Bible Study
See other Bible Study Articles
Title: Egypt's Pyramids Were Grain Silos, Not Tombs
Source:
Lead Stories
URL Source: http://ben-carson.leadstories.com/0 ... ere-grain-silos-not-tombs.html
Published: Nov 5, 2015
Author: Alan Duke
Post Date: 2015-11-05 08:58:10 by Willie Green
Keywords: None
Views: 28164
Comments: 60
Ben Carson, one of the Republican frontrunners in the race to be U.S. president, believes archeologists got it wrong about Egypt's pyramids. The huge stone structures were built to store massive quantities of grain, not to serve as tomb for rulers, according to what Carson said in a 1998 graduation speech at Michigan's Andrews University.
And the remarkable pyramids were built not by the pharaohs, but by the biblical Joseph, son of Jacob, Carson hypothesized.
In the Old Testament book of Genesis, Joseph was said to have "stored up grain in great abundance like the sand of the sea, until he stopped measuring it, for it was beyond measure," Carson said in a video of the address. Carson been a popular speaker for conservative Christian groups for years. Here's the speech posted on YouTube:
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
Begin Trace Mode for Comment # 49.
#4. To: Willie Green (#0)
In the Old Testament book of Genesis, Joseph was said to have "stored up grain in great abundance like the sand of the sea, until he stopped measuring it, for it was beyond measure," I like a lot of what he says, but on this he's just ignorant. At that time, man did not have the tools or knowledge necessary to build the pyramids. One look at the interior will tell you that the pyramids were not grain silos.
This really is a red-letter day for LF. We finally found just one thing that you won't believe. Would it help if Carson said there was a conspiracy by powerful and cunning Egyptian elites to use the pyramids to store grain? That it was a conspiracy by the Pharaoh and his cronies to perpetrate a pyramid scheme on the helpless citizens of Egypt?
Really? Well, there are many things I don't believe - one of them being that you are anything but a dickwad. And then you ping the police state shill GrandIsland to the thread? Yeh - you're a real class act. Would it help if Carson said there was a conspiracy by powerful and cunning Egyptian elites to use the pyramids to store grain? And your insanity continues unabated.
Well, at least one of you are insane, and perhaps a dickwad as well. "Carson’s claims seem to be drawn in part from Egyptologist Dr Wyatt Thom’s 1984 book Egypt Egypt Egypt. According to Thom, the pyramids were built to house grain, and mummified bodies were placed inside as scarecrows to keep birds away. If you’re wondering how that makes sense given that the pyramids are enclosed structures, Thom claims this is because you’re “hamstrung by a very modern conception of birds”. It is entirely possible that the first pryamids had a dual purpose.
It was not to store grain. Monuments to vanity by long-dead monarchs.
Most likely so. But it would be interesting to find some artifact that the massive storage of grain actually happened and where.
Anyone who has been inside a pyramid would understand that only small quantities of grain could be stored inside. Look at the size of the buildings we use to store grain today but we also store vast quantities by laying tapaulins on the ground and piling up the grain. Massive stone silos were not necessary to store large quantities. It is a pity an intelligent person did not do some research before expounding such a dumb theory. The size of the pyramids is impressive but the space available inside is small with narrow passages. The egyptions built their day to day buildings from mud (adobe) and such buildings do not last millenia thus we have no examples of how they store large quantities. You also have to consider the size of the populations. They were not vast millions as we have today. Even the hebrew of Moses day outnumbered the egyptians I do however agree with him regarding the origin of humans, we are a seperate species. Darwin's theories speak of adaptation but seperate species still exist without complete change of form
Where do we do this? I've never seen or heard of it before. BTW,I have never been in a pyramid before,either. Never had any interest at all in Egypt,either in Biblical or modern times.
#52. To: sneakypete (#49)
All over the Plains states. At many grain elevators, they pile more on the ground (and then cover with plastic sheeting) than they keep in the actual grain elevator's bins. They then load it on grain trains so it doesn't stay on the ground long enough to start to rot. The grain trains take it to the Mississippi or the coastal ports.
Seeing the pyramids and other ancient ruins are the only reason anyone goes to Egypt. Which is why their economy used to be 20% tourism. It took a big hit after the rioting and political unrest and hadn't recovered yet. The Russians started going there on vacation instead of to Italy or Spain. But Egypt was cheaper so Russians started going there in big numbers, helping Egypt's tourist sector to recover somewhat. After the recent shootdown of the airliner over the Sinai, Russia has suspended travel to Egypt. Another blow to Egyptian tourism.
BTW,I have never been in a pyramid before,either. Never had any interest at all in Egypt,either in Biblical or modern times. When there are wheat surplusses and insufficient silo capacity this methodology is used to store the grain, you would have to be travelling through wheat country to see it. As Eqypt is an extremely dry place there is not the same problems of storage as encountered in a wet place. This idea that pyramids were grain silos has about as much credibility as pyramids as landing platforms for space craft I have been inside a pyramid, lots of stone, very little space, rooms are not huge as you might think, passages are narrow because afterall they are formed by gaps in rows of stone walls.. Pyramids are not hollow inside, dealing with the weight of thousands of tons of stone must be carefully managed
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/LatestAnd the remarkable pyramids were built not by the pharaohs, but by the biblical Joseph, son of Jacob, Carson hypothesized.
#7. To: Deckard, GrandIsland (#4)
#8. To: TooConservative (#7)
(Edited)
We finally found just one thing that you won't believe.
#12. To: Deckard, TooConservative (#8)
And your insanity continues unabated.
#15. To: SOSO (#12)
It is entirely possible that the first pryamids had a dual purpose.
#16. To: TooConservative (#15)
It was not to store grain. Monuments to vanity by long-dead monarchs.
#17. To: SOSO (#16)
(Edited)
#49. To: paraclete (#17)
(Edited)
we also store vast quantities by laying tapaulins on the ground and piling up the grain.
Replies to Comment # 49. Where do we do this? I've never seen or heard of it before.
#53. To: sneakypete (#49)
Never had any interest at all in Egypt,either in Biblical or modern times.
#55. To: sneakypete (#49)
(Edited)
Where do we do this? I've never seen or heard of it before.
End Trace Mode for Comment # 49.
[Home] [Headlines] [Latest Articles] [Latest Comments] [Post] [Mail] [Sign-in] [Setup] [Help] [Register]