politics and politicians
See other politics and politicians Articles
Title: Porn Star Belle Knox Doesn't Know What Libertarianism Is. Neither Do Libertarians.
Source:
New Republic
URL Source: http://www.newrepublic.com/article/ ... g-made-me-libertarian-activist
Published: Jan 30, 2015
Author: Elizabeth Stoker Bruenig
Post Date: 2015-02-01 11:00:34 by Gatlin
Keywords: None
Views: 18474
Comments: 70
Belle Knox, the enterprising Duke undergraduate who ascended to fame last year after her porn career was discovered by nosy classmates, has decided to direct her notoriety to politics. In an interview with Business Insider, Knox expressed her desire to become a libertarian political activist, having already begun work with libertarian campus groups. Knox evidently identifies failed screenwriter Ayn Rand as a personal hero, and supports the Paul dynasty, citing appreciation for both Ron and son Rand. And she attributed her libertarianism to her conservative religious upbringing. “I grew up Catholic, so I grew up in a very, very, conservative background and that, I think, really was kind of the impetus for why I wanted to become a libertarian," she said. "I was always being told to cover up my body and I was always being told to wait until marriage to have sex… That really made me become a libertarian and become a feminist.” Insofar as libertarianism is opposed to almost every feature of Catholic morality, Knox has certainly picked an appropriate politics of rebellion. But Knox, who considers herself “very socially liberal, but … very economically conservative,” may find less agreement among fellow libertarians than she expects. This isn’t because Knox doesn’t have a good sense of what libertarians actually believe; it’s because libertarians themselves do not appear to have a good sense of what libertarianism actually means. Even Ayn Rand detested libertarians, whom she identified with hippies and considered irrational, ineffectual opponents of true freedom. When it comes to polling libertarians, it certainly appears that they aren’t quite as socially liberal as their nomenclature might suggest. In a Pew survey last year, for example, libertarians polled as plenty supportive of police intervention in citizens’ daily lives, showing slightly greater support for stop-and-frisk policies than the general population: A baffling quarter of libertarians surveyed believe homosexuality should be discouraged, and 59 percent were opposed to same-sex marriage in a survey conducted by the Public Religion Research Institute in 2013. Meanwhile, the inexplicable libertarian appreciation for cops frisking people at will is mirrored by an equally bizarre fondness for U.S. military intervention in global affairs. All this while supporting privacy, though perhaps only for themselves, and not for those on the receiving end of police shakedowns and U.S. drones. The only thing libertarians really seem to agree with their label on is the subject of poverty, with 57 percent claiming that government aid to poor people does more harm than good, and 56 percent responding that government regulation of business does more harm than good. If Knox sees libertarianism as a direct counterpoint to Catholic teaching, then this point should be of greatest interest to her, as libertarian disinterest in state efforts to care for the poor really is the antithesis of Catholic teaching on moral states. But insofar as Knox cites attorney Gloria Allred as a hero she would like to emulate, she still doesn’t appear to apprehend what libertarianism actually means: While Allred has spent a career fighting against gender discrimination, this also means she has spent a career levying state power to reverse privately made decisions about employment, pay, and so on. Like it or not, this is the regulation of business. Knox is only 19 years old, so we can hardly fault her for these contradictions. Libertarianism itself has no such excuse. How to explain its adherents' schizophrenia on matters that would, to an observer, seem to have fairly clear-cut libertarian approaches? The problem is that, while libertarians seem to agree that they favor freedom, and appear to be in agreement that freedom is reduced by state intervention, they do not have a positive working definition of what freedom actually is. For Belle Knox, freedom has to do with decriminalized sex work and fair pathways for women in employment—but both of those projects imply a level of proactive government regulation in business. For the jingoistic libertarians polled in the Pew survey, freedom clearly has to do with domestic freedom from criminal activity and threats abroad—but in those cases, some other person or group must be inspected or restrained to achieve such a sense of liberty. Libertarians who oppose government aid to the poor seem to desire freedom from taxes, but have no interest in whether or not the poorest are really free to exercise their rights to human flourishing when they can barely eat. In other words, libertarianism comes with a love of freedom but no consistent sense of what really constitutes freedom or who it is for. For libertarian politicians and their advocates, the sheer slipperiness of the concepts at hand may be a feature rather than a bug, allowing them to cherry-pick policies they personally prefer and shape malleable definitions around them. But for genuine, invested activists like Knox, the evasiveness of the libertarian message should be a red flag.
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
Begin Trace Mode for Comment # 47.
#1. To: Gatlin (#0)
She may be the most attractive female Libertarian in history.
I don’t know. There are a number of libertarian hotties pictured here. If the most prominent reward that Palestinian Martyrs are repeatedly promised are the 72 Dark-Eyed Virgins in Paradise, Oh, I know….a Ron Paul Tee Shirt:
The only reason Palmdale thinks she's attractive is because he knows she puts out. Which, I admit, does add a few points to the scale.
That was funny....
To: misterwhite, Palmdale That was funny.... "Libertarians are diligently plotting to take over the world, (in order) to leave you freeky authoritarians alone".
Libertarianism came into being in 1789. How much longer do you think this will take?
How much longer do you think this will take? Well, if you ever bothered to read our Constitution, you would see it is a very libertarian document. -- In that sense, we already have won. --- Although I have to admit, we're still fighting you authoritarians about the fine points.
There can be no doubt when it comes to substance, you libertarians are living in your own fantasy world, and often that’s quite literally true. You live in your fantasy world, Ayn....I choose to continue to live with reality.
Your reality approves of the war on drug's, swat team type police tactics, and big brother govt, as you just conceded on another thread. --Thanks...
His attacks on Ayn Rand seem to also suggest he thinks hes entitled to another mans property, as that was her main point of contention with the beta males of the world, whom she despised, and they in turn, have a hatred for her for showing all just how small they are.
Ayn Rand Was A Secret Welfare Queen A typical welfare tparasite.
So, what POSITIONS of hers do you disagree with? Attacking the message by slandering the messenger wont work. Cmon, you betas may not have any man parts, but supposedly you make up for it by being clever. What ya got sparky?
What ya got sparky? It appears Dead Culture Watch wants to know if you have any man parts. Maybe it is legitimate. He could be doing scientific research or he could just be dysfunctional.
Are you one of Gatlins personalities that you have on another device? And no, am not curious about his parts, its obvious what his issue is.
You seem to suffer from paranoia and delusions.
Umm, hes tried to get in with five other screen names. Why would suspecting him of logging in on anther device be paranoid?
I'm not privy to that information. Are you a moderator?
So, you just say stuff with no facts to back you up. Gotcha.
I asked a question. Are you a moderator? If not, then you would be saying stuff with no facts to back it up.
#49. To: Otter (#47)
Lol... But I DO have facts on my side. Sucks to be you. But, im sure yer used to that.
Forum B&E. I see The Dishonorable One...is Back Again. *snort*
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
#4. To: Palmdale (#1)
She may be the most attractive female Libertarian in history.
then what is the promise reward for fanatical libertarians in Paradise?
#6. To: Gatlin, Palmdale (#4)
"She may be the most attractive female Libertarian in history."
#15. To: misterwhite, Palmdale (#6)
#17. To: Gatlin, misterwhite, Palmdale ---- This is funny.... (#15)
Gatlin wrote:
#18. To: tpaine (#17)
"Libertarians are diligently plotting to take over the world, (in order) to leave you freeky authoritarians alone".
"Libertarians are diligently plotting to take over the world, (in order) to leave you freeky authoritarians alone".
#19. To: Gatlin, Y'ALL (#18)
Libertarianism came into being in 1789.
#21. To: tpaine (#19)
In that sense, we already have won. --- Although I have to admit, we're still fighting you authoritarians about the fine points.
#22. To: Gatlin, Y'ALL (#21)
---- I choose to continue to live with reality.
#23. To: tpaine Gatlin Beta male (#22)
#24. To: Dead Culture Watch (#23)
Ayn Rand seem to also suggest he thinks hes entitled to another mans property
#27. To: Palmdale (#24)
#28. To: Palmdale (#27)
Cmon, you betas may not have any man parts, but supposedly you make up for it by being clever.
#34. To: Otter (#28)
#39. To: Dead Culture Watch (#34)
#41. To: Otter (#39)
#43. To: Dead Culture Watch (#41)
#46. To: Otter (#43)
I'm not privy to that information. Are you a moderator?
#47. To: Dead Culture Watch (#46)
Umm, hes tried to get in with five other screen names.
Replies to Comment # 47.
#68. To: Otter, Dead Culture Watch, Deckard (#47)
I asked a question. Are you a moderator? If not, then you would be saying stuff with no facts to back it up.
End Trace Mode for Comment # 47.
[Home] [Headlines] [Latest Articles] [Latest Comments] [Post] [Mail] [Sign-in] [Setup] [Help] [Register]