[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

The Establishment Doesn’t Fear Trump, And It Doesn’t Fear Bernie. It Fears You.

Cop Demoted After Dumping His Retired K-9 Partner at a Shelter to Be Killed

Will Democrats Take Up Arms To Remove 'Dictator' Trump Or Are They All Talk?

Cops Follow Unarmed Man into Bathroom for Jaywalking and Kill Him

Paula White, a White House employee and Trump's spiritual advisor, calls for 'satanic pregnancies to miscarry right now'

‘SNL’ cold open: Alan Dershowitz reunites with ‘just hanging’ Jeffrey Epstein in hell

MSNBC Anchor Denies Saying Slur During Kobe Bryant Clip

Kobe Bryant killed in Los Angeles helicopter crash

Why Do ... DemocraTs Suddenly --- HaTe Russia?

NFL launches new social justice ads

72 Things Caused By Gorebal Warming

New science proves that vaccines SPREAD infectious disease, causing up to 15 times MORE infections among fully vaccinated children

Trump v. RATZ/RINOZ 2020...easy decision, right?

Coronavirus 'will infect 350,000 people in Wuhan': Scientists make alarming prediction ahead of Chinese New Year as China locks down FOURTEEN cities, part of the Great Wall and Disneyland Shanghai – and even McDonald's shuts up shop

Bloomberg Trolls Trump and then Loses the Ball

'Show up to court with a toothbrush': ICE says sanctuary city officials should expect jail time if they ignore subpoenas

Zapruder’s JFK Assassination Footage Altered by Nefarious Forces

Michigan State Police Uncovers Breathalyzer Fraud…Technicians accused of falsifying documents that certified the accuracy of breathalyzer devices in Michigan

Video Shows Everything Cops Told the Public About Killing Man in His Driveway Was FALSE

Chinese Lab That Studies “World’s Most Dangerous Pathogens” is Based in Wuhan

A Real BOMBSHELL Book!

Mentally Ill Veteran Suffering After Cops Kill Service Dog As It Used the Bathroom, Lie About It Biting Them

Study Finds Unborn Babies May Feel Pain as Early as 12 Weeks

Terry Jones, Monty Python Founder and Scholar, Is Dead at 77

Virginia Democrats Push Legislation to Make Criticism of Government Officials a Criminal Offense

Virginia Democrats Give Finger To Gun Activists, Advance Gun Control. West Virginia Looks At Taking Counties From Virginia, Report Says.

False prophet? Pope Francis hosts bizarre drag queen-like circus performance in creepy reptilian-shaped Vatican Hall

“Democratic Institutions?” 10 Lessons from history that will destroy your trust in the CIA

Climate change hoax COLLAPSES as new science finds human activity has virtually zero impact on global temperatures

“He was Murdered” – 13 Month Old Infant Dies 14 Hours After Receiving the Flu Shot

Denver Post Columnist Fired After Arguing There Are Two Sexes

Cop Arrested for Faking War on Cops Story of Sniper Shooting Him Setting Off Massive Manhunt

More Than 4 Times as Many Police Officers Killed Themselves Than Were Shot in 2019

FEDS ran the so-called “white supremacist” group tied to VA Governor’s false claim that gun owners would stage armed assault on capitol in Richmond

How Japan Has Almost Eradicated Gun Crime

AOC declares Democrats a 'center-conservative' party: We don't have a 'left party' in this country

MUST SEE LIST of President Trump’s Historical and Miraculous Accomplishments Three Years Into His Presidency

To ‘Make America Great Again’ Trump Added a $1 TRILLION Deficit in 2019—Just Like Obama

Innocent Man Tries to Clean Cop’s Windshield to Earn Some Money, So the Cop Shot Him

New Bill to Allow Cops to Detain Citizens, Force Them to Explain Who They Are, What They're Doing

NINE WOMEN WE CAN DO WITHOUT IN 2020

It’s Clear That Northam Is Praying For Violence

Illegal Immigrants Blocked At Border Pray For Trump's Defeat "I wwant trump out'

The Tractor Backlash

VA State Senator Goes Public 72 Hours Before Rally: ‘We Are Being Set Up’

Richmond 2A Rallygoers To Be Corralled Into “Chain-Link Pen” With Only One Way In And Out

ICE ups ante in standoff with NYC: ‘This is not a request’

Trump's Lawyers Formally Answer Articles of Impeachment

Cops Mistake Medical Emergency for Drug Use, Viciously Beat Man with Batons

Epstein’s Former Lawyers Picked for Donald Trump’s Defense Team


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

WORLD WAR III
See other WORLD WAR III Articles

Title: Presidential War Is Unconstitutional
Source: Independent Institute
URL Source: http://www.independent.org/newsroom/article.asp?id=8936
Published: Dec 6, 2016
Author: Ivan Eland
Post Date: 2016-12-06 02:30:58 by Hondo68
Ping List: *Neo-Lib Chickenhawk Wars*     Subscribe to *Neo-Lib Chickenhawk Wars*
Keywords: None
Views: 263

The Obama administration has decided to stretch the 15-year old congressional authorization for war against the perpetrators of the 9/11 attacks, or those harboring them, to include an illegal war against a group in Somalia—al-Shabab—that wasn’t even in existence at the time of the attacks in 2001.

In fact, as with many of its Islamist terrorist opponents worldwide—including the original al Qaeda, the perpetrator of 9/11 that arose from U.S. arming of Mujahideen guerrillas against the Soviet Union in Afghanistan in the 1980s and al Qaeda in Iraq, which arose to combat the U.S. invasion there and morphed into ISIS—the United States inadvertently helped create al-Shabab in the first place. Al-Shabab did not arise until after 2007, long after 9/11, when the U.S. sponsored an Ethiopian invasion of Somalia to wrest control of the country from a milder Islamist council. The more virulent al-Shabab rose to attempt to repel this foreign invasion.

More generally, after 9/11, rather than following the congressional authorization and focusing like a laser beam on countering the original al Qaeda group and their patrons, the Afghan Taliban, the George W. Bush administration launched a general “war on terror,” which covered all terrorist groups of international scope, regardless of whether or not they focused on attacking U.S. targets. In the end, this massive Bush administration violation of the narrow 2001 authorization led to illegal U.S. drone wars and airstrikes in countries all over the Middle East and Southwest Asia—Somalia (against al Shabab), Yemen (against al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula), Pakistan (against the Pakistani Taliban), and Iraq, Syria, and Libya (against ISIS). The Obama administration then accelerated all these unconstitutional wars. Now Obama is trying shore up the already thin legal fig leaf, so that it can pass such travesties—which actually make Islamist groups more rabid each time the U.S. intervenes—onto the incoming Trump administration. When Obama took office, he complained that he inherited from the Bush administration an economic meltdown and a military quagmire in Iraq, but he in turn is bequeathing a legal quagmire to his successor.

Ambiguities in the U.S. Constitution do exist, but which branch of government was given the war power is not one of them. In 18th century Britain, the prerogative of deciding to go to war was the king’s. Having been a victim of this prerogative, debates at the American Constitutional Convention of 1787, the Constitution that resulted, and actual practice in the republic for almost two centuries until the Korean War in 1950 demonstrate conclusively that Congress—the people’s branch—gets to initiate war, not the executive. The Constitution specifically gives Congress the power to commence war; the debates at the Constitutional Convention indicate that the only exception is for urgent self-defense—that is, when U.S. territory is under sustained attack, thus preventing the Congress from convening. Even then, the Congress should meet at the earliest possible time to ratify any moves in self-defense made by the president, as commander in chief. Very early in American history, even in the informal and sporadic war at sea with France (the Quasi-War) in the last few years of the 18th century, the Congress was in the driver’s seat in conducting the war and President John Adams complied with its desires.

And in contrast to presidential claims of an expansive commander-in-chief role since the Korean War, the Constitution’s framers intended, and normal practice till 1950 confirmed, that the president’s role in that capacity was taken narrowly to mean only commanding troops on the battlefield after war had already been initiated by Congress—not commanding the entire nation, in times of crises or otherwise.


Yet since 1950, presidents have claimed powers to start wars even without any authorization from Congress—either getting none (for example, Bill Clinton in his war to separate Kosovo from Serbia in 1999 or Barack Obama in overthrowing Muammar Gaddafi in Libya in 2011) or claiming that they needed to do so only as a courtesy, which was primarily a gambit to win increased political support for their military escapades (for example, both Bushes in each of their misadventures in Iraq).

Another trick is what Bush and Obama have done with the aforementioned drone wars—trying to blatantly fold wars against other only tangentially-related “Islamist” groups in countries far from Afghanistan into the congressional authorization for war against the perpetrators of 9/11—the original al-Qaeda group and their hosts, the Afghan Taliban.

Such legal gymnastics must stop. During the Trump administration, the many drone wars either must be made legally legitimate, with specific approval for each of them from the people’s houses of Congress, or they must be stopped. The latter solution would be preferred—because those counterproductive foibles are making the threat from Islamist terrorism more virulent with each U.S. military intervention—but even the former option would at least put the wars on a much sounder constitutional footing. Subscribe to *Neo-Lib Chickenhawk Wars*

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com