachusetts; a second scandal, at a second lab, involving a chemist who admitted to doing drugs while on the job, has threatened thousands more convictions.

The Dookhan case has also illuminated an effort to tighten up operations at America's criminal drug labs. As the criminal justice system has grown more reliant on the work of forensic laboratories, scientists have pressed for all labs to be professionally accredited, a process that would require outside reviews ─ steps that experts say could have identified Dookhan's misdeeds much earlier.

"I think the situation might have been different at an accredited lab because there would have been more eyes looking," said Jack Mario, a retired seized-drug laboratory chemist who acted as a consultant in the Dookhan investigation. (1 image)

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com