United States News
See other United States News Articles
Title: "The Girl Was No Saint Either": Fox Jumps To Defend McKinney Police Officer's Brutal Manhandling Of Teen Girl At Pool Party
Source:
Media Matters
URL Source: http://mediamatters.org/research/20 ... ther-fox-jumps-to-defen/203924
Published: Jun 8, 2015
Author: THOMAS BISHOP
Post Date: 2015-06-09 20:34:34 by Gatlin
Keywords: None
Views: 5948
Comments: 31
Fox hosts and guests rushed to the defense of a police officer suspended after video surfaced of his brutal treatment of teenagers outside a pool party in McKinney, Texas. The video showed the officer pulling his gun on two teenage boys, then slamming a girl down onto her face. Wash. Post: "Video Shows Texas Police Officer Pulling Gun On Teenagers At Pool Party." The Washington Post reported on a video showing white police officer in McKinney, Texas brutally detaining and pulling a gun on black teenagers following a pool party: A white police officer in McKinney, Tex., has been suspended and a rally is being planned to call for his firing after a shocking video emerged Saturday that shows the officer manhandling, arresting and drawing his gun on a group of black children outside a pool party. The video, which was uploaded to YouTube over the weekend, captures a chaotic scene in a suburban community about 40 miles north of Dallas that grows increasingly tense when the officer -- identified as Cpl. Eric Casebolt -- attempts to throw a teenager onto a sidewalk before using his body weight to push her head toward the concrete. He is also seen pulling her hair. When several teenagers move toward Casebolt, he lets the teenager go and takes several steps toward them. As they begin to back up and then turn to flee, he pulls out his gun and approaches menacingly before two other officers appear to intervene. [The Washington Post, 6/8/15] Fox's Tom Shillue: Video "Didn't Shock Me At All" Because The Teen "Was Intimidating The Cop." On the June 8 edition of Fox News' The Five, co-host Tom Shillue claimed the video "didn't shock me at all" because "the cops are breaking up a party, these guys are great." Later Shillue justified the officer pulling a gun on the unarmed teen claiming "he was intimidating the cop" by running in his direction. [Fox News, The Five, 6/8/15] Fox Business' Lou Dobbs: "What In The World Are Police, We Have To Ask, Supposed To Do When People Who Don't Respect The Law ... Refuse To Obey?" Fox Business host Lou Dobbs defended the officer, asking, "what in the world" are police supposed to do when people "refuse to obey" their orders? [Fox Business, Lou Dobbs Tonight, 6/8/15] Fox's Brit Hume On Brutal Responses By Police: "If You Obey The Police It Doesn't Usually Happen." On the June 8 edition of The O'Reilly Factor, senior political analyst Brit Hume claimed that arrests and actions like those taken by the officer in McKinney, Texas, don't happen "if you obey the police." [Fox News, The O'Reilly Factor, 6/8/15] Fox's Kelly: "The Girl Was No Saint Either." Fox News host Megyn Kelly responded to the brutal video showing a teen girl being manhandled by a Texas police officer by commenting that "the girl was no saint either. He had told her to leave, and she continued to linger. And when the cop tells you to leave, get out." She followed this by saying "I'm not defending his actions, let me make that clear." [Fox News, The Kelly File, 6/8/15] Sean Hannity Claims That Officer In Texas Was Justified For Pulling A Gun Because Teens Could Have Come Up And "Hit Them With A Shank In The Back." On the June 8 edition of Premiere Radio Networks' The Sean Hannity Show, Fox News host Sean Hannity defended the Texas police officer, saying there is an environment of children not respecting the police, which President Obama has contributed to. [Premiere Radio Networks, The Sean Hannity Show, 6/8/15] Fox Guest Bo Dietl: The Teens Might Have Said "I'm Gonna Pop A Cap." On Fox's Hannity, guest and former NYPD detective Bo Dietl claimed that the police officer in the case could have felt justifiably threatened because the teens might have told him, "I'm gonna pop a cap." [Fox News, Hannity, 6/8/15] Fox's Doocy Questions "Rush To Judgement" Of Arresting Officer. On the June 9 edition of Fox & Friends, co-hosts Steve Doocy, Elisabeth Hasselbeck, and Brian Kilmeade reiterated their network's defense of the McKinney police officer, airing several segments from prior programs that attempted to exonerate the officer and highlight his purportedly strong "track record." Doocy lamented what he called a "rush to judgement" in the case, stating "let's just figure out what happened, and then let the cards fall where they may": KILMEADE: Well you know, the whole thing is you see this video, and it has about six million views, probably up to even higher now, and then you say to yourself, "well I kind of feel that I saw the whole story," but you didn't. You weren't there when we got there. We weren't there when the cops got there. You don't know what the call was. You don't know what they were looking for. [...] DOOCY: What we do know, is that there is an investigation right now. And we do know that some people are calling for the cop to be fired. Why the rush to judgement? Let's just figure out what happened, and then let the cards fall where they may. KILMEADE: I mean, his track record should matter, and it's a good track record. He's a strong officer. HASSELBECK: He was 10-year veteran. He was named the department's patrolman of the year in the past. [Fox News, Fox & Friends, 6/9/15] Fox's Todd Starnes: "Apparently - If You Object To Teenagers Terrorizing Your Neighborhood - You're A Racist." In a June 9 post to his Facebook page, Fox contributor Todd Starnes defended the officer's treatment of so-called "teenage thugs" and warned that media criticism of the police created "a slippery slope to anarchy": [Facebook, accessed 6/9/15] *This item has been updatedVideo Shows Texas Police Officer Pulling Gun On Teenagers, Manhandling Teen Girl
Fox Personalities Criticize The Teenagers And Try To Justify The Officer's Actions
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
#1. To: Gatlin (#0)
As an armed civilian I'd have pulled my weapon too. It certainly was the right tactic given it scatted the miscreants and prevented injury.
Interesting, I had not looked at it from that aspect.
He should have shot as many of those well behaved teenagers as he could. That would teach them. /GrandIsland
To shoot a kid who was pushed in the back? To start Gunfight at the OK Corral in a crowd of teens? The cop exercised poor judgment and has resigned.
To unholster a weapon isn't to shoot a weapon and good for the cop for resigning. WTF could work for a political appointee posing as a police chief?
I had to repeat that. Right/Wrong/Indifferent - The Chief had announced that he had an ongoing investigation that would be completed by the end of the week. I cannot possible decide what is right and what is wrong based solely on viewing a video and making a decision from that. I can however decide that it is WRONG to reach ANY decision until the investigation is complete.
There are health conditions that can cause a loss of touch with reality, and there is no harm in seeing a doctor.
Probably for the best.
Learn how to speak for yourself first. lol Another AGENDA poster shitting up Stones forum. Every society gets the kind of criminal it deserves. What is equally true is that every community gets the kind of law enforcement it insists on. Robert Kennedy
Again, I could care less what the cop or the chief did, I'm saying what I would do as a legally armed, well trained citizen. If a crowd gathers around me and I feel as tho my life is in danger, I'm pulling my gun.
Given the opportunity, I wager YOU would have put on your rent-a-cop 12" recently Brass-O'ed badge with your daily costume and pranced all around the situation with 50,000 primers to make a difference, correct? No, a koffee stained rent-a-cop uniform not washed in a month with stale doughnuts hanging out of your pockets? Excellent! That's how to make a difference!
Another of the forums finest AGENDA posters shitting on your forum.
Every society gets the kind of criminal it deserves. What is equally true is that every community gets the kind of law enforcement it insists on. Robert Kennedy
The object of the exercise was to break up the party and have people leave. It was not to apprehend as many people as possible or to escalate the situation. There was no life threatening situation until a sequence of Casebolt's actions created one. To apprehend a bunch of kids before the scene could be controlled was poor judgment. To throw the girl down to apprehend her was poor judgment. He had already run out of handcuffs. He made himself useless for crowd control. When the teen was pushed in the back and came forward he took it as a threat. He abandoned the girl on the ground and unholstered his weapon. When the teen immediately fled, showing no threat, was when he raised his weapon to the ready position. Poor judgments had led to a dangerous situation. Other cops came to get Casebolt to cool it. Any of Casebolt's actions might be justified as legal. Legal but problematic. You said, "As an armed civilian I'd have pulled my weapon too." Drawing your weapon in a crowd with real LEO on hand would be exceedingly poor judgment. After ten years, it sure does cut back on the retirement benefits though.
Doughnut boy is narc'ing on you to Pebbles. LOL I'm an agenda poster and so are you. LOL
He is a mommies's boy, Fred.
For some reason you assumed I'd be among LEOs when I pulled my weapon. I never suggested that. If I were alone and I thought my life were in danger I would pull my weapon without hesitation. Again, I could care less what happened to the cop or his lackey chief.
The issue was simple, too. He let his emotions get away his otherwise objective reasoning skills and decision making. That is NOT the hallmark of a professional. Kick the BUM OUT!
He could always claim he was a drunk and get a medical leave. Right?
What you posted from the Words of Christ has no bearing on the subject of this thread.
Truly my soul waiteth upon God: from him cometh my salvation. He only is my rock and my salvation; he is my defence; I shall not be greatly moved. (Psalm 62:1-2)
You were commenting on the instant incident. You were commenting as an "armed civilian" excluding yourself as one of the LEOs. You were commenting on an incident in an area crowded with teens and with a number of LEOs who had responded to the incident. Everyone there was in the presence of LEOs, i.e., "among LEOs." Perhaps you were commenting about pulling your weapon at a firing range in another county. It was Casebolt's poor judgment in escalating the situation which resulted in needlessly creating a situation in which he pulled his weapon. The LEOs went there to disperse a crowd. Casebolt was not alone. He was with other police and over a hundred civilians in a limited access/egress area. The mission was crowd dispersal after a few ladies were involved in a hair pulling incident.
Kick the BUM OUT! He created unnecessary risks to his fellow officers as well as the public. As you say, it was unprofessional.
Keep on trying to tell me what I was thinking if it makes you feel better, it still won't make it true. Any civilian who pulls his gun during an active LEO encounter would become an instant lead magnet, and that isn't me. My comment was limited to me being alone & surrounded by thugs who made me fear for my life. Now then, let's talk about your poor judgement. As an Obama voter you helped to straddle this nation with the most corrupt, racist presidential administration in our history. Two questions; do you realize this and are you sorry for being a political dupe?
From his point of view, I'm sure it looked like a threat. Especially when the "teen" (who was bigger than the cop) was reaching for something under his shirt and approaching from the side. "Other cops came to get Casebolt to cool it." Both officers then immediately took off after the "teen". My guess is that Casebolt told them he might be armed. Which justifies him pulling his weapon.
And arrest law breakers. The officer didn't do anything wrong in my view. Analyzing every decision a cop makes is a bad road to go down. The officer didn't shoot anyone. He feared for his safety when the punks got behind him and taunted him. I'll have to disagree with you on this one.
Perhaps. But it seemed a bit hasty. My guess is that his bosses were prepared to throw him under the bus for the sake of "racial relations" and he said screw that, I quit. Witnesses at the scene who were interviewed said it wasn't about race at all. The police had the full support of the residents who called the police. And if you watched the FULL 7-minute video, the officer was 100% justified in drawing his weapon. That said, I think a reprimand was in order for his attempting to be a one-man crowd control. But suspension? Firing? Come on. If all the teens were white it wouldn't even be a story.
That's how I read it.
That's how I read it. That's how I read it too. That is why I stated I had not considered it from that aspect.
This was your comment#1 to the article, in all of its context. As an armed civilian I'd have pulled my weapon too. It certainly was the right tactic given it scatted the miscreants and prevented injury.
Enjoy your argument, and Obama!
The officer didn't do anything wrong in my view. Analyzing every decision a cop makes is a bad road to go down. The officer didn't shoot anyone. He feared for his safety when the punks got behind him and taunted him. I'll have to disagree with you on this one. From what I heard today some of the kids/adults there were telling some of the kids there to ignore what the cops were saying. Also heard that the cop in question had just come from a double suicide scene and was still a bit shook up. Don't know if either one I heard is true but there they are. “Political correctness is a doctrine, fostered by a delusional, illogical minority, and rapidly promoted by mainstream media, which holds forth the proposition that it is entirely possible to pick up a turd by the clean end.”
#2. To: Vinny (#1)
#3. To: Gatlin (#2)
#4. To: Vinny (#1)
As an armed civilian I'd have pulled my weapon too.
#5. To: nolu chan (#4)
#6. To: Vinny (#5)
WTF could work for a political appointee posing as a police chief?
#7. To: Fred Mertz (#3)
#8. To: nolu chan (#4)
The cop exercised poor judgment and has resigned.
#9. To: Fred Mertz, A K A Stone (#3)
To: Gatlin He should have shot as many of those well behaved teenagers as he could. That would teach them. /GrandIsland
#10. To: Gatlin (#6)
#11. To: GrandIsland, Fred Mertz, (#9)
Learn how to speak for yourself first. lol
#12. To: A K A Stone (#11)
#13. To: Vinny (#5)
To unholster a weapon isn't to shoot a weapon and good for the cop for resigning.
and good for the cop for resigning.
#14. To: buckeroo (#11)
#15. To: Fred Mertz (#14)
#16. To: nolu chan (#13)
You said, "As an armed civilian I'd have pulled my weapon too." Drawing your weapon in a crowd with real LEO on hand would be exceedingly poor judgment.
#17. To: nolu chan (#13)
Poor judgments had led to a dangerous situation.
#18. To: buckeroo (#17)
Kick the BUM OUT!
#19. To: Vinny, redleghunter (#18)
(Edited)
#20. To: buckeroo (#19)
#21. To: Vinny (#16)
You said, "As an armed civilian I'd have pulled my weapon too." Drawing your weapon in a crowd with real LEO on hand would be exceedingly poor judgment.
For some reason you assumed I'd be among LEOs when I pulled my weapon. I never suggested that.
If I were alone and I thought my life were in danger I would pull my weapon without hesitation.
#22. To: buckeroo (#17)
He let his emotions get away his otherwise objective reasoning skills and decision making. That is NOT the hallmark of a professional.
#23. To: nolu chan (#21)
It was Casebolt's poor judgment
#24. To: nolu chan (#13)
"When the teen was pushed in the back and came forward he took it as a threat."
#25. To: nolu chan (#21)
The LEOs went there to disperse a crowd.
#26. To: Gatlin (#8)
"The cop exercised poor judgment and has resigned." "Probably for the best."
#27. To: Vinny (#23)
"My comment was limited to me being alone & surrounded by thugs who made me fear for my life."
#28. To: misterwhite, Vinny (#27)
"My comment was limited to me being alone & surrounded by thugs who made me fear for my life."
#29. To: Vinny (#23)
Keep on trying to tell me what I was thinking if it makes you feel better, it still won't make it true. Any civilian who pulls his gun during an active LEO encounter would become an instant lead magnet, and that isn't me. My comment was limited to me being alone & surrounded by thugs who made me fear for my life.
#1. To: Gatlin (#0)
#30. To: nolu chan (#29)
#31. To: A K A Stone (#25)
And arrest law breakers.
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
[Home] [Headlines] [Latest Articles] [Latest Comments] [Post] [Mail] [Sign-in] [Setup] [Help] [Register]