[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Does Marijuana Increase the Risk of Vehicle Crashes?

Youtube Gay Screen - Flag YouTube Comes Out- Youtube goes Gay

Man Jailed After Drywall Powder Mistaken For Cocaine

Clarence Thomas: ‘Improbable’ that 2nd Amendment Only Protects Carrying a Gun in Your Home

Yazidi sex slave unwittingly ATE her one-year-old son after ISIS fanatics COOKED the child and served it with rice after starving her for three days, Iraqi MP claims

Justices Thomas and Gorsuch: Supreme Court Should Take More Second Amendment Cases

After Getting Busted for Bombing Syria Based On a Lie, Trump Doubles Down … Threatens to Bomb Syria Even Harder Based On Same BS

New Study Finds Marijuana Users Are Happier And More Successful In Life

“I Could Kill You!” Cop Pins Teen Down, Chokes Him for Running Through His Grass

Cops Brag About Harassing Homeless Man Fixing Bikes for Money, So Facebook Destroyed Them

The Jewish and The Chinese Pilots

Tucson Court to Hear Extradition of Woman Accused of Feeding her Mother

Liberal Nightmares Come True as Gorsuch Begins to Cast SCOTUS Votes

Why Is Donald Trump Enabling Russian Espionage in America?

Fmr. Attorney General Lynch Could Face 5-10 Years in Prison

Project Veritas Undercover Investigation: CNN Producer Admits Network Hyping ‘Mostly Bullsh*t’ Trump-Russia Scandal for ‘Ratings’

Runaway roofers who removed the wrong roof tracked down by St. Louis neighbors

The Washington Post and Gary Webb

Smoking Marijuana Really Can Ruin Your Life

Eugenics and Abortion

I know who the Texas killing field murderer is

Who will speak for the children about impact of marijuana?

University of Arizona Says They Have No Relationship with Visiting Scholar Who Identifies as a Hippo

'Cool story bro': Twitter mocks Trump's proud claim that his approval ratings are higher than Obama's

Charlie Sheen reveals he’s behind sale of Babe Ruth’s 1927 World Series ring, 1919 contract

Killer whales suspects in Cape shark killings

SCOTUS Lets Ruling Stand Protecting Second Amendment Rights Following Non-Serious Misdemeanors

Supreme Court backs church in major religious rights case that will lift an outright ban on state funding

Trump Can Win Travel Ban Case at Supreme Court Simply by Enforcing It

Supreme Court Orders States to List Same-Sex Parents on Birth Certificates; Gorsuch Dissents

Federal ‘OPT’ Program Rewards Companies For Hiring 330,000 Foreign College Grads in 2016

Asylum seekers in Canada who fled Trump now trapped in legal limbo

......Liberal Lawyer Gloria Allred Being Sued for FRAUD

President Trump Ends Long Tradition of Celebrating Ramadan in White House

Nebraska Dem official caught on audio: I’m ‘glad’ Scalise was shot, ‘I wish he was f*****g dead’

MARIJUANA AND SUICIDE: A GROWING RISK FOR OUR YOUTH

These mothers of suicides don’t think marijuana is harmless

People Who Smoke Weed Every Day Have More Suicidal Thoughts, Study Says

MARIJUANA USE IS LINKED TO INCREASED SUICIDE RISK

Hacker collective Anonymous releases video claiming that NASA is on the verge of announcing alien life

UN Official: We Should Make Every Effort To Depopulate The Planet

Driver in crash that killed Midview student had marijuana in his system

Insurance study ties legal pot to boost in car crash claims

(Free Republic Archived Retro Thread from 2002): Sneakypete Schools Freepers and Nopardons on Reality Of Bush Family As Statists/RINOs (and NOT "conservative")

Texas mom arrested after children die in hot car

How the CIA Turned Us onto LSD and Heroin: Secrets of America's War on Drugs

Supreme Court limits rights of property owners

Health Care Debate Exposed as a Fraud, Dems and Reps Just United to do Big Pharma's Bidding

The US Criminal “Justice System” is Devoid of Justice

How the Government Conditions Citizens to Obey


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

politics and politicians
See other politics and politicians Articles

Title: Libertarian case for open borders
Source: Ope Bborders Info - Libertarian
URL Source: https://openborders.info/libertarian/
Published: Mar 17, 2017
Author: Staff
Post Date: 2017-03-17 10:09:27 by Gatlin
Keywords: None
Views: 148
Comments: 5

This page outlines a case for open borders based on libertarian perspectives, but it should be read with two important caveats. First, the libertarian principles invoked in these arguments have appeal to many non- libertarians, and therefore this case can be convincing to many non-libertarians. Second, a number of self-identified libertarians reject the libertarian case for open borders. For more, see the moral counter- case page. For the views of prominent libertarians on immigration, see our page libertarians’ views of immigration.

As with all our top-level pages, please treat this page only as a starting point in exploring the ethics of the open borders question. To dig deeper, follow and read the links.

TL;DR

  • Libertarianism is a moral and political philosophy that argues in favor of a strong presumption of letting people engage freely in mutually consensual activity and on minimizing coercion in society. In the modern political context, libertarians generally focus on government-enforced and government-facilitated coercion.
  • The right to migrate can be considered a corollary of the libertarian view that people should be free to do what they please (individually or collectively) unless it violates the rights of others.
  • Libertarians’ view of obligations to strangers has two core premises. First, no obligations to strangers beyond respecting their rights. Second, a very strong obligation to respect their rights. Together, these premises argue in favor of not letting concerns about harms to fellow nationals be a justification for opposing free migration.
  • Although libertarian theory does not really offer a case against free migration, libertarians have argued against free migration on consequentialist grounds (in terms of the detrimental effects that an open borders policy would have on moving towards or maintaining a libertarian society) as well as via the anarcho-capitalist counterfactual.
  • Even many libertarians who do support freer migration do not consider freedom of migration a high-priority issue.

What is libertarianism, and what does it have to do with migration policy?

Libertarianism is a moral and political philosophy that argues in favor of a strong presumption of letting people engage freely in mutually consensual activity and on minimizing coercion in society. In the modern political context, libertarians generally focus on government-enforced and government-facilitated coercion.

Libertarians: Diligently plotting to take over the world and leave you 
alone

Meme depicting the idea of libertarianism. Source What Libertarianism isn’t… by Eric Peters Autos

Libertarianism, as a whole political philosophy, is not very popular. However, basic libertarian ideas are reflected in many people’s moral intuitions (see, for instance, the forced organ donation hypothetical). The idea that people should be free to do what they want unless there is strong evidence that their actions harm others is generally accepted, though non-libertarians set different bars regarding the degree of harm or the strength of evidence needed. Thus, people with partial libertarian sympathies should still find the libertarian case for open borders at least somewhat convincing, though they may rely more on an evaluation of the empirical conseqeunces before coming to a conclusion.

Check out What is Libertarianism? on the libertarianism.org website, or the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on libertarianism.

Right to migrate

The right to migrate can be considered a corollary of the libertarian view that people should be free to do what they please (individually or collectively) unless it violates the rights of others. Migration is just one of many things that people should be free to do.

A more moderate version: restrictions of the right to migrate are only moral if there is clear evidence of very bad consequences. We might call this moderate version a presumptive right to migrate.

Obligations to strangers

Libertarians’ view of obligations to strangers has two core premises. First, one does not have positive obligations to strangers beyond respecting their rights. In other words, it is not my duty to help feed, clothe, and pay a stranger. On the other hand, we do have strong obligations to not infringe on people’s freedom unless there are strong reasons to do so.

Applying the same logic to the government of a nation-state or region, the said government owes no obligations to potential immigrants. But it does not have the authority to arbitrarily restrict their entry. Thus, even if the harms to immigrant-receiving countries are serious, they do not overcome the presumption in favor of the right to migrate.

A more moderate relaxation of this view might concede the existence of some positive obligations, including obligations to citizens, residents, potential immigrants, and others, but still argue that these obligations do not override the moral obligation to not interfere with people’s free movement.

Self-ownership versus state ownership

The self-ownership versus state ownership argument, while again of a distinctively libertarian flavor, has been employed by many non-libertarians. The argument is generally deployed to counter concerns about harms to immigrant-sending countries (such as brain drain and delay of political reform). The argument is that even if these harms are serious, they do not override the presumption in favor of the right to migrate. This is because people own themselves (the self-ownership principle) and are not owned by the state where they were born.

Self-ownership can also be used as a basis for the right to invite, countering the use of collective property rights to justify immigration restrictions.

Hypotheticals to illuminate the libertarian case

See more hypotheticals here.

Libertarian views and concerns related to immigration

While libertarian theory per se does not offer strong grounds to oppose open borders, libertarians have endorsed a number of arguments against open borders, including the following:

See also our page on libertarians’ views of immigration.

Blog posts and articles

(1 image)

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: Gatlin (#0)

A K A Stone  posted on  2017-03-17   10:27:27 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: Gatlin (#0)

Get rid of the welfare state, and end the Islamic war on civilization, and I am with you.

vikingisaverb  posted on  2017-03-18   0:59:07 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#3. To: vikingisaverb (#2)

welcome back ...

It has been a while ...

Gatlin  posted on  2017-03-18   1:23:12 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#4. To: Gatlin (#3)

welcome back ...

It has been a while ..

I have been lurking. Thanks for the WB.

vikingisaverb  posted on  2017-03-18   1:36:15 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#5. To: vikingisaverb (#4)

Nice to see you....stick around.

Gatlin  posted on  2017-03-18   1:39:42 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com