[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Citizen Mars

Rand Paul Reluctantly Defends Trump from Hewitt’s ‘Gotcha’ Questions

NBC’s Nightly News Willing To Exploit A Dead Child To Promote The Invasion Of Europe

Europe’s ‘Core Value’ of Open Borders Enables Illegal Alien Invasion

NYT Editorial Board Complains That Australia Is “Ruthlessly Effective” at Not Being Overrun

"Lady of the Left" Gloats on Gay Marriage

Revealed: How the five wealthiest Gulf Nations have so far refused to take a single Syrian refugee

11-year-old shoots and kills home intruder in north St. Louis County

FBI, DEA and others will now have to get a warrant to use stingrays

Rupert Murdoch’s Ex-Security Chief Blows the Whistle

Solicitation for “role-players” confirms DoD training in Boston on heels of JADE HELM 15

Martin Armstrong Warns: The #1 Terrorist Group Is You, Domestic Citizens

Blending in, Jade Helm Style: Fake Rental Trucks Reveal Hidden Spy Rooms

Do Cops’ Lives Matter to Obama?

BUSTED: Videos of Virginia Reporter Shooting Hoax Were Separate Takes!

Because they Lack Crucial Training, These Cops Severely Beat a Blind Autistic Teen Unconscious Read

No Black Lives Do Not Matter

Trump Praises His Sister, a Pro-Abortion Extremist Judge

The Deciding Vote for Obama’s Iran Deal Was Bob Corker, Not Barbara Mikulski

Cop who claimed he was targeted by gunman fabricated story, police say

Man Arrested for Mocking Mayor on Twitter Wins Big in Civil Suit

Texas teen fatally shoots himself while taking selfie[Darwin Award]

What did Mahatma Gandhi think of black people?

The GOPÂ’s Loyalty Pledge Targeting Trump Is Ridiculous. HereÂ’s A Better Idea.

DHS grants temporary legal status to Yemeni citizens

Tom Brady WINS

France confirms wing part found on Reunion is from MH370

Europe Pursues ‘Great Replacement’ via Immigration

Where Should Syrian Refugees Settle?

DNC Hires Illegal And Brags About It; What Will GOP Do?

Culture Trumps Economics, cont.

Refugees threaten Europe's Christian roots, says Hungary's Orban

Psychoanalyzing Trump: How To Write A NEW YORK TIMES Op-Ed In Three Easy Steps!

The 2030 Agenda: This Month the UN Launches a Blueprint for a New World Order with the Help of the Pope

"War on Cops" Debunked: Police Killings Lower Since Last Year, in Steady Decline for 3 Decades

A Simple Solution to the Arab Migrant Crisis: Cancel 2022 World Cup in Qatar

Arby’s Employee Says Unfortunate Joke Not Denial Of Service To Officer

Hot Air exclusive: Scott Walker speaks out on cop murders and American leadership

This Cop Was Suspended for Beating Multiple People, 7 years and $600K Later He’s Still on Vacation

EU draws up emergency plan to relocate 160,000 stranded refugees across the continent (but Britain will take ZERO)

Homicide suspected in 'clearly suspicious' death of off-duty Texas officer: Police

The Clintons’ plan to counterattack Obama

Exposed! Libya Security Briefs, Algeria Hostage Info & More — Hacker Threatens To Sell Hillary Clinton’s ENTIRE UNRELEASED Private Emails For $500K

VIDEO: Entire Family Arrested, Child Taken by CPS, for Refusing Unlawful Search at Checkpoint

Ukraine is still at war, and its bloodiest battle isn't over

King Arthur? No, the legendary leader was just a Scottish general who lived most of his life in Strathclyde

CARLY FIORINAÂ’S Secret Deals with Iran While CEO of Hewlett Packard

Confirmed: US to “Use” Al Qaeda to Take Syria

The Rise Of The Inhumanes (Even Hitler Would Be Proud)

Bryan Pagliano, Clinton’s Former Tech Staffer, Will Plead The Fifth In Email Investigation


Status: Not Logged In; Sign In

Opinions/Editorials
See other Opinions/Editorials Articles

Title: Buchanan: A Decade Of War -- For What?
Source: Human Events
URL Source: http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=51281
Published: May 4, 2012
Author: Patrick J Buchanan
Post Date: 2012-05-04 12:28:05 by Brian S
Keywords: None
Views: 611
Comments: 2

"My fellow Americans, we have traveled through more than a decade under the dark cloud of war," said Barack Obama from Bagram Air Base.

"Here in the predawn darkness, we can see the light of a new day on the horizon. The Iraq War is over. The number of troops in harm's way has been cut in half, and more will be coming home. ... The time of war began in Afghanistan, and this is where it will end."

Interesting comment, that last.

If "the time of war" is at an end, does that rule out U.S. military action in Syria or war on Iran?

Setting aside the 14,000-mile round trip to Afghanistan to do an end zone dance on the anniversary of Seal Team Six's dispatch of Osama bin Laden, Obama seems to have boxed in his Republican rivals.

His assurance that our wars are ending and our troops are coming home reflects the national will. And his partnership agreement with President Hamid Karzai and pledge that a U.S. force will remain to train the Afghan army and prevent al-Qaida's return inoculates him against the charge that he is cutting and running.

Yet The New York Times was disappointed.

Obama had not said how the United States is to train the Afghan army to defeat the Taliban by 2014, nor how we can get Karzai to deal with the pervasive corruption and incompetence of his government.

Nor did Obama say how we can be certain al-Qaida will not return when we depart.

The Times misses the point.

This speech was not designed to lay out a U.S. strategy for the next 12 years, but to get Barack Obama past the post in November.

And for that objective, the speech works.

No one knows what will happen when 23,000 more U.S. troops come home by Sept. 30, and all combat troops are out in 2014. The odds are that, after a "decent interval," like the one in Vietnam from 1973 to 1975, the Taliban will return to take vengeance on all who abandoned them, and Afghanistan will come again to resemble the land we invaded a decade ago.

Why is this probable?

First, because the Taliban have shown themselves to be, though fewer in number, a superior fighting force to the Afghan army. They have not needed foreigners to motivate, train, advise or lead them.

Nor have they needed foreign money to fight. Yet they have battled the best army in the world for a decade and repeatedly sacrificed their lives in suicide attacks.

How many Afghans on our side have launched suicide attacks?

Second, the Taliban are rooted in the Pashtun, the largest tribal group in Afghanistan, which constitutes half the population and is concentrated in the crucial south and east.

Third, they have a secure sanctuary in Pakistan.

Fourth, because, as we saw with the hysterical reaction to what U.S. troops thought was the routine burning of desecrated Qurans, Islam is the most powerful cultural and social force in the country. And the Taliban are the most deeply rooted in that faith.

Fifth, because nationalism is the most potent political current roiling nations from the Maghreb to Middle East to South Asia. And the Taliban have the causalities and credentials to prove they will fight forever to free their country of foreign influence.

A majority of Afghans surely wish the Taliban would not return, given the savagery of their previous rule and the desire of the Afghan people to be free to live their own lives according to their own interpretation of their faith.

Yet the Taliban have shown themselves willing to persist against huge odds, to fight and die in considerable numbers for the kind of country they wish to live in -- and the kind of regime they wish to live under.

Our allies have not remotely matched their zeal.

"A small body of determined spirits fired by an unquenchable faith in their mission can alter the course of history," said Mohandas Gandhi.

So, after a decade of war in Afghanistan, what have we accomplished, and at what cost? Some 2,000 U.S. dead, 16,000 wounded, hundreds of billions sunk, scores of thousands of Afghan dead. Al-Qaida was driven out a decade ago but is now in Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, North Africa and Iraq.

The Taliban are gone from Kabul but may be coming back. And our hope of preserving what success we have had rests with Hamid Karzai.

"America has no designs beyond an end to al-Qaida safe havens," said Obama in Bagram. "Our goal is not to build a country in America's image, or to eradicate every vestige of the Taliban."

But if those are our goals, had we not achieved them all by early 2002? What, then, were we fighting for -- these 10 years?

If we had to do it all over again, would we?

The nation now seems not to think so. And the nation is right.

Post Comment   Private Reply   Ignore Thread  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

#1. To: Brian S (#0)

But if those are our goals, had we not achieved them all by early 2002? What, then, were we fighting for -- these 10 years?

Paul Craig Roberts explains exactly what we were fighting for.

If we had to do it all over again, would we?

Hell yeah! Republicans and Democrats throughout the District of Criminals made a killing! What's a few thousand dead GI's and hundreds of thousands of "furriners?"

Fibr Dog  posted on  2012-05-04   16:30:18 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


#2. To: Brian S (#0)

What do you think of Pat Buchanans article.

You being a Buchanan supporter don't you fee like a turn coat supporting Obama and the destruction of our nation?

Buchanan and Obama are light years apart.

A K A Stone  posted on  2012-05-04   21:49:24 ET  Reply   Trace   Private Reply  


TopPage UpFull ThreadPage DownBottom/Latest

[Home]  [Headlines]  [Latest Articles]  [Latest Comments]  [Post]  [Mail]  [Sign-in]  [Setup]  [Help]  [Register] 

Please report web page problems, questions and comments to webmaster@libertysflame.com