Should I stay or should I go now? That question, posed by the eminent political philosophers known as the Clash, is one that confronts any Republican with a glimmer of conscience. You used to belong to a conservative party with a white-nationalist fringe. Now its a white-nationalist party with a conservative fringe. If youre part of that fringe, what should you do? Veteran strategist Steve Schmidt, who ran John McCains 2008 presidential campaign, is the latest Republican to say no more. Recently he issued an anguished Twitter post: 29 years and nine months ago I registered to vote and became a member of the Republican Party which was founded in 1854 to oppose slavery and stand for the dignity of human life, he wrote. Today I renounce my membership in the Republican Party. It is fully the party of Trump.
Schmidt follows in the illustrious footsteps of Post columnist George F. Will, former senator Gordon Humphrey, former representative (and Post columnist) Joe Scarborough, Reagan and Bush (both) aide Peter Wehner, and other Republicans who have left the party. Im with them. After a lifetime as a Republican, I re-registered as an independent on the day after Donald Trumps election.
Explaining my decision, I noted that Trumpkins want to transform the GOP into a European-style nationalist party that opposes cuts in entitlement programs, believes in deportation of undocumented immigrants, white identity politics, protectionism and isolationism backed by hyper-macho threats to bomb the living daylights out of anyone who messes with us. I still hoped then that traditional conservatives might eventually prevail, but, I wrote, I can no longer support a party that doesnt know what it stands for and that in fact may stand for positions that I find repugnant.
I am more convinced than ever that I made the right decision. The transformation I feared has taken place. Just look at the reaction to President Trumps barbarous policy of taking children away from their parents as punishment for the misdemeanor offense of illegally entering the country. While two-thirds of Americans disapproved of this state-sanctioned child abuse, forcing the president to back down, a majority of Republicans approved. If Trump announced he were going to spit-roast immigrant kids and eat them on national TV (apologies to Jonathan Swift), most Republicans probably would approve of that, too. The entire Republican platform can now be reduced to three words: whatever Trump says.
And yet there are still principled #NeverTrump conservatives such as Tom Nichols and Bill Kristol who are staying in the party. And they have a good case to make. Kristol, for one, balks at giving up the Republican party to the forces of nativism, vulgar populism, and authoritarianism. As he notes, It would be bad for the country if one of our two major parties went in this direction.