Opinions/Editorials
See other Opinions/Editorials Articles
Title: Republicans to the Unemployed: You're Lazy
Source:
Politics Daily
URL Source: http://www.politicsdaily.com/2010/0 ... -to-the-unemployed-youre-lazy/
Published: Jun 25, 2010
Author: Donna Trussell
Post Date: 2010-06-25 11:56:39 by Brian S
Keywords: None
Views: 1062
Comments: 2
Salt, meet wound. Wound being unemployment, and salt being the suggestion that the worst economy since the Great Depression was created by its powerless victims -- the jobless.
Republicans, do tell: If so many jobs are ripe for plucking, explain the five applicants for every job. (Down from six a few months ago. Oh joy.)
Why would anyone believe unemployment is voluntary when there is so much evidence to the contrary? The answer is surprisingly simple: Because that belief makes them feel good.
Life is not fair, we learned in childhood. Apparently we never got over it. The psychology term "just-world phenomenon" has been around for only half a century, but the practice of assuming people get what they deserve is not new. You can find examples in the poetry of Robert Browning and the Bible. 
And in politics. A shrewd politician can take advantage of the just-world fallacy, defined as:
Many a cancer survivor has encountered the just-world theory firsthand. I myself am a survivor, and from my own experience, I can recreate a typical conversation. It goes something like this: Does cancer run in your family? Were you under a lot of stress before your diagnosis? Do you think the years you lived in Houston had anything to do with it? Etc.
If you want to make your friend happy, you should answer yes, yes, and yes. That's because 1) she's not related to you, 2) she meditates every day, and 3) she never lived in Houston. Therefore she will not get cancer. She can then exile you to the land of "the other" and all is right with the world again.
So maybe there's no science proving self-assurance wards off cancer any better than a voodoo incantation. Facts, schmacts! Feeling is what counts. She feels safer. If you feel worse, that's your tough luck. Which you already have, obviously. In abundance. Due to some failure on your part.
Politicians love a just world, especially conservatives. Take Sharron Angle, Republican candidate for senator of Nevada in the 2010 election.
Angle's message has all the subtlety of a car-lot sales pitch. Her handlers have scrubbed her Web site, but thanks to technology, we have her words archived for all eternity. She can run (watch Angle trot away from reporter Nathan Baca as he asks what she meant by "Second Amendment remedy" to incumbent Senator Harry Reid), but she can't hide.
During a speech, Angle was recorded saying, "We did those things growing up that Americans don't do. We cleaned bathrooms and made beds. Swept floors. Did laundry." But now, according to Angle, Americans won't do those jobs, and unemployment benefits, specifically Harry Reid's vote to extend them, are to blame.
Angle caught some flack for that statement, so a week later she clarified:
Sharron Sharron Sharron. Girl, I gotta ask: Who taught you how to backpedal? Cuz you suck at it. You're supposed to neutralize your first comment, not reinforce it. If you can't backpedal worth a damn, I predict your career in politics will be short and not at all sweet.
Ms. Angle continued:
So the problem today is not too few jobs. The problem is unemployment benefits are too generous. How do you get people to work if they're not starving and desperate? (I'll bet slaveholders in the old South used to chaw tobacco over just such an issue.)
Here's a chart of real wages and benefits (adjusted for inflation) from the 1960s to 2004. In 1971 average weekly wages were about $331. Some 30 years later the average wage had dropped to $277. And that was 2004, prior to the current recession, which has further decimated the average worker's earnings.
Where's the Republican outrage on the minimum wage losing buying power? On the off-shoring of good jobs? On the huge increases in the cost of health care and college tuition? Instead of eliminating the few safety nets we possess, why not reverse course on policies that have, for decades, chipped away at the middle class in favor of banks, big business and the wealthy?
Not likely. It's easier to assume losers never really wanted to win in the first place. Or didn't deserve to win.
Which brings us back to the just-world theory. Says the Markula Center for Applied Ethics:
Hear ye, Republicans! The unemployed are not lazy. It's you who are intellectually lazy. Or -- even worse -- you understand. You know that most of the people losing jobs and homes in these terrible times did nothing wrong whatsoever. You simply don't care.
(1 image)
Post Comment Private Reply Ignore Thread
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
Begin Trace Mode for Comment # 1.
#1. To: Brian S (#0)
Could they handle this election cycle any more moronically?
There are no replies to Comment # 1. End Trace Mode for Comment # 1.
Top • Page Up • Full Thread • Page Down • Bottom/Latest
Replies to Comment # 1.
[Home] [Headlines] [Latest Articles] [Latest Comments] [Post] [Mail] [Sign-in] [Setup] [Help] [Register]