[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

HAVE THEIR RUSE ... TO COME IN AND --- SEARCH THAT SAFE.

The Biden Administration’s Grave Mar-a-Lago Mistake

Walrus that attracted crowds in Oslo fjord euthanised: officials

Yes, Comey did leak classified information

On The Kherson fronT lines ... liTTle sign --- of a Ukrainian offensive

Judge Roy Moore ... VindicaTed --- Wins $8.2 Million DefamaTion LawsuiT

Does Donald Trump Have Jeffrey Epstein’s List of Clients?

DemocraT Megadonor Tells Fox ... ‘Hundreds of Thousands of Americans Have Been Killed by’ --- COVID-19 Vaccines

Fargo School Board ... votes 7-2 ---To no longer reciTe The Pledge of Allegiance

American STasi ... The quesTions remains --- Will winning elecTions be enough To sTop Them?

B.C. Little League cancels God from historic Player Pledge

FBI Raid On Trump Will Make Him A Martyr

FBI raid of Trump home shows that 'equal justice' is a farce

Don’t Be Fooled—the Left Is Gaslighting Again

Democrats suddenly realize open borders are a disaster

As Media Turns on Biden, Don’t Forget Their Role in Creating Current Disaster

STUNNING! 80.0% of In-Person Voters in Maricopa County on Election Day Voted Republican – Only 23.4% Voted Democrat

Judge Strikes Down San Francisco Law Allowing Non-Citizens To Vote

Congress should not legalize marijuana

The Russian Embassy JusT Released A New Video Mocking The WesT ... ‘Time To Move To Russia’ --- Where There’s ‘TradiTional Values - ChrisTianiTy - No Cancel CulTure’

Biden's Title IX rule could mean your daughter's college roommate will be a man

How progressive groups like the ACLU make New York City more dangerous

Why Biden’s claims of US economic strength don’t add up — and Dems are looking to add more poison

Unborn life needs strong national protection

Biden’s border of death

Progressive prosecutors are being ousted, one by one.

Gingrich: "American Tsunami" Will Deliver GOP 5-6 Senate Seats, 40-70 House Seats

The GlobalisT EfforT ... To 'GeT Trump' --- Is Backfiring...Bigly!

Nancy and Paul Pelosi are trading large — with a wealth of hypocrisy

ElecTion Heroes ... Are STopping FraudulenT VoTing --- The PosTal Service Was In On IT

Nolte: Despite January 6 Kangaroo Court, Donald Trump Beats Joe Biden in 7 of 10 Rematch Polls

Mayor Adams’ wake-up on migrant flights

‘Woke’ Corporate Support of BLM Has Deadly Consequences

CNN Director: We Worked To Oust Trump, Use ‘Fear’ To Pass Climate Agenda

Documents show Bill Gates has given $319 million to media outlets to promote his global agenda

Is Liz Cheney toast?

Biden and The Destruction of Wisdom

How Progressive InsaniTy ... Has DesTroyed --- The DemocraTic ParTy

Judge blocks Biden admin's transgender school bathroom rule, athletes

Canada’s ‘expert’ panel recommends the mentally ill be candidates for euthanasia

Cat's reaction when she says “I use she/her pronouns”

The 2022 Referendum on Crime

Here’s Why The Media Don’t Want You To Know About The Massive Protests Going On Around The Globe

Multiple 'Raging' Crises: Failures of 'Progressive' Governance on Full Display This Week

Affluent white female Democrats push away Hispanic and working-class voters

The Global Vaccine NighTmare Has JusT Begun ... 3 billion vaccinaTed people --- have undiagnosed myocardiTis?

Kamala Harris ... Delivers Word Salad --- aT American Rescue Plan Workforce DevelopmenT SummiT

My Democratic abuelos raised me. Here's why I'm now a Republican running for Congress.

Sorry, Democrats: We're Stuck With Joe and Kamala | Opinion

Teaching Library


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

LEFT WING LOONS
See other LEFT WING LOONS Articles

Title: The Stone truth ... Left-wingers --- are boring - mass media produced obombabots
Source: aei.org
URL Source: http://aei.org/article/politics-and ... truth-left-wingers-are-boring/
Published: Dec 7, 2012
Author: Jonah Goldberg
Post Date: 2012-12-07 14:35:08 by BorisY
Keywords: neocoms, neocoms, neocoms
Views: 2852
Comments: 4

The Stone truth: Left-wingers are boring

Oliver Stone’s boomer-nostalgic radicalism is stale and hackneyed.

Jonah Goldberg

National Review Online

December 07, 2012

Reuters

Narrator, director and writer Oliver Stone and writer Peter Kuznick participate in the panel for the Showtime series "Oliver Stone's Secret History of America" during the Television Critics Association winter press tour in Pasadena, Calif., on Jan. 9, 2010

Article Highlights

• When, at long last, will people understand that the left is boring? @JonahNRO

•“If you want to see a true rebel on campus, seek out the pro-life Christians.” @JonahNRO

• Championing economic liberty will tick off your professors, and you can still be a libertine on weekends. @JonahNRO

When, at long last, will people understand that the left is boring?

The question came to mind as I was dipping in and out of Oliver Stone’s miasmic 700-plus-page tome. I’ll never read the whole thing, and not because it’s a left-wing screed full of slimy distortions about the evils of the United States (though that doesn’t help). It’s that it’s boring.

Stone and co-author Peter Kuznick call their book “The Untold History of the United States,” except, again, it isn’t. This story has been told countless times before. As the Daily Beast’s Michael Moynihan notes in a devastating review, Stone and Kuznick offer no new research, and much of the old research they rely on has been rendered moot by more recent discoveries since the Berlin Wall came down.

Still, what vexes me about the book isn’t really the substance. What bothers me is the manufactured rebelliousness, the kitschy nostalgic play-acting of the thing. The 66-year-old Stone can be an original filmmaker, but he is a stale old Red when it comes to politics.

In a sense, that’s fine. We’re all entitled to our opinions, even to commit them to paper in book form. But spare me the radical pose. Among the hilarious blurbs is this encomium from the octogenarian radical Daniel Ellsberg. “Howard [Zinn] would have loved this ‘people’s history’ of the American Empire. It’s compulsive reading: brilliant, a masterpiece!”

Ellsberg is right about one thing: The late Howard Zinn, a wildly left-wing historian, probably would have loved it — in no small part because he wrote so much of it already in his decades-old and endlessly recycled A People’s History of the United States.

Zinn’s work, along with Noam Chomsky’s, Michael Moore’s, and, now, Stone’s, is seen as boldly transgressive and subversive. Intellectually, there’s some truth to that of course. If you’re dedicated to subverting the free-enterprise system and traditional patriotism, then you’re a subversive.

I guess what bothers me is the whole pretense that these people are bravely speaking truth to power in some way. Zinn has been on college syllabi for decades. Moore wins Academy Awards and is treated like royalty by the Democratic party (he sat in Jimmy Carter’s suite at the 2004 Democratic convention). Chomsky has been a fixture on the campus paid-lecture circuit since before I was born.

According to investigative reporter Peter Schweizer, Chomsky, the avowed hater of capitalism, set up a special trust to hide his millions in personal wealth from the taxman. This from the guy who inveighs against a tax code full of “complicated devices for ensuring that the poor — like 80 percent of the population — pay off the rich.”

Stone, a notorious booster of Cuban socialism, owns numerous properties around the world. During an interview at his Santa Barbara, Calif, Spanish colonial villa, Architectural Digest asked about the contradiction between his anti-capitalist schtick and his lifestyle, and he replied that he wouldn’t fall for the guilt trip. “That’s a Western Christian trip.”

The bowel-stewing hypocrisy notwithstanding, what’s amazing is how the same dreck is recycled as new, fresh, and courageous. Charles Beard’s An Economic Interpretation of the U.S. Constitution will be 100 years old next year. Its attack on the Founders as greedy white men was wrong then, but at least it was relatively original. Today, college kids regurgitate the same nonsense — and professors applaud their rebelliousness. Except what or whom are they rebelling against? Not the faculty or the administration.

Hackneyed left-wingery is not only treated with respect on campuses (though most mainstream academics aren’t as left-wing as Zinn or Stone), it is repackaged daily by Hollywood and celebrated by the mainstream media.

The self-styled rebels of Occupy Wall Street received overwhelmingly positive coverage in the mainstream media in no small part because the liberal press thinks authentic political expression for young people must be left-wing. The regurgitation of hackneyed ’60s slogans pleasing to the ears of aging, nostalgia-besotted baby boomers elicits squeals of delight. Meanwhile, tea-party protests were greeted as dangerous, odd, and deserving of hostile journalistic scrutiny.

And yet the kitsch of leftism still works its magic. In huge numbers, young people think they’re rebelling when all they’re doing is playing their assigned part and lending energy and, often, votes to a stale, regimented form of statist liberalism that often disappoints and never satisfies.

I don’t expect young people to become conservatives, though if you want to see a true rebel on campus, seek out the pro-life Christians. But is libertarianism really too much to ask? Championing economic liberty will tick off your professors, and you can still be a libertine on weekends. And if you get rich, you won’t be a hypocrite for defending your villa.

— Jonah Goldberg is editor-at-large of National Review Online and a visiting fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. You can write to him by e-mail at JonahsColumn@aol.com, or via Twitter @JonahNRO. © 2012 Tribune Media Services, Inc.


Poster Comment:

machine manufactured out of a tattoo - 3rd world jewelry jungle freak shop

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

Begin Trace Mode for Comment # 3.

#2. To: BorisY (#0)

Children are going to learn.

They may not learn what you want them to....;}

Children should be taught instead to Question Authority.

AEI wants the War of 9/11 to go on forever, for instance.

Stone doesn't go far enough. Like this:

FDR had broken the Japanese and German Naval Codes before Pearl Harbor.

Read Pearl Harbor Countdown: Admiral James O. Richardson by ... www.freado.com/read/.../p...dmiral-james-o-richardson Pearl Harbor Countdown: Admiral James O. Richardson "Why was the American Pacific fleet anchored at Pearl Harbor on the date of infamy? Why did President ...

Carlin is right. It’s all make-believe, religion, the history we’re taught, the value of money. Question everything and look for the inconsistencies and think about them. There are no rights. Power makes rights and we don’t have any folks we gave them away for security and because we’re too lazy to think and too scared to act.

mcgowanjm  posted on  2012-12-08   9:18:22 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


#3. To: mcgowanjm (#2)

Billy Mitchell in honolulu - 1924 ... said a fleet of japanese air craft carriers --- were going to destroy pearl harbor !

Some people ... can see the future --- some people can't see the past - present !

BorisY  posted on  2012-12-08   18:15:00 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


Replies to Comment # 3.

#4. To: BorisY (#3)

1924!!!!!!!

1940:

US breaks Japanese Naval Code.

Rain East

mcgowanjm  posted on  2012-12-09 09:04:54 ET  Reply   Untrace   Trace   Private Reply  


End Trace Mode for Comment # 3.

TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com