[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Oklahoma murder suspecT confesses To ... killing neighbor - cooking her hearT --- invesTigaTors say

Biden Is No FDR

Jason Chaffetz: Biden-Harris' disastrous start – first month full of hypocrisy, scandal and incompetence

Biden is set to repeat Obama’s Mideast failures — and wipe out US influence

How the GOP can win back Congress

There Is No GOP Civil War

Biden rewards Iran’s bad behavior by begging it to make a deal

‘Never before’ has the leader of the free world [Biden] been ‘so cognitively compromised’

ATTorney Lin Wood Releases STaTemenT Before Supreme CourT Ruling ... on ElecTion Fraud Today --- UPDATED WITH NEW COMMENT

Biden and his assistant is too cruel a punishment with which to hit America.

TiTanic ... Genius Time Traveler goes back --- everyone saved !

Rush Limbaugh passed away this morning

Remember ... George Will --- Me neiTher.

Eating Biden’s Lunch

Biden Wrong to Consider Restricting Travel to Florida

The Real Reason ... Pelosi & McConnell Folded LasT NighT Leaks --- Lock Them Up

GOP Party

Seven turncoats: What motivated those Republicans to vote guilty?

Real life study: Masked schoolchildren are harmed physically, psychologically, behaviorally and suffer from 24 distinct health issues

Trump Celebrates Acquittal, Hints At Political Future

SNAKE - McConnell ... Uses Floor To BruTally Trash Trump --- Following Failed ImpeachmenT EfforT

BREAKING - Trump ... Releases StaTemenT --- Following ImpeachmenT AcquiTTal

BREAKING - SenaTe VoTes 57 - 43 ... To ACQUIT Donald Trump --- Here Are The SEVEN Republicans Who VoTed To ConvicT

SCHOOLBOY 'KILLERS' Thugs - 15 - 17 ... 'filmed Themselves gang raping woman - 36 - beaTing her To deaTh' --- 'in a park as oTher boys waTched'

Joe Biden Is a F#@ing Idiot!

ImpeachmenT blunder - AuThor of TweeT inTroduced aT Trial says iT was ... Calvary / prayer - crucificTion --- falsified - misinTerpreTed to caValry / horses - soldiers - invasion

Georgia's New Democrat Senator Is Under Investigation for Voter Registration Fraud

Tom MacDonald - "Fake Woke"

Five Vanities That Are Destroying America

Leftist Sicko Bruce Springsteen arrested for DWI in New Jersey…

Impeachment Trial Redux

“Wikipedia…Can .... PuT AnyThing They WanT OuT There To Ruin My IdenTiTy” --- Mike Lindell on Wikipedia’s ATTempts To Trash His Good Name

WhaT's wiTh smiTTen romney ... mormons / liberals have anoTher Holy SpiriT --- dead soul - empTy brain echo chamber !

HUGE DEVELOPMENT - Hand RecounT Finds Dominion VoTing Machines ... ShorTed EVERY REPUBLICAN in Windham - New Hampshire --- 300 VoTes!

Rep. Andy Biggs - Evidence seems To ... indicaTe Congress leadership knew of CapiTol rioT --- days before

FORMER CIA OFFICER - BRYAN DEAN WRIGHT - I’m A DemocraT ... But IT’s Time --- To Leave The ParTy

Google Competitor PRESEARCH.org Launches Decentralized Search Engine (How to rid your life of toxic tech)

Doctors Link Pfizer, Moderna Vaccines to Life-Threatening Blood Disorder

Time Magazine Gushingly Profiles The Successful ‘Conspiracy’ To Rig The 2020 Election

Massive brawl erupts among teenagers inside Illinois ... chimpoline park --- video shows

“Unmasked” Video Provides ... More InformaTion - Evidence --- Surrounding The 2020 ElecTion


Yale Grad STudenT ... ShoT Dead --- In GoaTville

Tom MacDonald - "Cancelled"

Marcy Kaptur’s warning

Biden's Big Disappointment. Jim Carafano on AMERICA First | Sebastian Gorka Radio

Last 15 Minutes of Lindell's Absolute Proof - Most Powerful Part of the Documentary.

TIFFANY DOVER - Another Vaccine Casualty


Study: Long-Term Mask Use May Contribute To Advanced Stage Lung Cancer

Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

See other Humor Articles

Title: The Theology of Statism by Hogeye Bill
Source: [None]
URL Source: [None]
Published: Jul 9, 2016
Author: Hogeye Bill
Post Date: 2016-07-09 14:35:02 by tpaine
Keywords: None
Views: 646
Comments: 2


The Theology of Statism

by Hogeye Bill

May 19, 2007

Most people like to think that their opinions and beliefs are based on facts and solid reasoning. But in one area many people make an exception - they consider it quite proper to believe and act without such a rational empirical basis when it comes to religion. For beliefs about a deity, faith is generally claimed to be superior to reason, at least by "believers." Here we will examine another area in which some people put faith above reason: politics. Most people today hold beliefs and opinions about government (the state) which are faith-based, and quite analogous to religious dogma.

According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, a freethinker is "one who forms opinions on the basis of reason independently of authority." While this is the general definition of "freethinking," some would restrict it to opinions about religion only. We use the more general definition here, unless otherwise stated, and take freethinking to refer to all opinions and beliefs, from beliefs about fairies and leprechauns, to homeopathy and creationism and alien abduction and religion.

atheist-anarchism-symbol Historically, freethinking has been critical of both God and State. A 19th century French slogan "No Gods, No Masters" expressed the sentiment that man's mind should not be subordinated to any authority, supernatural or natural. Even earlier, seminal freethinker Denis Diderot wrote, "Man will never be free until the last king is strangled with the entrails of the last priest." Similarly, other notable freethinkers opposed both church and state power, such as Voltaire ("ecrasez l'infame") and Tom Paine (who wrote against both "kingcraft" and "priestcraft.") Traditionally, freethinkers had a clear libertarian streak.

Conversely, most classical anarchist luminaries railed against theism. Michael Bakunin turned Voltaire's famous aphorism around, writing, "If God really existed, he would have to be abolished." Johann Most, a famous German anarchist, wrote a virulent pamphlet called "The God Plague." Emma Goldman denounced "Religion, the dominion of the human mind ... and Government, the dominion of human conduct." Many periodicals in 19th century America combined denial of state authority (philosophical anarchism) and the denial of religious authority. Freethinkers (in the narrow sense) and anarchists were allied - both were freethinkers in the broad sense.

Logically, it is easy to see why. If one rejects all "tyranny over the mind of man," as Jefferson put it, it follows that one rejects both supernatural and secular authority. If one is to make up ones own mind, and do so with rationality, then both secular and religious dogma must be questioned.

Today, it seems that most self-labeled freethinkers have more or less limited their rejection of authority to religious issues, and allowed dogma concerning the state to thrive. And yet, given the parallel between many secular and religious beliefs, one would think that modern freethinkers would easily see through common statist claims and superstitions. Here is a short list of dogma shared by theism and statism.

Thou shall have no God/State before me. Like God, the state is a jealous state. The statist paradigm proclaims that everyone owes obedience to their "home" state. If you don't obey, you're a traitor/heretic. God/State is the source of morality/legality. Just as theists commonly claim that you should obey God's laws, and that morality springs from God, statists claim that you should obey the state's laws, and that morality springs from the state. God/State is my salvation/solution to all problems. Theists pray to the Lord to solve their problems, and God is omnipotent and able to solve them. Likewise, statists seem to believe that the state can solve all, or at the very least is the obvious and generally successful solution. Use any means necessary to create the (kingdom of God/perfect society) on earth. Theists, for the most part, have grown out of this belief and stopped burning heretics and witches. Statists still believe in robbing others ("taxation") for the holy ghost ("public good"), and conscripting, "interning," and torturing as necessary. All are God's/State's children - consent is not required. Just as theists give lip service to free will, yet subject non- believers to God's law, statists give lip service to consent, yet subject non-believers to taxation, regulation, imprisonment for non-aggressive conduct, and so on. The liberal statist dogma of "forced consent" - that people consent to the state whether they agree or not - is loosely analogous to the theist teleological argument for the existence of God. Just as theists claim that order in the universe implies a designer, statists claim that living one's life in a spacial area implies consent to obey. Logically, of course, neither follows. Since freethinkers reject all authority, both spiritual and temporal, one could almost say this: Freethinking applied to god(s) and religion implies atheism, while freethinking applied to rulers and the state implies anarchism. But while this may be true for most people, it is possible for someone to be a freethinking theist or a freethinking archist. A freethinker may, applying all his rationality, think that argument X for obedience to God holds, or argument Y for obedience to State holds. Thus, there are four possibilities.

Authority God Accept Reject State Accept traditional statist believers; many/most people; religious right statist freethinkers (narrow definition); pro-state atheists & agnostics religious anarchists e.g. antinomianists, followers of Tolstoy, Gandhi freethinkers (broad definition); atheist anarchists (most anarchists) Reject To summarize: The logic of rational empiricism - freethinking in the general sense - would seem to lead to atheism and anarchism if taken to their logical conclusion. As Voltairine de Cleyre put it, "Anarchy ... is the only logical outcome of freethought - the ripened fruit of which freethinking is the potent seed." Thus, it is rather surprising that most people who consider themselves "freethinkers" today are quite statist, rather than libertarian or anarchist. There is apparently some mental compartmentalizing going on; these modern "freethinkers" are able to rationally question religious dogma, but are unable or unwilling to question analogous statist dogma. Basically, they have replaced the irrational belief in gods, so dangerous in earlier eras, with an irrational belief in states. From a theist's perspective, statism puts the state in god's place - the modern form of idolatry is statolatry.

Hogeye Bill is a chess master, songwriter, and freelance anarchist. He is author of the popular Anarcho-capitalist FAQ and an online history of anarchist thought entitled Against Authority. He currently resides in Ozarkia (northern Arkansas in statist-speak) unless he is on the lam again.

Poster Comment:

I'm sure I'll need to explain that I DO NOT agree with all of hogeyes opinions, but some of his observations are spot on about the kanary klan here at LF.. Enjoy the humor.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  

TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: All you kanary klan clowns, statists to a man. (#0)

The statist paradigm proclaims that everyone owes obedience to their "home" state. If you don't obey, you're a traitor/heretic.

statism puts the state in god's place - the modern form of idolatry is statolatry.

A couple of hogeyes more pithy comments.

tpaine  posted on  2016-07-09   14:43:26 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  

#2. To: Willie Green, yukon, roscoe, gatlin, harrowup, all alert canaries, canary island (#1)






If you ... don't use exclamation points --- you should't be typeing ! Commas - semicolons - question marks are for girlie boys !

BorisY  posted on  2016-07-09   15:16:39 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  

TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com